I think the nrl would prioritise Luke lauliii . Ones good prospect , the other is the best winger in his Age group .
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
Tiger-ferret
Well-known member
That’s fair as far as type of player in a squad etc. I would personally pay 350. He offers way more than tamou did at that price if my memory serves me correct.
Tom Shines
Well-known member
Ok .., fair enough…
Nothing personal at all against Twal… he has played more than a 100 first grade for the club and I respect the hell out of that…
I just want more… like I said earlier I’m tired of the Tigers just making up the numbers in this competition …look at the Broncos … how we ever going to compete against that team? they now have a better team then Penrith in my opinion who as we know have won something like 80 percent of their games the past 4 years and one of the best teams in 50 years …
There is an arms race going on …Teams like the Warriors and the Knights taking big strides.., and you can bet that Souths and the Roosters will be back..
This team needs to take a quantum leap…
End rant …
earl
Well-known member
I agree. I like Twal but I think we need to be really careful about how we manage our cap. We can't spend big on players who don't push the needle. Twal to me sounds like he is overpaid.
I can't see us purchasing stars so we need to develop them. I don't want us to develop players and then see them go elsewhere for more dollars.
balmain boy
Well-known member
So does that suggest Twal will in fact be on 680k next season, if salaries are rising with the cap?
balmain boy
Well-known member
He was, for a few months. So we got good value out of him this year.
I wonder how often a player has gone from development contract to NRL contract on $125k to NRL contract on $700k in under a year. I'd guess no club has ever thrown contracts around like this before. It smacks of a club that manages the cap poorly.
I didn't think all salaries were rising with the cap (correct me if I'm wrong).
Some players though are signing contracts with ratchet clauses that guarantees their salary is based on its respective percentage of the salary cap, rather than a fixed monetary value.
Tom Shines
Well-known member
balmain boy
Well-known member
It's not guaranteed, but i believe many NRL contracts included a clause that sees the contract rise with any equivalent rise in the cap. So a player isn't disadvantaged by signing a long term contract while CBA negotiations were ongoing. If they signed a contract 6 months earlier is it fair that they get paid 30% less than someone who signed later? Players shouldn't have to take short term deals in order to benefit from cap increases either.
But no i'm not an agent or player so i'm not 100% sure of the exact dynamics used in the NRL contracts.
balmain boy
Well-known member
He's not going to 1.4 million. He may get 1 million at the absolute max.
And he's proven himself over a number of years, played origin and in a grand final so he's earned his pay rise. We're so crap we just throw money and long term deals at players and just pray it doesn't bite us in a few years time (it usually does, but i'm fairly confident this contract will be better value than most of our previous big contracts).
Tom Shines
Well-known member
Time will tell…
Lee’s buddies in the media like Slothfield are saying he will get $1.6m .., so I thought I was being conservative …
They are paying Haas $1.2 m so you can’t say with a straight face they will pay Walsh less.,
‘Unheard of money‘: Walsh to command $1m-plus payrise as Broncos’ Haas headache worsens
‘Unheard of money‘: Walsh to command $1m-plus payrise as Broncos’ Haas headache worsens
www.foxsports.com.au
Now you are right …our boy is not Reece Walsh… but I’m willing to think he might be half as good…
Like I said,,, if Bula doesn’t live up to the deal, then I’ll be the first one here complaining about it … but I’ll wait and see
BlackWhiteGold
Well-known member
Broncos have developed players with elite attributes, both physical & skill, and have taken those attributes (speed, strength, power, cardio, ball skills) to new levels. Walsh, Cobbo, Staggs, Fansworth, Mam, Haas, Riki, Flegler & Carrigan provide an amazing combination of attributes. With shrewd recruitment in Reynolds & Capewell, they have rocketed up the ladder the past 4 seasons.
We are not going to replicate that by purely recruitment. We need to develop the likes of Laulilii brothers, Faagutu, Galvin, Mason, Large brothers, Makasini, Willett and take the likes of Stef, Pole, Matamua, Fainu brothers, Blore, T'oa & Bula to whole new levels to get us anywhere near the top 4.
Morris is a good man to have on board to help Benji & Api with this.
upthetigers
Well-known member
Bit harsh. He had a great 2023 season. Bloke fully deserves to be extended when does he miss a tackle? His carries have been better too.
tigertragic
Well-known member
Time will tell…
Lee’s buddies in the media like Slothfield are saying he will get $1.6m .., so I thought I was being conservative …
They are paying Haas $1.2 m so you can’t say with a straight face they will pay Walsh less.,
‘Unheard of money‘: Walsh to command $1m-plus payrise as Broncos’ Haas headache worsens
‘Unheard of money‘: Walsh to command $1m-plus payrise as Broncos’ Haas headache worsens
Now you are right …our boy is not Reece Walsh… but I’m willing to think he might be half as good…
Like I said,,, if Bula doesn’t live up to the deal, then I’ll be the first one here complaining about it … but I’ll wait and see
I think the whole discussion moving forward is that he should anticipate the tigers offer will be less than his on now.
Other clubs would need to out bid whatever the tigers offer is
There is no doubt in the world Reece Walsh would have numerous clubs prepared to pay him 1.4 million per season.
Regardless it’s near certain he’ll be staying with the Broncos and good luck to them both.
As for Bula, I love the way the kid has risen through our grades to become a player the whole competition is talking about.
We had to keep him at all costs, so if it took 700k to keep him, then so be it.
I’ve long said I still have doubts he has the playmaking skills or sheer speed to make an elite fullback, but geez I hope I’m wrong.
Worst case scenario if he doesn’t work out as planned at fullback, I think he would make a brilliant centre regardless.
Tom Shines
Well-known member
We are going down the juniors path, but I’m also hoping they buy some players .. in particular a Center and Winger ASAP…like this offseason to play in March 2024 … although re- signing Staines can count as the winger …
Lot of pressure on these young players … They need coaching and leadership to develop … I would like to see more confidence and cockiness in some of these guys …,look at the Broncos and Penrith…. it concerns me that all the young guys know is being belted …
It is a huge risk the Club is taking but it’s all we got so let’s hope for the best …
I reckon if we can sign Xavier Savage who is no longer a high priority at the Raiders, despite being paid a starting players salary.
Add a hard running tackle busting edge forward in Josh Curran.
Re-sign the valuable Charlie Staines and Alex Seyfarth.
To fit them in offload the ageing David Nofoaluma, offload the disappointing Asu Kepaoa and one or two others.
We would have a team capable of scoring over 20 pints per game without even trying.
Tom Shines
Well-known member
Im loving those offloads … they need to move on at least 4 Im hoping …I thought they would have moved on some by now …there are a couple ( Kepaoa is one) who I thought they could just cut and eat their salary … so I wonder why they haven’t done so by now
Nofo unfortunately wont be moved on … but I hope he introduces himself to the NSW Cup coach over the summer…as he will getting to spend a bit of time with him next year ..
Odessa
Well-known member
Sounds like a young Bennett
