Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
Nah. Not every signing has to result in an early release.
Tucker
Well-known member
He has been in our system for a while now and done very little that’s eye catching. For a supposed talent pinched from Union, that’s not good enough.
king_sirro
Well-known member
Going off last season he is easily placed to start the year. Yes he had his flaws, and it probably highlights how weak we are outwide, but he definitely proved he is our best winger. It's up to others to go past him. I think Staines staying fit will see him be rated better, and let's hope Lobb can play as well as kick goals, but that's all to be seen. Going off what we have seen, Tupou starts. Who played better on the wing last year than Tupou?
Tucker
Well-known member
No one played well on the wing last year, including him.
I wanted a completely new 3/4 line for next season but alas…
king_sirro
Well-known member
Yea but you said he isn't the best option. So who is?
Odessa
Well-known member
Mate what is your opinion on Waqa Blake would be be worth a Reggie's contact?
To play wing
Magpie_Magic
Well-known member
Staines had the poise when on field, which sadly wasn't long enough. Looks like he belongs at the top level. I suppose on the other wing if Tupou is gone one could go Naden or even Noff.
Truth is, Naden performed at Penrith in better class so if Luai and Olam comes that could bring him up.
Noff is an interesting case. Probably would relish playing in a better side to prove a point. Luai/Sezer and Fainu squaring up defences will get him running straight. And his got good hands unlike Tupou.
Sure he feels entitled and it's not a good attitude but probably feels he put in a little more than some others who craped on the club and departed.
Could do alot worse than have players with a point to prove.
The hinge is Luai. If he comes Naden, Staines.,Noff and even To'a might rise to the challenge.
To'a and Tupou have poor situational and game awareness. You might carry one in the backs but not two.
We then would be light on two quality backs.....but could probably get away with it.
Truth is, Naden performed at Penrith in better class so if Luai and Olam comes that could bring him up.
Noff is an interesting case. Probably would relish playing in a better side to prove a point. Luai/Sezer and Fainu squaring up defences will get him running straight. And his got good hands unlike Tupou.
Sure he feels entitled and it's not a good attitude but probably feels he put in a little more than some others who craped on the club and departed.
Could do alot worse than have players with a point to prove.
The hinge is Luai. If he comes Naden, Staines.,Noff and even To'a might rise to the challenge.
To'a and Tupou have poor situational and game awareness. You might carry one in the backs but not two.
We then would be light on two quality backs.....but could probably get away with it.
Last edited:
king_sirro
Well-known member
Personally I think Blake is horrible and has been for a long time.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
Blake is one of the worst defenders I have ever seen.
Tiger Stripes
Well-known member
Benji should be training him for a centre position now in the pre season sessions to get him used to defending as a centre ie. in preference to persevering with Tupou at centre. Attack should be good.
Sully
Well-known member
We think Tupou has flippers for hands then Blake makes him look like Tedesco as he can’t catch a bomb to save his life.
Halbrowne61
Well-known member
You are absolutely correct.
I got confused as I originally thought he was going over in 24. Now I know it’s 25 but Herbie and co will still be there.
Halbrowne61
Well-known member
Maybe the pieces will come together when we sort out Luai, but then again maybe Benji has changed his mind about Olam.
Halbrowne61
Well-known member
No from me, not to play anywhere. Wouldn’t even consider him.
TigerNeddyK
Well-known member
AD is his private tackling coachAh it's not immeadiate. Okay we get to keep Tupou for 2024 but loose him in 2025.
That still sucks, as the biggest problem with Tupou was defensive effort. I can't see him putting his body on the line much more then he has done.
Its been on...off...now apparently back on again.
I tend to agree with MM , Luai hold the key if we snare him things may fall into place, but as usual its "always next year" or 2025
Nothning closesly resembling a decent outside back has been linked with us, maybe OLams our only shot
Don't disagree but not happy wasting any more time on this bloke next year if he's off to the fish in '25
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
The club has the option of playing him in reserve grade.
Tucker
Well-known member
To me he isn’t the best option because he requires a tonne of work and it’ll all be for nought as he is leaving next year. I highly doubt he’ll perform well enough this year to cause us problems if we don’t select him.
I don’t know the young blokes well enough to supply names but surely there’s a project player available that can take his place. Until then, we have experienced guys on roster that I’d put ahead of him.