Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Nothing will happen to any of the top side on poaching weaker clubs juniors. Manly and Roosters got away in 80's 90's and Penrith will get away with it know.

We have waited 20 years for this joint venture to get it's act together.
 
Tom Shines said:
It’s a little easy to me to blame injuries for our problems …yes they certainly don’t help.. but they do expose the lack of depth in the squad as a whole … which has been brought about through a strategy of having an over reliance on juniors in the Top 30 who are not first grade ready …. Besides ..they have won 10 of their last 65 games …so they lose even with their best players available …

They need another winger and Center in addition to Turuva … I don’t see a lot of solutions who are at the club now … they will probably be forced into continuing with Olam given this lack of depth …. But he was one of the worst players on the field last start ..which is saying a lot ..

Yeah ..it’s easier said than done to find other guys .. I don’t know what options are available…I have mentioned trying to get a guy like Brad Parker here who is seemingly stuck in reserve grade at Manly… its interesting to me though that a player like Tommy Talau is keeping him in reserve grade and he is playing pretty good football now when he was beyond terrible his years playing here …

At the end of the day ..it’s up to Richo to find the players to improve the team …Im sure he is being paid amongst the top CEO’s…so he has gotta start showing why …
Click to expand...
100% on Brad Parker, Tom. We don't need a team full of superstars or promising juniors. Right now we need job-ready 1st graders who have proven their attitude. A few signings like Parker will help to stabilise the team/club and win a few more games. Give us a bit more credibility in the free market & allows us to introduce talented juniors when they are ready.
 
stephen said:
100% on Brad Parker, Tom. We don't need a team full of superstars or promising juniors. Right now we need job-ready 1st graders who have proven their attitude. A few signings like Parker will help to stabilise the team/club and win a few more games. Give us a bit more credibility in the free market & allows us to introduce talented juniors when they are ready.
Click to expand...

Unlike a lot of guys that get thrown up here … Parker is still only 27 and has played over a 100 NRL games I believe ..

He is an unspectacular but solid player who at least can defend ok and doesn’t have brain explosions ..

Sign him up for 2 years … surely in that time they can find the next Jason Saab in their junior system
 
Tom Shines said:
It only survives in the AFL because no player or club challenges it …any legal action would have the same result as the Hill case ..

It shows a key difference between the sports … the “whats best for me” in the NRL versus “good of the game “ in the AFL …

Not saying AFL is right and NRL wrong … their drugs policy is wrong in my view …
Click to expand...
The other difference is that the NRL has competition from the English Super League and Union. AFL players have no alternative
 
Dr_Ice said:
And after all that fighting left the Magpies after 2 years to go the Manly!

This part is less difficult to believe
Click to expand...
You have to remember, the Roosters were not always a strong club. They have spent more than their share of time in the bottom half of the table. It's just that we have recency bias - and so do the journos. The Panthers used to make up the numbers and rarely made the semis, The Sharks were also bottom feeders for a long time. A good reminder that all of this is cyclical. The Tiges will have their day in the sun again, but it won't be soon unless we get our act together as a club,
 
SwervinMervin said:
You have to remember, the Roosters were not always a strong club. They have spent more than their share of time in the bottom half of the table. It's just that we have recency bias - and so do the journos. The Panthers used to make up the numbers and rarely made the semis, The Sharks were also bottom feeders for a long time. A good reminder that all of this is cyclical. The Tiges will have their day in the sun again, but it won't be soon unless we get our act together as a club,
Click to expand...
You are right, but I think we can expedite the process if we make the good decisions.

Brad wins 300% more games than Benji and turned the eels into a powerhouse for a long period through good signings and instilling some grunt.

I just think we need a lot of experience at this juncture.

Benji can leave for family reasons and come back another time. Throw him on the board to stop him losing face.
 
TSP said:
You are right, but I think we can expedite the process if we make the good decisions.

Brad wins 300% more games than Benji and turned the eels into a powerhouse for a long period through good signings and instilling some grunt.

I just think we need a lot of experience at this juncture.

Benji can leave for family reasons and come back another time. Throw him on the board to stop him losing face.
Click to expand...
There is no shame in stepping back into an assistant role to learn his craft.. Problem is, I am sure Brad Arthur would expect to be a long term head coach appointment at his next club, not a benchwarmer for a rookie coach to take over in 2-3 years. What a shame we didn't get Wayne Bennet to come in to do another 2-3 year gig with a plan to hand over to Benj potentially at the end of that. Look at what he has done at the Dolphins in less than 2 seasons. Built a roster from bit parts, got them competitive in the first year, uncovered some rising stars, got the most out of some hardened veterans and recruited some star power for their second season. They were competitive in their first year, and probably will make the finals this year. What could have been, eh.
 
SwervinMervin said:
There is no shame in stepping back into an assistant role to learn his craft.. Problem is, I am sure Brad Arthur would expect to be a long term head coach appointment at his next club, not a benchwarmer for a rookie coach to take over in 2-3 years. What a shame we didn't get Wayne Bennet to come in to do another 2-3 year gig with a plan to hand over to Benj potentially at the end of that. Look at what he has done at the Dolphins in less than 2 seasons. Built a roster from bit parts, got them competitive in the first year, uncovered some rising stars, got the most out of some hardened veterans and recruited some star power for their second season. They were competitive in their first year, and probably will make the finals this year. What could have been, eh.
Click to expand...
It simply shows what can be achieved if you know what you’re doing. And that’s called experience !
 
SwervinMervin said:
You have to remember, the Roosters were not always a strong club. They have spent more than their share of time in the bottom half of the table. It's just that we have recency bias - and so do the journos. The Panthers used to make up the numbers and rarely made the semis, The Sharks were also bottom feeders for a long time. A good reminder that all of this is cyclical. The Tiges will have their day in the sun again, but it won't be soon unless we get our act together as a club,
Click to expand...
Well said, GNR could take a leaf.
We have Richo now and a new board, it will take time to filter through. Our juniors are going good l, flegg, sg ball, Harold Matthews are on the up. Our coach is the worry for me, I’d rather we’d signed Flanagan but Arthur will do. Bunji ti drop back to assistant.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,283 (members: 36, guests: 1,247)
Back
Top