Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

teddy23 said:
If Brisbane get Walker…. then from a Roosters perspective as much of a turd Moses is you’d be silly not to go get him.

Especially if your captain is behind the scenes trying to make it happen.
Click to expand...
He agreed to terms before then did a backflip so I don't think Uncle Nick would want him now
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Umm excuse me? I was adamant from the beginning that Luai was coming I never faltered on that. Ask @innsaneink and @king_sirro who were convinced i was just trolling. As for the rest of your post. I’ve seen people get on the defensive for no reason before, but not quite like this. Not sure what was so offensive about the Turuva comment. I answered your question. I think he’ll find him in both positions during the season.
Click to expand...
Yes @FrodoTBaggin you're most definitely wrong on Gunthers posts on Luiai... He was very confident romey was coming.
"it's done" was stated umpteen times... Dunno how you missed it
 
FrodoTBaggin said:
Do you have any Intel on where we plan to play Turuva? I thought centre when we first signed him but AD / Olam could fill that next year and then we are potentially looking at Cobbo in AD spot the year after?

Not to mention Makasini potentially coming through. Makes me feel like benji views Tito as a winger.
Click to expand...
Seriously
Is this the same Cobbo who has required leave this year and last year to go home to spend time with his family (home sickness)
And you have him signed for us in 2026 playing & Living in Sydney 😂
 
rugbygoated said:
He will not do anything here unless we build around him and set the platform (forwards, outside backs, management). Crichton has gone to the Dogs with a Panther-esque structure of Gould at CEO, Ciraldo a great defensive coach, and many former panthers (Burton, Kikau, Salmon). He is also playing centre so he doesn't have as much to worry about compared to a half or fullback as he plays one side, and can focus on leadership too. It is why Burton and Mahoney are having great years after being thrown the captaincy last year which took away from their on field leadership through actions and distracted their decision making. They also have plenty of marquee players and a strong roster. Bulldogs 2024 roster has much more depth and quality than Tigers 2024. For 2025, allowing more juniors and marquee players to strike a relationship is key for success, but I think we are at least a few years away from a top 8 berth if you look at the roster. Also Benji's coaching is not giving me too much confidence, yet we will persist with him until we go into a deeper hole and find a stop-gap solution
Click to expand...
The thing for me though is we spent a long time putting resources around Luke Brooks and the guy just wasn't up to it.

It will be refreshing and hopefully beneficial for us not to have to worry too much about the new halfback, who will do his job and create chances, and let the other players just do their job.

For example Tigers 2024 are a low-error side and Tigers 2023 had lots of attacking possession, but the main problem was that good defences could withstand our early assaults and then wrestle back control of the match. At which point we'd eventually capitulate.

My personal argument is that in 2024 Tigers are even more competitive for longer periods, compared to 2022-2023, despite not yet converting that to more wins. And the key to that has been being able to sustain pressure and maintain an attacking threat, which Luai is expected to provide.

It's different for a young and modest team when there isn't continual pressure on us, and pressure is alleviated by keeping the ball (which we are doing) and turning possession into points (which Luai was signed to help).
 
jirskyr said:
The thing for me though is we spent a long time putting resources around Luke Brooks and the guy just wasn't up to it.

It will be refreshing and hopefully beneficial for us not to have to worry too much about the new halfback, who will do his job and create chances, and let the other players just do their job.

For example Tigers 2024 are a low-error side and Tigers 2023 had lots of attacking possession, but the main problem was that good defences could withstand our early assaults and then wrestle back control of the match. At which point we'd eventually capitulate.

My personal argument is that in 2024 Tigers are even more competitive for longer periods, compared to 2022-2023, despite not yet converting that to more wins. And the key to that has been being able to sustain pressure and maintain an attacking threat, which Luai is expected to provide.

It's different for a young and modest team when there isn't continual pressure on us, and pressure is alleviated by keeping the ball (which we are doing) and turning possession into points (which Luai was signed to help).
Click to expand...
2023 tigers were worse in defence but the biggest problem were the halves. Brooks was actually not that bad last year, Wakeham terrible and then Will Smith as backup was grim. This year we are in more games and our defence wasn't that bad for the first 10 rounds until the cowboys or dragons game. Our biggest issues now are having a dominant forward and our outside backs defence
 
So much rubbish chat about Halves, it’s Galvin and Jerome next year 100% Sezier hopefully remains in the squad and Latu develops. Bud needs to go.

What we need are middles, not big name has beens like the safitis. We need players with commitment, youth and skill that are ahead of our newly introduced developing players. This will spur them all on to grow.

Players floating around the edge of their starting side. I believe the play is that we pay overs for 3 players on a long term. This will pull hopefully them away from their clubs.

Going through the list of players no signed for next year. Here are some targets

Klese Haas
Corey Waddell
Joe Chan (MO)
Jamayne Tanou Brown (been injured all year)
Charlie Guymer (played tonight, looked great)
Tom Eisenhuth

Players we should go after and pay overs for:
Liam Henry
Naf Whyte
Davvy Moale
 
27kelpie said:
So much rubbish chat about Halves, it’s Galvin and Jerome next year 100% Sezier hopefully remains in the squad and Latu develops. Bud needs to go.

What we need are middles, not big name has beens like the safitis. We need players with commitment, youth and skill that are ahead of our newly introduced developing players. This will spur them all on to grow.

Players floating around the edge of their starting side. I believe the play is that we pay overs for 3 players on a long term. This will pull hopefully them away from their clubs.

Going through the list of players no signed for next year. Here are some targets

Klese Haas
Corey Waddell
Joe Chan (MO)
Jamayne Tanou Brown (been injured all year)
Charlie Guymer (played tonight, looked great)
Tom Eisenhuth

Players we should go after and pay overs for:
Liam Henry
Naf Whyte
Davvy Moale
Click to expand...
just 4 non argument ,really 3 years?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 428 (members: 4, guests: 424)
Back
Top