Stefano Utoikamanu #241

Come on he went to England to land players , there has been forwards moving around clubs everywhere, and what have we got a big O
Well who was tying up $800K a year while we gave him time to consider our offer? So, it would appear only since Stef has been allowed to explore his options that we both require another forward and are in a position to make a play for one.
 
Ya'll are dreaming if you think us pulling the offer will do anything other than just lose him - CB said it himself, any club would love to have him.

Except ours I guess, we'll probably be even better without him aye!
And Dragons and Raiders. Apparently at one point two of his biggest “suitors”
 
Well who was tying up $800K a year while we gave him time to consider our offer? So, it would appear only since Stef has been allowed to explore his options that we both require another forward and are in a position to make a play for one.
Even if he stays we need at lease 2 new forwards, or what is the point in buying luai, because if the forwards can’t hold there own , nothing will change
 
Yes no doubt it was a poor signing in hindsight

I am bemused though that Klemmer gets about 5 percent of the criticism Stef gets
I think the Knights chipping in made it seem more worthwhile but the length of deal was the big error based on hindsight.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
I think the Knights chipping in made it seem more worthwhile but the length of deal was the big error based on hindsight.

the story was that they chipped in for $400k last year only… Tigers paying the full freight now ….better than nothing… but still a Sheens special
 
the story was that they chipped in for $400k last year only… Tigers paying the full freight now ….better than nothing… but still a Sheens special
It was first two years subsidised and next year is a mutual option. Tigers won’t extend and it makes sense if he can get a longer deal to move on. Probably a part payout from Tigers. Benji has to drop him this week however Twal is still out so it’s a problem.
 
Yes no doubt it was a poor signing in hindsight

I am bemused though that Klemmer gets about 5 percent of the criticism Stef gets
Ok, let me help the balance, bloody well and truly past it. The only prop I know who skips to the line, no toughness left just pedestrian runs time after time.
He and Twal as bad as each other. Should both be punted imo !!
There you go.
 
I believe Newcastle put up funds around half for the first 2 years , then we had a mutual agreement , so Klemmer has not been a bad deal until now , we may have to cover his total of around $ 800 k for next year only
he was purchased to help thats about it , not a world winner just a name who has history of being tough prop ,
 
I believe Newcastle put up funds around half for the first 2 years , then we had a mutual agreement , so Klemmer has not been a bad deal until now , we may have to cover his total of around $ 800 k for next year only
he was purchased to help thats about it , not a world winner just a name who has history of being tough prop ,
I don’t care about the money I’m more interested in the contribution. And there is little to none, can’t believe he’s an ex Test forward coz he’s no longer tough but gone soft. (Woods Mk2).
 
I don’t care about the money I’m more interested in the contribution. And there is little to none, can’t believe he’s an ex Test forward coz he’s no longer tough but gone soft. (Woods Mk2).
Newcastle paid 1/2 his freight , so he was about a $ 400 k prop for us , that’s not a bad deal , he has always had a crack and made mtrs , you need to have another look at his stats , he is great defender and always has a crack, better than a lot others who get no mention of being pretty poor
 
Newcastle paid 1/2 his freight , so he was about a $ 400 k prop for us , that’s not a bad deal , he has always had a crack and made mtrs , you need to have another look at his stats , he is great defender and always has a crack, better than a lot others who get no mention of being pretty poor
Ok 426, maybe I’m being a bit harsh but the Klemmer I remember was a real goer, and fiery too. I know he’s older now and has probably mellowed but we just don’t seem to have any fire in the belly( except maybe Seyfarth when he gets riled).
I’d like some Haas, Fisher Harris or Leinu type charges from someone on a regular basis !!!
 
Would definitely be pulling the extension and benching him next game until he pulls his finger out. Shame because he has all the potential to be a top 3 prop in the game but plays like a soft [This word has been automatically removed].

My guess is he goes to either Panthers or Roosters on “unders”. Don’t see how the Eels could offer anything close to our offer considering how much they have wrapped up in Moses, Brown, Gutherson, RCG, and Paulo alone. Bellamy won’t pay anywhere near 800K for an inconsistent prop and most signs point to him wanting to stay in Sydney.
 
Newcastle paid 1/2 his freight , so he was about a $ 400 k prop for us , that’s not a bad deal , he has always had a crack and made mtrs , you need to have another look at his stats , he is great defender and always has a crack, better than a lot others who get no mention of being pretty poor

they chipped in $400k last year only … now $800k full freight for the Tigers
 
Ok 426, maybe I’m being a bit harsh but the Klemmer I remember was a real goer, and fiery too. I know he’s older now and has probably mellowed but we just don’t seem to have any fire in the belly( except maybe Seyfarth when he gets riled).
I’d like some Haas, Fisher Harris or Leinu type charges from someone on a regular basis !!!

Personally I always thought Klemmer got picked from Origin and Australia off the back off a shaved head and angry face. He was never an elite front rower. Generally his yards are ok and he makes his tackles, but slow play the balls, no solid contact in defence even in his representative years, way too many penalties and dropped balls make him quite average.
Always been overrated like Jason Ryles.
 
Personally I always thought Klemmer got picked from Origin and Australia off the back off a shaved head and angry face. He was never an elite front rower. Generally his yards are ok and he makes his tackles, but slow play the balls, no solid contact in defence even in his representative years, way too many penalties and dropped balls make him quite average.
Always been overrated like Jason Ryles.
Ive seen people on here mention a lot that he has slow play the balls. I check those sorts of stats after games regularly and he more often than not has one of the fastest average play the ball speeds in the game. Im not sure why people think he's slow in that area.

I can't disagree with the no solid contact though. I dont think he's been terrible for us but with his size and his experience i was expecting a lot more
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top