tigertragic
Well-known member
Because that’s the best we’ve got unfortunately
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
He didn’t pick Naden and who do you suggest he picks ?
king_sirro
Well-known member
Couldn't disagree more. Replace the pathetic experienced players that continually let us down with kids and we compete a lot more then we currently are.
I'm over this crap talk about experience. Buying players for experience has let us down for 15 years. Experience means jack shit if the player isn't hungry.
You need hungry players with good character. Only sign someone who has something to prove and a lot to gain by busting their arse.
clontarfkid
Well-known member
It's not about experience..its about ability.
The so called kids just aren't ready for nrl..many never will be tbh
They wld have been monstered by a physical Sharks team..moreso than our grown ups
The other key ingredient we are lacking is being dynamic especially in on field movements.
That explosiveness that some players possess in the NRL we have none of this.
king_sirro
Well-known member
You know who has explosiveness who is seeking an opportunity? Ethan Bullemor. This guy can be dynamic on an edge but for some reason just hasn't nailed a spot at Manly. He would be hungry and aggressive. At 24 I think he could be a real surprise packet on the cheap.
That is true, but the question is how do you get the more experienced players that have already tapped out to put a bit of effort in between now and the end of the season ?
I wanted to recruit Ethan Bullemor before he turned up in first grade at the Broncos. Instead we pick up Tuki Simpkins.
I keep reading he has a high IQ and a few degrees outside of footy and considers giving the game away to take up a corporate job.
Yet he seems to end up continuing his NRL career year by year.
He carries the ball at speed, generally plays with high energy, is very experienced and battle hardened and approaching the best years of his career as an NRL forward.
A player like him would be an astute recruit if we could somehow get him off Manly.
WestsTigers4VR
Well-known member
Kotoni Staggs is free to negotiate come November 1st, would most likely mean seeing him come in 2026. What would you say is a fair contract to offer someone like Staggs? Personally I’d say around $800,000 - $850,000 for around 3-4 years would be the most realistic. He is already currently on $750,000 so it’s pretty unlikely he’d take less unless he goes to a good club and as for age he’d be 27 or 28 by that time. Thoughts?
Too much common sense for this club
Yeah that’s the problem.
Great player, very underrated and plays with the intensity and aggression we lack.
But by the time he’s 28 it’s hard to imagine him wanting to move from a highly successful club to a club trying to dig their way off the bottom and still have the drive to give his best on a regular basis.
I suppose it is why coaches such as Bellamy and Bennett have such a big reputation as they know how to motivate and get the best out of players no matter what.
Dennisspicer1
Well-known member
Cannot understand why all is quiet on the western front,
I know Richo & Benji said they wanted to keep things quiet.
BUT THIS IS REDICULOUS.
We need some knowledge about anything that could give us idiot supporters some hope our future could be better than what we are living through at the moment.
And if there is no good news forthcoming Then please explain.
Are we strapped financially and simply can't afford to purchase any decent players that will be able to help Jerome Luai
Next year, Or are we looking at no other players coming to our club.
And early next season when we lose our first 7 or 8 matches the rumours will start that our one and only star wants out.
PLEASE GIVE US SOMETHING TO FEEL POSITIVE ABOUT.
Like an explanation as to what the he'll is happening at
West Tigers.
I know Richo & Benji said they wanted to keep things quiet.
BUT THIS IS REDICULOUS.
We need some knowledge about anything that could give us idiot supporters some hope our future could be better than what we are living through at the moment.
And if there is no good news forthcoming Then please explain.
Are we strapped financially and simply can't afford to purchase any decent players that will be able to help Jerome Luai
Next year, Or are we looking at no other players coming to our club.
And early next season when we lose our first 7 or 8 matches the rumours will start that our one and only star wants out.
PLEASE GIVE US SOMETHING TO FEEL POSITIVE ABOUT.
Like an explanation as to what the he'll is happening at
West Tigers.
TSP
Well-known member
A refreshing thought, I’d think he’d want too much. All I can do is part with $750k for 3 years max and he’d spit in my face.
TSP
Well-known member
Well we are trying to build up the war chest -that’s well known based on Richos comments and his trip os.
When it comes to recruiting, we can’t say too much too early as other clubs may learn of the pursuit and take an interest in a player they might have otherwise have passed on. That just creates extra competition we don’t need. It’s a risk.
The main thing is we are targeting the right players. That’s on Benji atm.
As Benji isn’t proving too good at motivating players, we are in dire need of players who don’t need too much!
Proper 80 minute footballers who aim up. They are out there but are usually quite expensive and hard to sign.
balmain boy
Well-known member
We should only be releasing players when we're signing new players. The fact we didn't sign anyone midseason this year is beyond comprehension. It's just not possible that there wasn't a single player in the NRL, or NSW/Qld cup, currently blocked from first grade, willing to show their wares in the shop window for 6 months with the hope of an extension if they do well. Or get snapped up by another club
balmain boy
Well-known member
If we were a professional club, we would have waited till he had played 6 matches before making a decision on his contract status.
So far, he has proven he's not an NRL player. He should not have been offered a contract. We don't have enough room to move in our top 30, now another spot is wasted on a loser with a toxic attitude who can't help us move forwards.
No other club would be as unprofessional as we are. It's why we'll get 3 spoons in a row.
The only way out is paying out a million dollars worth of players and bringing in cheap players with the right skill sets and attitude
balmain boy
Well-known member
The club should be rightfully back the coach in saying, this team is absolutely crap, the players are too bad, no one can coach them. Sack a dozen of them.
And he wouldn't be wrong.
He should have lost the backing of many of the players. The players should have been told you're free to leave asap. That's what any professional club would do. We need a complete gut
