Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[king_sirro]

Lol whatever man, I’ve proven you wrong so many times it’s not funny.
We have to try something new. What we did this year and frankly most years does not work.
Get out of the dinosaur mindset. The fact you just ridicule rather than discuss shows how closed minded you are. Hopefully Benji has more courage.

Your right

 

[2041]

We did have James Roberts. Just couldn't get him the ball.

You're a lunatic. James Roberts at the Tigers was so far past past it that he couldn't see it in the rear view mirror.

 

[Demps]

You're a lunatic. James Roberts at the Tigers was so far past past it that he couldn't see it in the rear view mirror.

Man, James Roberts was a weapon.
He had so much talent & ability.
He could've been 1 of the best.
Unfortunately, a lot of distractions, off field issues and possible head noise.

It's a shame how his career played out and how his life appears to play out [with recent arrests]. Tigers got the worst version of the Jet.

Shame.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

Jack Williams as a middle 👍 Jack Williams as a backrower 👎

 

[bptiger 0]

If available, between Hopgood and Wishart which one would you go for to be our 13 then?

Bugger it take both

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

Man, James Roberts was a weapon.
He had so much talent & ability.
He could've been 1 of the best.
Unfortunately, a lot of distractions, off field issues and possible head noise.

It's a shame how his career played out and how his life appears to play out [with recent arrests]. Tigers got the worst version of the Jet.

Shame.

Heard from someone reliable that James Roberts had the worst shoulder of anyone they'd ever seen & that's coming from a medical professional. They said it was a miracle he was playing for WT's every week & needed weekly injections for the pain.

 

[Needaname]

I think you sell Stimson short.

94% tackle efficiency in 1st grade suggests he's pretty solid defensively.

But, he hasn't played more than 6 games this year- so there's that. The Titans did win 3 of those 6 though.

But then, playing lock & prop in Hostplus Cup for Ipswich- 91% tackle efficiency coupled with 180m per game on average with 3 games well over 200m in a game, while playing entire matches, so fatigue factored in....I'd say that's some pretty dominant performances.

Don't get me wrong- he's not going to suddenly be Payne Haas. But he'll hold the middle together at a price that won't stop the club retaining it's stars. When Bellamy & Hasler are his coaches- chances are, he's fit & disciplined.

I think people forget he played the whole NRL season last year when Fermor had the preseason training injury that ruled him out.

 

[batboy]

Heard from someone reliable that James Roberts had the worst shoulder of anyone they'd ever seen & that's coming from a medical professional. They said it was a miracle he was playing for WT's every week & needed weekly injections for the pain.

Was playing RM Cup last year, Can't have been that bad.....

 

[SeanT]

Sean Lane - thoughts ?

Rather have a statue at the edge then him.

He's absolutely rubbish. One decent year two years ago. All those Eels forwards are past their best.

 

[Needaname]

I know its not a popular signing option but I can't help but think Tyrell May will announced as another signing. Don't burn me at the stake but I just have a feeling, seeming a few other Panthers are coming next year. I can also imagine Luai being in Marshall's ear.

Once again. Luai is a family man. Unless he had a 3rd party view of the incident or whatever has transpired for the charge to be laid and knows he is innocent I’d say he would be thinking twice about the teammate he used to have.

 

[426Tlgerland]

Jack Williams, Dylan Waker and Jezz Tevaga....

That's a great start.

I think Walker has stated he is staying in NZ. But Jazz is available and Williams may be looking for some cash and a nrl starter each week

 

[Needaname]

Flanagan and Holmes go back to Sharks so there is a history.

Just need to resign Jack Bird and they’ll have 3 members (Flanno as coach) from their 2016 premiership side in play.
I reckon Williams ends up there as well.

 

[Buttface]

Hopgood

Me too.

 

[Needaname]

Front loading players is 'unprofessional'?

Sit down.

I'm not making a suggestion, I'm making a prediction about where a small part of the money will likely end up.

It's also a far better option than simply spending it all on what's available because it has to be spent.

That is actually the smart play if there is not the required quality on the market.

it has the potential to lock some players into longer contracts then desired.
I mean if you look at the maths of it.

Each team is required to spend 97.5% of their salary cap.
There is only 30 players to a salary cap.
So each year we decide to frontload; we are effectively making our squad weaker and weaker until we eventually land a bevy of Marquees that all that saved cap money is spent on. All the while hoping that the players that have been given long term contracts with the (front loaded bonus) continue to develop on course or better in an overall weaker side based on talent.

I’ll rephrase. It’s fantastic for a top club to do this to ensure they have a gun side when the time is right.
I’m sure you remember the Cronulla Salary cap scandal for 2015 and 2017 but the premiership winning 2016 season was compliant. Case in point.

So for a struggling club continuing to front load to build up a war chest that no one wants a part of. It’s the worst thing that can happen.

 

[851]

The Fox was probably the last one. Prior to that Darren Clarke 😆. Prior to that Larry Corowa 😆😆

Koroibete

 

[mtd#2]

I dont think Id bring anymore backs to the club for 2025.
Weve signed three good ones and we do have choices already here. One of the possible lineups could be as follows:

• 1. Bula
• 2. Turuva
• 3. Galvin
• 4. Olam
• 5. Skelton
• 6. Luai
• 7. Sezer

This list has lots of points in it. Backups include Staines, Laulilii, Fainu, To'a, Faataape, Saukuru, Doueihi, Feledy, Sullivan, Alaimalo.

Get them a specialised backs coach who will re-familiarise them with what it takes to form a cohesive unit.

Now get them some hard working pigs to join Api, Pole, Seyfarth and Sam

Bro.... Galvin to the centres.......

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Probably. Doesn't take away from his potential though and I absolutely would not be drawing a line through him.

Agree. But he is being rushed currently which is why the errors he makes happen. Hopefully the pain now will lead to an awesome player. Time will tell.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Heard from someone reliable that James Roberts had the worst shoulder of anyone they'd ever seen & that's coming from a medical professional. They said it was a miracle he was playing for WT's every week & needed weekly injections for the pain.

That would be impressive.

When I went to the surgeon for my shoulder his opening line was “thanks for doing such a great job and keeping me employed”. The consult went to 3mins - he just said “you’re getting a recon and several ligaments reattached, see you at the hospital”

Post op visit 10 days after - he said “I need a seat and a glass of water to read the report” he then read out 23 things that he had to be fixed up.

 

[The Chad]

Bro.... Galvin to the centres.......
Have you taken your medication today?

Fittler & Daley played large portions of their early career at centre.

They were still superstars.

I don't think Galvin is your typical, organising, team running half/5-8. I think he'd kill it at centre. And Staines would love him.

 

[The Chad]

I think people forget he played the whole NRL season last year when Fermor had the preseason training injury that ruled him out.

Not starting for the Titans doesn't make you a rubbish player. That's a pretty hot forward pack & has some considerably good depth to it.