Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

But if you wanna question if he has been a good 5/8 this year that right there is not up for discussion
Yes it is up for discussion. The evidence is against him. Dont be fooled by his busy workrate and good motor. He hasnt done much this year to help us win games. 3 wins from 19 digs says he hasnt been effective in the halves.
 
He has run the second worst attack in the comp this year and the 7th worst attack in Wests Tigers history.
He gets lost in defence constantly, he is too weak to bring down proper men, therefore is targeted. He runs across field a lot cramping his outside men and he dies with the ball a lot as he hasnt the speed to run around most and gets caught.
His team has come last. Would things be different with someone else in 5/8? We made him sit out one game and we won it.....
My bad champ forgot that it’s the 5:8 that runs the team and not the halfback

Galvin is 18 and has been put in the worst situation in rugby league

His running game is just about the only threat that our attack has

And for someone who is “to weak to bring down proper men” only missing 29 tackles is pretty impressive
 
My bad champ forgot that it’s the 5:8 that runs the team and not the halfback

Galvin is 18 and has been put in the worst situation in rugby league

His running game is just about the only threat that our attack has

And for someone who is “to weak to bring down proper men” only missing 29 tackles is pretty impressive
How many does he not even attempt because he is being turned around in circles like a little kid?
The 5/8 runs our attack. End of story.
 
Yes it is up for discussion. The evidence is against him. Dont be fooled by his busy workrate and good motor. He hasnt done much this year to help us win games. 3 wins from 19 digs says he hasnt been effective in the halves.
DCE missed finals more then he made finals over his 10 year deal

Based off your logic he hasn’t been effective either
 
How many does he not even attempt because he is being turned around in circles like a little kid?
The 5/8 runs our attack. End of story.
You find me 5 clips where a defensive miss is 100% Galvins fault and I’ll be happy to admit your right and I’m wrong
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
What are your thoughts on the possibility of Onitoni Large at left centre with Heamasi Makasini at left wing in 2026 ?
They know each others game like the back of their hands.
I think a lot of Heamasi’s talents are wasted on a wing if I’m honest. he’s got a beautiful pair of hands and his ballplaying is top shelf. I’d have him at left centre no doubt.

Onitoni is the interesting one. he could easily unseat Bula, Galvin or Fainu in their respective positions given his talent, but if I had to make a prediction I think he’ll come into grade at right centre.

this is all dependent on them staying, of course. Masi I heard was likely to stay but Oni was leaning towards union. that said, things seem to have cooled of late. no doubt Richardson smoothed things over.
 
You find me 5 clips where a defensive miss is 100% Galvins fault and I’ll be happy to admit your right and I’m wrong
Genuine curiosity- if your centre & winger jam IN, but your second rower & 5/8 slide OUT, who is not following the coaching instructions?

Because I saw that numerous times this season.
 
Genuine curiosity- if your centre & winger jam IN, but your second rower & 5/8 slide OUT, who is not following the coaching instructions?

Because I saw that numerous times this season.
Depends on the defensive structure but honestly abit of everyone’s fault

Wingers and centres should only really jam in if there is an overlap and the defence can’t slide

Other special occasions mean they should but overall would probably blame them for a defensive stuff up like that
 
Back
Top