Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Tiger-ferret said:
He had sharks going ok. How can a defence coach implement anything if there’s not a united front from the top down? Ie Benji is not a defence orientated coach who goes on holidays mid season…
Click to expand...
You have absolutely no clue if they’re a united front or not 😂 you don’t rate Benji we get it. Morris is listed as the defensive coach and we were one of the worst defences in the history of the league, enough said.
 
tigermate said:
coaching candidates - IF Benji is sacked now or after we lose the first 8 games.

who would you pick?

1. Brad Arthur
2. Madge
3. Holbrook
4. Josh Hannay
5. John Morris
6. ??????

Apart from the first two you wouldn't go the others.

Either 1 or 2.

Probs Madge (assuming he would take it)

Question is -- who would get us more wins in a year? Doesn't matter if madge burns people out if we win a comp in two years.

And would Galvin sign extension if current NSW coach was coming on board? hmmmm.
Click to expand...
Madge myth put this club back ten years
 
JB9918 said:
Sezer officially signs 2 year deal with Hull FC.

Not a lot of cash opens up but some.

More importantly a definite roster spot.
Click to expand...
Actually it doesn’t. He had an MO for next year which wasn’t taken up. Our 30 is full for next year still without him, but I’m expecting some player movement soon to free up needed spots.
 
Glenji95 said:
Actually it doesn’t. He had an MO for next year which wasn’t taken up. Our 30 is full for next year still without him, but I’m expecting some player movement soon to free up needed spots.
Click to expand...
True. But the money that possibly committed for the option is back in the bank.

It's hard to keep track of the 30 as you say you'd assume a few more releases.

@kade7 - noting how quiet it is.

Something must be brewing.
 
yeahcaz said:
You have absolutely no clue if they’re a united front or not 😂 you don’t rate Benji we get it. Morris is listed as the defensive coach and we were one of the worst defences in the history of the league, enough said.
Click to expand...
Agree, I have no idea in reality. i get it. You rate benji. Just an opinion.
 
tigermate said:
coaching candidates - IF Benji is sacked now or after we lose the first 8 games.

who would you pick?

1. Brad Arthur
2. Madge
3. Holbrook
4. Josh Hannay
5. John Morris
6. ??????

Apart from the first two you wouldn't go the others.

Either 1 or 2.

Probs Madge (assuming he would take it)

Question is -- who would get us more wins in a year? Doesn't matter if madge burns people out if we win a comp in two years.

And would Galvin sign extension if current NSW coach was coming on board? hmmmm.
Click to expand...
That’s a poor list to choose from. BA just barely had a pass mark given Parra made the finals 5 out of 10 times with him as coach. Besides from what’s been reported it sounds like he’s the coach for the Bears should they be the next team to come in which having a coach lined up will increase their chances given it’ll save time to look for one.

Madge won’t come back here and tbh I think it’ll be a mistake of brining him back. I was one of his supporters and I wanted him to have a chance with Api and Ice given I think he had a big hand in them coming here, but he coaches a certain way which not many players get behind. He’ll burn our players again which will result in talent leaving possibly even Galvin given he won’t stay when the squad is too burnt out from his training methods.

Holbrook while I don’t think he was the major problem when he was the Titans coach, he’s not exactly a world beater in terms of coaching. Most likely won’t play finals under him. Maybe avoid bottom 4 at best with him but don’t see us playing finals with him as coach.

Hannay hasn’t had a lot of experience in head coaching only been an interim if needed so can’t say how he’ll go.

Morris doesn’t deserve the job after this years bad display of defence. He’s supposed to help with it yet it was bad. Nowhere near in line for the promotion.

If the club is gonna replace Benji they’ll have to look elsewhere. These guys are not exactly the greatest coaches out there.
 
tigermate said:
coaching candidates - IF Benji is sacked now or after we lose the first 8 games.

who would you pick?

1. Brad Arthur
2. Madge
3. Holbrook
4. Josh Hannay
5. John Morris
6. ??????

Apart from the first two you wouldn't go the others.

Either 1 or 2.

Probs Madge (assuming he would take it)

Question is -- who would get us more wins in a year? Doesn't matter if madge burns people out if we win a comp in two years.

And would Galvin sign extension if current NSW coach was coming on board? hmmmm.
Click to expand...

Dean Young?
 
Glenji95 said:
That’s a poor list to choose from. BA just barely had a pass mark given Parra made the finals 5 out of 10 times with him as coach. Besides from what’s been reported it sounds like he’s the coach for the Bears should they be the next team to come in which having a coach lined up will increase their chances given it’ll save time to look for one.

Madge won’t come back here and tbh I think it’ll be a mistake of brining him back. I was one of his supporters and I wanted him to have a chance with Api and Ice given I think he had a big hand in them coming here, but he coaches a certain way which not many players get behind. He’ll burn our players again which will result in talent leaving possibly even Galvin given he won’t stay when the squad is too burnt out from his training methods.

Holbrook while I don’t think he was the major problem when he was the Titans coach, he’s not exactly a world beater in terms of coaching. Most likely won’t play finals under him. Maybe avoid bottom 4 at best with him but don’t see us playing finals with him as coach.

Hannay hasn’t had a lot of experience in head coaching only been an interim if needed so can’t say how he’ll go.

Morris doesn’t deserve the job after this years bad display of defence. He’s supposed to help with it yet it was bad. Nowhere near in line for the promotion.

If the club is gonna replace Benji they’ll have to look elsewhere. These guys are not exactly the greatest coaches out there.
Click to expand...
There was a wooden spoon involved, but I reckon we’d all be happy with making the cut every second year.
BA though, I just can’t get excited about it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,337 (members: 3, guests: 1,334)
Back
Top