Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

crazycat said:
It's not just that.

If our defense sucked, but our attack was on target. Then I would say he is doing something.

We scored 463 points. The worst in the league.
While Olam had some injuries.. Really our injuries were not too bad.

Then yes, our defense SUCKED!

What we have seen is Craig F and Ciraldo improve the Sharks and Dogs defense immensily.
We will see Jason Ryles do the same at Parra.
Benji has failed to impart skills that will build this team.
Click to expand...
We were running out a team half full of kids who had never played first grade. No big surprise really.
 
AdelaideTiger said:
Reckon Papalii just wanted to go and the club didn't have much choice but to let him, he was wishy washy about coming here in the first place and we didn't cover ourselves in glory once he was here either. Neither party handled it well, best for both to cut losses and move on (wish Bateman would do the same)
Click to expand...
Geeze Penrith can spot a good player. I got the impression he was reluctant after we sacked the kiwi coach. He’s an Oceanic games athlete. His mother played footy in NZ side. Takes his performance seriously.
 
crazycat said:
It's not just that.

If our defense sucked, but our attack was on target. Then I would say he is doing something.

We scored 463 points. The worst in the league.
While Olam had some injuries.. Really our injuries were not too bad.

Then yes, our defense SUCKED!

What we have seen is Craig F and Ciraldo improve the Sharks and Dogs defense immensily.
We will see Jason Ryles do the same at Parra.
Benji has failed to impart skills that will build this team.
Click to expand...
Cameron Ciraldo's year 1 with the Dogs sucked balls so in that respect we aren't doing much worse. While we didn't score a shit tin of points if you could not see the vast improvement in our attacking structures over the year then I'm not sure what you were watching. Go back and have a listen the the season wrap by the boys on the WTF poddy and you will note that this is supported by the stats.

Benji and the coaching staff failing to impart knowledge is simply bullshit. There was clear evidence, when we got the right bounce of the ball, that we could stick with and execute the gameplan. Problem is that we were outmuscled/out enthused across the park at critical times in most games.

Was it good enough - shit no - but we were playing kids against men and our highly paid senior players weren't performing. We have a significanly improved roster and have added to the coaching staff. Again, not the guy we would have liked to see selected, but someone with experience though. Hodgo doesn't have huge runs on the board but he has had plenty of exposure to different systems. Between him, Morris and Benji there should be enough nouse to improve what we have.

If Benji and co can't start to move the needle in the right direction in 25 Richo will need to make a tough decision; but that is what he is paid for. Holding the kids to account for their fitness on return for pre-season is a great start and shows that the coaching staff are serious about standards.!

Edit
 
Last edited:
crazycat said:
It's not just that.

If our defense sucked, but our attack was on target. Then I would say he is doing something.

We scored 463 points. The worst in the league.
While Olam had some injuries.. Really our injuries were not too bad.

Then yes, our defense SUCKED!

What we have seen is Craig F and Ciraldo improve the Sharks and Dogs defense immensily.
We will see Jason Ryles do the same at Parra.
Benji has failed to impart skills that will build this team.
Click to expand...
Mate , you know how he fixed thier defence . He got them fit as , and mentally strong . When you’re fit and firing , mental lapses become less and less , you’re where you need to be easier , and when the inevitable attrition sets in , you’re able to recover quicker .
Defence is all about being patient , reading numbers , and controlling the ruck to not allow disadvantages and quick play the balls. All fitness related .
A big thing is getting Bula to really spray the boys who aren’t getting to thier assignments quick enough .
I think luai will help a long way with this . At the very least relaying the messages sent in defence , by Bula .
 
Kelce68 said:
So your argument is, basically:

'Look, apart from Jerome Luai and Sunia Turuva and Jack Bird and Royce Hunt and Jeral Skelton and going after Kobe Hetherington and Terrell May and already clearing two roster spots and still being in talks to clear further roster spots.....what has Richardson done for recruitment in the 11 months he's been here?!'

Nothing mate. He's done absolutely nothing. We should sack him.
Click to expand...
Gee u don’t read really well do u , I said he had signed luai , turuva , and Skelton , and bird and hunt , what my post was about, where is the workhorse forwards that we need , u bend everything to make it about something else , YES sack him and benji , is that what u wanted me to say , but I want 2-3 more forwards to stop us from getting number 4 wooden spoon .
So stop been a wanker and read the post for what it is not what u want to read
 
Robbie's Love Child said:
Geez the Benji and Richo bagging is next level insane. Richo is one of the great NRL CEO's fact. Benji is a rookie coach who has had one full NRL season, news flash he wasn't the head coach in 2023 as some would have you believe. Benji has promoted exciting juniors who will lead us forward, heavily involved in Luai coming. The roster he has had to work with for the majority of the season was KOE and youngsters, no super coach would've done better.
Click to expand...
Bullshit. Stop making excuses.
Benji has been poor so far.
These breaches if real are a good step forward. Hope he keeps moving in that direction.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 509 (members: 32, guests: 477)
Back
Top