Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Canadian Club]

Seyfarth looked good on a few occasions last season ... especially that ball off Latu.

Seyfarth had a couple good moments, but many many more shocking moments. His lateral movement is very very poor for an edge forward, makes poor decisions and rushes out of the line.

That's is even before taking into his poor discipline. He would have to be in the top 2 of the entire NRL of giving away the most unnecessary penalties.

He should be a depth option in the front row and nothing more.

 

[SeanT]

Seyfarth had a couple good moments, but many many more shocking moments. His lateral movement is very very poor for an edge forward, makes poor decisions and rushes out of the line.

That's is even before taking into his poor discipline. He would have to be in the top 2 of the entire NRL of giving away the most unnecessary penalties.

He should be a depth option in the front row and nothing more.

Yep..shouldn't be in the 17. Not of you want to play finals.

 

[Lestronge]

So if i don't know - And you don't know....
Why are we here?

ps: Garner joined the Club in 2016/17 Pre-Season (6 months Before Cleary)
pps: In what world is Luke Garner the 'Starting back Rower' over the Internationals of Sorenson and Martin - (We're not even talking Ice over there yet)

Who told you he was recruited to replace kikau (With Sorenson and Martin still there)
- The journos you're shitting on above.

What's that big fancy word you're using for people remembering things to support their POV?

You can disagree all you like - There's 17 Clubs, If Garner was worth close to 500k a year, He be at one of them on exactly that.
Furthermore, he's now 4th choice at Panthers - News Flash, Premiers don't pay their 4th best back Rowers close to 1/2 a million bucks.

He’s the 4th best back rower who started in the GF , yea ok bro ….. cool story tell it again.
See unlike you I’m purely relying on my memory for these things . And I could have sworn Cleary recruited Garner because I remember him coming across and when he got moved to the backrow after a game or 2 in the backs for the Reggie’s . And Cleary having really positive things to say about him . But i guess you’re right .
Either way , I couldn’t really give a shit . I’m advocating for a guy who was starting back rower for last years premiers and you’re saying he’s overrated. I’ll stick to my guns thanks all the same .
you’re dribbling buddy , get yourself a napkin ……
And Sorensen and Ice will be spending time in the middle next season . I’ve heard it on 2 or so podcasts now .
I really don’t understand why you’re so emotional because I said Madge and the old admin were shit judges about talent , and a lot of things . Talk about picking your hills to set your flag . Jesus …

 

[upthetigers]

Seyfarth had a couple good moments, but many many more shocking moments. His lateral movement is very very poor for an edge forward, makes poor decisions and rushes out of the line.

That's is even before taking into his poor discipline. He would have to be in the top 2 of the entire NRL of giving away the most unnecessary penalties.

He should be a depth option in the front row and nothing more.

You're off your head go easy on those CCs buddy

 

[Buttface]

Be good to get the Indian population behind us. I’m a fan of their food.

I’d be happy to participate in the half time curry muncher stakes.

Butter Chicken is tops Tito.

 

[weststigers]

275k is the listed number....
You said he left for 330k - then it was also reported he took a paycut to re-sign with them...
You're the genius here (Clearly) Math seems bout right to me
- I'll leave you to check it though.
Goodluck Supercoach

Bag Papalii all you like - Weather it was him or us, We'll never know.
But I'd bet you weren't so full of wisdom when we signed him for 600k

On IP, we got him for a song, but I think the issue with him and others is we couldn't add more like for like quality within his tenure so not only wasn’t he up for it, we just didn't have the talent to make him useful. Hard to make an impact in his position without the quality around you.

This season, I'm sure he would have gone better, but he had one foot out the door already, so what are you going to do.

Either way, we have recruited high quality players in bunches this time around, so our new signings should (hopefully) live up to their ability.

 

[JB9918]

The other option to look at for a back rower or lock option would be the dogs. They have Kikau, Preston, Tuipanua, Salmon, Mann, Curran, Morrin, Amone, Hayward, King, Hughes... Plus others


Morrin is the type of effort player we could look at unsigned for 2026.

Salmon surely doesn't get starting time this year as a back rower.

My first preference though is push the Broncos with Hethrington.

Sign him for 2026 & keep trying for that early release.

Best option on the market & what we have coming through.

 

[batboy]

He’s the 4th best back rower who started in the GF , yea ok bro ….. cool story tell it again.

Ok, I will….

Think you might find Sorensen started (despite coming back from Injury with no game time) and Garner was pushed back to the bench before kick off…
So yeah, his coach picks him behind Sorensen with a dodgy hammy.

All you’ve done is use lots of words to remind us you don’t know your ass from your elbow…

I never said I didn’t rate him, I said he was overpaid - and he was.
3 years later (by your own admission) he’s still on less money than we paid him - and still not a starting back rower in a good side, despite you trying to convince us he is.

 

[Demps]

Garner is alright
Tries hard
Gets folded too easy for my liking

Sammy Fainu >

 

[mactiger]

Bullemor and sipley are a couple of back rowers that go ok id be looking at them

 

[Kaito]

The other option to look at for a back rower or lock option would be the dogs. They have Kikau, Preston, Tuipanua, Salmon, Mann, Curran, Morrin, Amone, Hayward, King, Hughes... Plus others


Morrin is the type of effort player we could look at unsigned for 2026.

Salmon surely doesn't get starting time this year as a back rower.

My first preference though is push the Broncos with Hethrington.

Sign him for 2026 & keep trying for that early release.

Best option on the market & what we have coming through.

JB long time no see. Glad Ur back posting

 

[Kaito]

There will be plenty going on over this period where
we don't hear anything (before the new year) last
block of pre-season training after, hope we're finding
new homes 4 a few more guys — that would be great

 

[Lestronge]

Ok, I will….

Think you might find Sorensen started (despite coming back from Injury with no game time) and Garner was pushed back to the bench before kick off…
So yeah, his coach picks him behind Sorensen with a dodgy hammy.

All you’ve done is use lots of words to remind us you don’t know your ass from your elbow…

I never said I didn’t rate him, I said he was overpaid - and he was.
3 years later (by your own admission) he’s still on less money than we paid him - and still not a starting back rower in a good side, despite you trying to convince us he is.

Once again , Sorensen and Ice are going to spend time in the middle this coming year. ,got it wrong that he came off the bench , so yea I’m not sitting here going through nrl.com to confirm things. All good .
You’re the only one arguing this stupid point , that’s invalidated by the fact the guy has 2 rings and starts most games for the best team in the comp .
And you have zero idea how much he earns .
I’ve seen journos now say Bud is on 800k per year next year when it was widely reported the contract he signed was 4 years 2.2 mil at the time .
Which one is correct ? Who knows ….. that’s the point !
And literally every contract is scaled for inflation , and other performance metrics .
So if he signed for 295k 2 years ago there’s no way he’s not on 50-100k more by 25 . Or he has the worst manager in the world .
But I don’t think he’s on that contract , because that first year he signed with them would have ballooned his asking price simply by being in the best team in the comp .
I’ve tried to end this thing twice already . Jesus Christ I don’t agree with you . And I value Garner as a player . What’s the issue . Did he root your missus once ?
This is cause I bagged Madge I bet ?

 

[batboy]

Once again , Sorensen and Ice are going to spend time in the middle this coming year. So how does a guy , who I got wrong that came off the bench , so yea I’m not sitting here going through nrl.com to confirm things.
You’re the only one arguing this stupid point , that’s invalidated by the fact the guy has 2 rings and starts most games for the best team in the comp .
And you have zero idea how much he earns .
I’ve seen journos now say Bud is on 800k per year next year when it was widely reported the contract he signed was 4 years 2.2 mil at the time .
Which one is correct ? Who knows ….. that’s the point !

The king of shifting Goal Posts....

I remembered it at the Time, Because Eiso got dropped with the change up
Yes, Some of us are interested in the game, Not just Multis and Supercoach points

You've bought Bud, Fifita, Leilua into me correcting your original bullshit post
(That we didn't rare Garner)
When it was obvious to all and sundry that we was rated
- For what he was / is and still is at the Panthers, A Solid Back Up....

Furthermore, Now you're saying my point is invalidated by the fact he has 2 rings
- When in my original response, that was my point.
Now, You're throwing in the Panthers 2025 game plan for a bloke who has barely touched the ground yet because you 'Heard it on a podcast'
I can see the headlines now, A couple NRL Edge Players spend time in the middle!!
- Didn't you remind us that we did that last year? We're ahead of the Curve - Yowee...

Like I told you,
I steer clear of your ramblings - And am hesitant to be drawn into them.
I apologise for letting you're level of stupidity get the better of me more than once,
I'll promise to be more mindful.

Garner left for a better opportunity, And less Money.
Not because he wasn't rated.

 

[Wiz]

I recall Garner was on $400k or $425k during his last year with us which was shocking to me given his output I.e. overpaid.

Apparently signed at Penrith for $275k per year for his first contract with them.

Garner has since signed another contract with Penrith but I’ve no idea the value, although my guess is it’s commensurate with a reserve second rower.

 

[Lestronge]

The king of shifting Goal Posts....

You've bought Bud, Fifita, Leilua into me correcting your original bullshit post
(That we didn't rare Garner)
When it was obvious to all and sundry that we was rated
- For what he was / is and still is at the Panthers, A Solid Back Up....

Furthermore, Now you're saying my point is invalidated by the fact he has 2 rings
- When in my original response, that was my point.
Now, You're throwing in the Panthers 2025 game plan for a bloke who has barely touched the ground yet because you 'Heard it on a podcast'
I can see the headlines now, A couple NRL Edge Players spend time in the middle!!
- Didn't you remind us that we did that last year? We're ahead of the Curve - Yowee...

Like I told you,
I steer clear of your ramblings - And am hesitant to be drawn into them.
I apologise for letting you're level of stupidity get the better of me more than once,
I'll promise to be more mindful.

Garner left for a better opportunity, And less Money.
Not because he wasn't rated.

you’re the one rambling ! I made a comment about Garner being let go , and should have been kept . And YOU and YOU alone , turned it into this thing . And was worth the 400-450k he was asking . That my opinion . I rate him as a footy player .
And you’ve gone off and jumped at shadows . Carrying on like an idiot over what ?
What are you even mad about ? I stand by my opinion . And I feel validated by what the guy has done since he left, and how appreciated he is by one of the best coaches in the game . And I also take into account we should have paid overs to keep him . That’s it .
And by the way , to imply he was valued is absolute dog shit ! He was bagged so much on here…. So spare me and go cry into your morning coffee because someone disagreed with you … this whole thing makes no sense at all …. Did you get coal for Christmas ? Like what are you even mad about ?

 

[cqtiger]

Batboy, Lestronge, Batboy, Lestronge who is going to have the last word in their posting war?

 

[Lestronge]

Batboy, Lestronge, Batboy, Lestronge who is going to have the last word in their posting war?

Pretty lame isn’t it ! Considering it started because I said the club was run by donkeys and shouldn’t have let Luke Garner go . It’s not even worth talking about at all , let alone having a battle about … Clearly the guy just wanted to have a go at me for whatever reason. Because if it’s about Luke Garner , Like I said before talk about picking your hills to die on / set your flag .
I didn’t realise Luke Garner raised soo much blood pressure ….

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

Pretty lame isn’t it ! Considering it started because I said the club was run by donkeys and shouldn’t have let Luke Garner go . It’s not even worth talking about at all , let alone having a battle about … Clearly the guy just wanted to have a go at me for whatever reason. Because if it’s about Luke Garner , Like I said before talk about picking your hills to die on / set your flag .
I didn’t realise Luke Garner raised soo much blood pressure ….

Well that’s the thing with a forum isn’t it anything id up for discussion. And for the record Garner isn’t a player worth getting into a bidding war for.

 

[gregjm87]

Batboy, Lestronge, Batboy, Lestronge who is going to have the last word in their posting war?

Lestronge is correct in stating that he was bagged here (on the forum). But realistically anyone who isn't either 'going to be a star' or 'is a star' gets bagged. No one seems to value the low cost role player (probably as that seems to be all we have/had in our side and no stars) and Garner probably was also overpriced for such a player during his time here.
Lestronge is entitled to his opinion but he appears to be alone in valuing Garner at 4-500K as neither club did, seemingly no other club has (as he hasn't signed elsewhere) and i've never seen anyone else on the forum rate him that highly.

Batboy's original retort that he was valued here (as in by the club) is however right. The mere fact that he was paid (and offered) more here than he was/is at Panthers would prove that he was valued here. And rightly so as he is a handy back up 2nd rower with good utility value. I just don't see how any club could afford to offer such a player more than at most about 300-350K unless they were to see him as more than that.