Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

liltiger said:
Ink I never forget the start of the season after Cleary had us for his first pre season. We beat Melbourne twice and the Roosters we were just winning by 1 or 2 points in real low scoring grinding games, we were defending our guts out till injuries hit, we have never defensively looked that good before or after.
Click to expand...
Yea I remember that it was great, 2018... I was in Cairns for a bit at that time, but it was scrambling desperate hectic defense....not a controlled and consistent brick wall wave.
I feared at the time we wouldnt be able to keep up that frantic panicky D
 
liltiger said:
Ink I never forget the start of the season after Cleary had us for his first pre season. We beat Melbourne twice and the Roosters we were just winning by 1 or 2 points in real low scoring grinding games, we were defending our guts out till injuries hit, we have never defensively looked that good before or after.
Click to expand...
2010 and 11, our D noticeably lifted for both final series. Steve Folkes was head Trainer for both seasons.
Ivan had us in the grind and winning, even Packer was killing it. Then the wheels fell off the bus.
You win more games on good D than you lose.
 
Buttface said:
2010 and 11, our D noticeably lifted for both final series. Steve Folkes was head Trainer for both seasons.
Ivan had us in the grind and winning, even Packer was killing it. Then the wheels fell off the bus.
You win more games on good D than you lose.
Click to expand...
I think D is more about the connection within the group than systems/coaching. The players have had plenty of coaching when they make the grade.

i.e. how much do I really want to stop this try for my mates. If it’s not 100%, there’s your issue.
 
BAGNF05 said:
I think D is more about the connection within the group than systems/coaching. The players have had plenty of coaching when they make the grade.

i.e. how much do I really want to stop this try for my mates. If it’s not 100%, there’s your issue.
Click to expand...
I reckon it’s the whole combo, inter player connection, fitness, past and current coaching, and current structure. All of it goes into good D.
 
BAGNF05 said:
I think D is more about the connection within the group than systems/coaching. The players have had plenty of coaching when they make the grade.

i.e. how much do I really want to stop this try for my mates. If it’s not 100%, there’s your issue.
Click to expand...
Shouldn’t it be I wanna stop this try bcoz I wanna be the best player I can be?
But yeah I agree I want that mate ship connection too.
 
If the 'big signings' are done for 2025, I'd be surprised if Seyfarth isn't starting in the 2nd row, at least at first. Him or Bird- but that kind of makes them interchangable- one plays #13, one in the 2nd row.

The development of a couple of the younger players could be key- Kit Lualili'i, Matamua & Sukkar. If even 1 of these guys steps up into a 1st grade level, our forward pack takes good shape. There are others, obviously, but these 3 seem the most likely, not include Tim J.

I don't mind our forward pack. But I think we are light on for depth & aggression. My biggest complaint was how easily we got beaten up on without firing back any form of intimidation. I don't see who in our pack makes the opposition look up & worry about contact. Maybe Hunt helps. Maybe Seyfarth. Maybe Klemmer. I don't see too many JWH's in our pack. It's not like we didn't TRY to fix that, just that those types of players didn't come here. Horsborough was a miss.

Laugh all you like- I'd be adding Liam Knight on a T&T right now.
 
Buttface said:
2010 and 11, our D noticeably lifted for both final series. Steve Folkes was head Trainer for both seasons.
Ivan had us in the grind and winning, even Packer was killing it. Then the wheels fell off the bus.
You win more games on good D than you lose.
Click to expand...
If memory serves me correctly I'm pretty sure Folkes used to flog the guys, can't remember where I read it but one of the players said they never trained harder than under Folkes, he was a fitness freak.
 
The Chad said:
If the 'big signings' are done for 2025, I'd be surprised if Seyfarth isn't starting in the 2nd row, at least at first. Him or Bird- but that kind of makes them interchangable- one plays #13, one in the 2nd row.

The development of a couple of the younger players could be key- Kit Lualili'i, Matamua & Sukkar. If even 1 of these guys steps up into a 1st grade level, our forward pack takes good shape. There are others, obviously, but these 3 seem the most likely, not include Tim J.

I don't mind our forward pack. But I think we are light on for depth & aggression. My biggest complaint was how easily we got beaten up on without firing back any form of intimidation. I don't see who in our pack makes the opposition look up & worry about contact. Maybe Hunt helps. Maybe Seyfarth. Maybe Klemmer. I don't see too many JWH's in our pack. It's not like we didn't TRY to fix that, just that those types of players didn't come here. Horsborough was a miss.

Laugh all you like- I'd be adding Liam Knight on a T&T right now.
Click to expand...
Liam Knight would be a great addition on a T&T to add experience and a bit of aggression to show our younger forwards the way.
 
Last edited:
liltiger said:
If memory serves me correctly I'm pretty sure Folkes used to flog the guys, can't remember where I read it but one of the players said they never trained harder than under Folkes, he was a fitness freak.
Click to expand...
Remember when they were in the weights room the players were scared to ask if they could put on the aircon.
 
The Chad said:
Maybe Richo should ask Terrell if Tyrone is interested in playing backrow..
Click to expand...
Tyrone has made his career out of being a ball player, he doesn’t offer much in way of running the ball and does not share the same aggression as his 2 younger brothers.
Does not really have any characteristics of an NRL edge back rower.
But I do agree it would be nice to find a hidden gem somewhere to add some depth and competition to our edge back row stocks.
 
Last edited:
Vicious said:
Tyrone has made his career out of being a ball player, he doesn’t offer much in way of running the ball and does not share the same aggression as his 2 younger brothers.
Does not really have any characteristics of an NRL edge back rower.
But I do agree it would be nice to find a hidden gem somewhere to add some depth and competition to our edge back row sticks.
Click to expand...
Put him on the carnivore diet and add in some face slapping RIP Tommy.
 
Buttface said:
2010 and 11, our D noticeably lifted for both final series. Steve Folkes was head Trainer for both seasons.
Ivan had us in the grind and winning, even Packer was killing it. Then the wheels fell off the bus.
You win more games on good D than you lose.
Click to expand...

Where has this illusion come from that Packer was killing it for us at any given time? His first month was slightly above average at best.
 
Vicious said:
Tyrone has made his career out of being a ball player, he doesn’t offer much in way of running the ball and does not share the same aggression as his 2 younger brothers.
Does not really have any characteristics of an NRL edge back rower.
But I do agree it would be nice to find a hidden gem somewhere to add some depth and competition to our edge back row stocks.
Click to expand...
Call me crazy, but I'd give Naden a run as 2nd row during trials. He's big enough & definitely mobile. Nothing to lose.
 
The Chad said:
If the 'big signings' are done for 2025, I'd be surprised if Seyfarth isn't starting in the 2nd row, at least at first. Him or Bird- but that kind of makes them interchangable- one plays #13, one in the 2nd row.

The development of a couple of the younger players could be key- Kit Lualili'i, Matamua & Sukkar. If even 1 of these guys steps up into a 1st grade level, our forward pack takes good shape. There are others, obviously, but these 3 seem the most likely, not include Tim J.

I don't mind our forward pack. But I think we are light on for depth & aggression. My biggest complaint was how easily we got beaten up on without firing back any form of intimidation. I don't see who in our pack makes the opposition look up & worry about contact. Maybe Hunt helps. Maybe Seyfarth. Maybe Klemmer. I don't see too many JWH's in our pack. It's not like we didn't TRY to fix that, just that those types of players didn't come here. Horsborough was a miss.

Laugh all you like- I'd be adding Liam Knight on a T&T right now.
Click to expand...

the signings aren’t “done “ .., there isn’t anyone available at this second … have some patience … that will change…
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,379 (members: 20, guests: 1,359)
Back
Top