Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Rock Hopper Steve]

I think that’s where he ends up as well, but probably not for a few years. he’s perfectly suited to the back row currently but as he grows the middle is definitely his spot.

The thing is jr he is saying he is middle depth with Klem going, a couple of injuries and you may have to move him to the middle when we are already short on the edges, no confidence in the depth and size under Twal

 

[tigerballs]

I think that’s where he ends up as well, but probably not for a few years. he’s perfectly suited to the back row currently but as he grows the middle is definitely his spot.

No way he's a middle. He's our Olokuatu

 

[jrtiger]

I don’t believe what I’m reading sometimes.
If we go into a season with Kit Laulilli, Justin Matamua and Tim Johanssen as our first 3 middle forwards to call on as soon as we get an injury, we will finish bottom 4 and there will be nothing our class players can do about it.
They should be 3rd, 4th and 5th call ups at best.
It’s no point including Samuela Fainu and Alex Seyfarth as middles, they are required for the back row.

with two spots left, I think we need a lock and a back rower. if Taylan May hypothetically does come on the market then you clear out a Feledy, Matamua or Tumeth if need be.

Depth chart for middles reads now as follows:

May, Pole, Twal, Hunt, Bird, Si. Fainu, K. Laulili’i, Matamua, Johannssen*

 

[tigerballs]

Gotta think bigger picture than that.... it's not like Klemmer played well last year. He was average, and he wasn't going to be any better this year.

Benji most likely would've picked those guys ahead of Klemmer anyway - we really haven't lost much unless there's a big injury crisis

I think people are thinking about the Klemmer of 4-5 years ago more than the Klemmer that played last year.

Klemmer never missed a tackle and had a quick play the ball. He was well marked every run because no one else could cause any problems. Don't underestimate his contribution.

 

[Fainu Brothers]

No way he's a middle. He's our Olokuatu

Running off Luai I am expecting a massive season from Samuela

 

[GNR4LIFE]

No way he's a middle. He's our Olokuatu

He’s my smokey for club player of the year. Or player’s player. He’ll be in the mix on awards night at the end of the season.

 

[Merlot]

Gotta think bigger picture than that.... it's not like Klemmer played well last year. He was average, and he wasn't going to be any better this year.

Benji most likely would've picked those guys ahead of Klemmer anyway - we really haven't lost much unless there's a big injury crisis

I think people are thinking about the Klemmer of 4-5 years ago more than the Klemmer that played last year.

Klemmer when he moves on is not a loss.Its a waste if Molo is in some dodgy trade ,This team is being built to give a big push up the ladder(from where we are now .3peat) in a year or 2.Kit ,Johanne etc, you can fill in your own names being sprinkled threw 1st grade over the next few years will bode us well.Top class 2nd rower center will come in time.Seem to have some decent cattle there to hold the fort if injuries favour u this year And the 50/50 calls go in our favour n butterfly kiss our eyeballs.Hang tight,lol ,its not all about the next win

 

[tigerballs]

He’s my smokey for club player of the year. Or player’s player. He’ll be in the mix on awards night at the end of the season.

Players player, what an accolade. I think, and hope, you may be right.

 

[tigerballs]

with two spots left, I think we need a lock and a back rower. if Taylan May hypothetically does come on the market then you clear out a Feledy, Matamua or Tumeth if need be.

Depth chart for middles reads now as follows:

May, Pole, Twal, Hunt, Bird, Si. Fainu, K. Laulili’i, Matamua, Johannssen*

Taylan May. He's fit and ready, confident he'll be onfield by round 5. There's a spot available all of a sudden.

 

[Vicious]

with two spots left, I think we need a lock and a back rower. if Taylan May hypothetically does come on the market then you clear out a Feledy, Matamua or Tumeth if need be.

Depth chart for middles reads now as follows:

May, Pole, Twal, Hunt, Bird, Si. Fainu, K. Laulili’i, Matamua, Johannssen*

Yes but Laulilli and Matamua have not even shown they can stand out playing NSW Cup.
Johanssen has shown he can stand out at NSW Cup level, but there has to be concerns about his lightweight frame if being called upon to assist our NRL team take on the bigger more aggressive rival forward packs.
Why are we including Sam Fainu or Seyfarth as middle forward options when they will be needed exclusively as our edge forwards.
We will have a good top 17, but as soon as we get injuries to our forwards we will be up the creek without a paddle unless we sign much better depth, preferably a couple of players that are proven at NRL level.
Based on Klemmer’s likely departure I am much more concerned about our middle forward depth, than I am about our edge forward depth.
No team wins NRL games without strong middles, including the bench,

 

[Vicious]

You agree V we are 2 big middles short now and Benji comes out and says we have plenty of middles I am beginning to think the knocks on him are starting to have some legs.

He obviously doesn’t watch our NSW Cup team play as he would know who is NRL ready and who is not if he did.

 

[Tiger Stripes]

Klemmer never missed a tackle and had a quick play the ball. He was well marked every run because no one else could cause any problems. Don't underestimate his contribution.

He was gang tackled----------no quick play the balls last year.

 

[tigerballs]

Yes but Laulilli and Matamua have not even shown they can stand out playing NSW Cup.
Johanssen has shown he can stand out at NSW Cup level, but there has to be concerns about his lightweight frame if being called upon to assist our NRL team take on the bigger more aggressive rival forward packs.
Why are we including Sam Fainu or Seyfarth as middle forward options when they will be needed exclusively as our edge forwards.
We will have a good top 17, but as soon as we get injuries to our forwards we will be up the creek without a paddle unless we sign much better depth, preferably a couple of players that are proven at NRL level.
Based on Klemmer’s likely departure I am much more concerned about our middle forward depth, than I am about our edge forward depth.
No team wins NRL games without strong middles, including the bench,

I'm disappointed with Klemmer going but very happy with Hunt and May. Jjohhaannssenn can be counted on for 50 tackles and 20 runs per game. Not necessarily breaking the line or smashing people but doing a job. Pole is Pole, maybe a bit better this year. Twal, meh. I think we may miss Klemmer more than we think. All of a sudden, we may be a bit short.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

He obviously doesn’t watch our NSW Cup team play as he would know who is NRL ready and who is not if he did.

Maybe he is playing too much golf.

 

[Vicious]

Su

I'm disappointed with Klemmer going but very happy with Hunt and May. Jjohhaannssenn can be counted on for 50 tackles and 20 runs per game. Not necessarily breaking the line or smashing people but doing a job. Pole is Pole, maybe a bit better this year. Twal, meh. I think we may miss Klemmer more than we think. All of a sudden, we may be a bit short.

Surely Kit and Matamua have to play at least one or two standout games in NSW Cup before they can be considered NRL ready ?
I’m ok with releasing Klemmer if we replace him with someone else of proven NRL quality, but not for him to be replaced by players within our squad who have shown and proven nothing.

 

[Vicious]

S

Maybe he is playing too much golf.

Surely he can’t be that dumb, it’s his coaching career on the line.

 

[Telltails]

The young players have not reached their ceiling there is plenty of scope for them to improve. Klemmer on the other hand is approaching the back end much like when we had Tamou. Less chance of moving Klemmer on next season got to take opportunities when they present themselves and it opens up scope to recruit.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

S

Surely he can’t be that dumb, it’s his coaching career on the line.

Question the Klem decision give it a week to see if the media throws us something, think a signing might be happening behind the scenes.

 

[Needaname]

Jack Wighton?

Good call.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

The young players have not reached their ceiling there is plenty of scope for them to improve. Klemmer on the other hand is approaching the back end much like when we had Tamou. Less chance of moving Klemmer on next season got to take opportunities when they present themselves and it opens up scope to recruit.

Agree but how does that help the now, real quality is still lacking behind Hunt, Terell and Pole in the middle.