Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[batboy]

Great career move that was. He’d be a regular first grader had he stayed.

You use the term first grader very loosely…
He’d be another reserve grader playing first grade because he’s being paid too much and he might have 1.5 games for his entire contract.

He’ll go to rugby where you can happily mope around like you’re shopping with the missus and kick stones with no urgency

 

[Tom Shines]

He runs pretty hard mate. He’s got potential. Definitely would be first reserve winger if Skelton or Turuva are out.

I was pretty disappointed with him last season … he was ok his first year ,,if you have a weakness under the high ball these days it will be exploited … maybe $250k max and they only need to call on him 5-6 times a year in the NRL …probably needs to be winger 4

 

[Tim Sheens]

He can’t catch a ball even on the end of a backline let alone under a bomb…

Major red flag that the Dolphins are happy for him to leave 6 months into a three year deal,,,

Wasn't that long ago that the chooks were happy for Terrell to leave. Not at the same level, sure, though everything is relative dollar wise and Tupou should at least be considered.

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

He can’t catch a ball even on the end of a backline let alone under a bomb…

Major red flag that the Dolphins are happy for him to leave 6 months into a three year deal,,,

Because they’re paying him to be a starter when he’s just a depth option. For around 300k (Fins chip in the rest) you wouldn’t take him back?

 

[Odessa]

Junior Tupou given permission to talk to rival clubs… would you guys take him back for depth? I personally would tbh.

Not unless it's a contract around the 200K mark

 

[BAGNF05]

Surely we’ve moved on from flippers and Toops

Spoon players need not apply.

 

[TSP]

Not unless it's a contract around the 200K mark

Brutal!

 

[mtd#2]

During his training?

He said he was "required" to go when he did.

Thats unlikely.

Hes got non training periods to attend if he wants to and im sure the cops could have booked him in later.

If hes helping them, they would like to help him.

Mate it's domestic violence with a family member.

I think he's a fat cnt that needed to lose weight and probably was a poor trainer who needed an attitude adjustment, but I think it's a bit rough to make judgement in such a sensitive issue.

The tigers probably just used this as an excuse to cut him and create roster spots and salary cap space... Whether it was fair or not I'm not privy tO

But he's a kid who obviously had some family issues and I think that we need to factor in theres emotion involved and if the cops asked him to go to the station, that is technically them requiring him to go..he's a footy player not a fkn expert in law

 

[Tom Shines]

Because they’re paying him to be a starter when he’s just a depth option. For around 300k (Fins chip in the rest) you wouldn’t take him back?

made a comment earlier…. I’ll say further that I would rather Luke L to be honest ..who is already in the Top 30 ..

I was pretty disappointed with him last season … he was ok his first year ,,if you have a weakness under the high ball these days it will be exploited … maybe $250k max and they only need to call on him 5-6 times a year in the NRL …probably needs to be winger 4

 

[BUGSY MALONE]

Yes at the right price 300k - 350k tops.

🙃👎

 

[hank37w]

I brought this up on the weekend he will have a lot of trust to earn.
Romey and Apis mates at the dogs would know whats going on... youd have to be on mars not to...
Theyve been going pretty good at Belmore and now some upstart waltzes in...ive no doubt thered be a few sideways glances.
He had Tallyn here...whos he got there?
His old coach...lol...no one ever liked the teachers pet

Didn't Galvin even complain at one stage that Luai was the teacher's (Benji's) pet. 🤣

 

[liltiger]

My understand too - 3rd party deals must be arms length…..but then again since when do NRL abide by their own rules

It's just a magical coincidence everytime the Broncos, Roosters, Storm and Bulldogs need one, it just magically appears out of nowhere at the perfect time.

 

[liltiger]

Great question. No they haven’t. They have no interest in creating a scandal for the game via uncovering a salary cap breach.

Imagine the conversation the people in power from Melbourne would have had with their secretary, after they asked the N.R.L auditor if they required the copy of the books in the safe aswell. Lol.

 

[TSP]

Mate it's domestic violence with a family member.

I think he's a fat cnt that needed to lose weight and probably was a poor trainer who needed an attitude adjustment, but I think it's a bit rough to make judgement in such a sensitive issue.

The tigers probably just used this as an excuse to cut him and create roster spots and salary cap space... Whether it was fair or not I'm not privy tO

But he's a kid who obviously had some family issues and I think that we...

Hes got training and he knows he should be there. Thats what we are paying him for.

If hed asked the cops if he could make his statement after training, 99% chance theyd agree.

He tells the club he was required to make a statement during the training.

And probably unfair to invoke and use the cops like this as an excuse.

Unless theres more info, i cant blame the club for finding his excuse mysterious.

 

[crazycat]

Maybe not. Maybe Adam is staying. How do you justify the rest of your column.

I justify it simply by asking:

"What did we build when we were the spoon?"

Seriously, what?
Ricky when he lost a stack of games at Cronulla was building defensive structures. It was the right decision as he did not have the cattle to be competitive.
When your last, you build your team back so that next year... You are not last.
We front loaded No one. We fluked a good forward in May and good wingers. and that's it.

 

[TSP]

Forum crash is over, yay!

I thought everyone was banned, mods got tired of us!

 

[Demps]

Player discussed earlier this week,
Kurt Morrin.

Rumoured to be signing with the Gold Coast Titans.

 

[Ecto-1]

Forum crash is over, yay!

I thought everyone was banned, mods got tired of us!

Galvin was powering the forum. With him gone 💥

 

[Rugba]

Player discussed earlier this week,
Kurt Morrin.

Rumoured to be signing with the Gold Coast Titans.

How many more forwards the titans getting

 

[mtd#2]

Hes got training and he knows he should be there. Thats what we are paying him for.

If hed asked the cops if he could make his statement after training, 99% chance theyd agree.

He tells the club he was required to make a statement during the training.

And probably unfair to invoke and use the cops like this as an excuse.

Unless theres more info, i cant blame the club for finding his excuse mysterious.

So I understand @TSP if someone was to walk into your house and belt a family member of yours across the face.. The cops arrive... Then ask you to come down to the station to make a statement... Youd leave for work instead.

I am grateful you aren't a member of my family.