Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

It looks like we now have decent depth all round except for the back row and KPP will help out on that front.
Sukkar was acceptable in defence but if you're playing NRL you really can't be serving up 4 runs for 27 metres in 80 minutes.
If an edge is offering nothing it just gives the opposition too much of a leg up. He really was the invisible man out there.
Other than that our squad really is starting to look good with the pressure that our KOE boys are providing.

 

[Odessa]

It looks like we now have decent depth all round except for the back row and KPP will help out on that front.
Sukkar was acceptable in defence but if you're playing NRL you really can't be serving up 4 runs for 27 metres in 80 minutes.
If an edge is offering nothing it just gives the opposition too much of a leg up. He really was the invisible man out there.
Other than that our squad really is starting to look good with the pressure that our KOE boys are providing.

How many starting first grade games has he played ?

 

[crazycat]

400k?!
He's a backup. Not a top 17 player.
He's a 200k player. Not a centre. A backup half maybe at best.

re AD... which game?

I am serious, I have seen him earn a 700k paycheck and I have seen him play at 130K standard.

Somestimes the guy kills it. With us vs Easts, no AD means no win.
Yet he has gone AWOL in a few games.

I mean seriously... AD had been given the Center spot in our team a few times and really pushed back against that. Yet he rarely shines in the halves, but occasionally it all just clicks.

AD is WAY too hot and cold to keep.

You can't pay big money to players outside your 17.

BINGO!!!
^this.

 

[Odessa]

Does anyone know when this year's articles about how the mighty West Tigers should relocate are coming out

We have been inundated with articles about Galvin TDS Benji and Richo I was thinking I mite have missed them so I went back had a lot look and there not out yet

It's one of my favourite reads each season and then the discussions about should we move to Perth or join another team

I was hoping for a Adelaide push this year the city of churches would be nice and make a change

 

[Spartan117]

It looks like we now have decent depth all round except for the back row and KPP will help out on that front.
Sukkar was acceptable in defence but if you're playing NRL you really can't be serving up 4 runs for 27 metres in 80 minutes.
If an edge is offering nothing it just gives the opposition too much of a leg up. He really was the invisible man out there.
Other than that our squad really is starting to look good with the pressure that our KOE boys are providing.

Tony Sukkar had a very decent game against the roosters.

He is a hulk of a human, very mobile and young.

He will be very very good.

 

[batboy]

Just wanted to say it’s the first time in NRL history where a set of 3 brothers has scored in one game 🐯 love the fainu’s

Latu’s words regarding Benji was also admirable

NRL maybe - Mortimers did it previously...

 

[BBTF]

Tony Sukkar had a very decent game against the roosters.

He is a hulk of a human, very mobile and young.

He will be very very good.

I thought he was solid but I have not seen anything to suggest 'very very' good

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

At the moment any suggestion that Sukkar will ever offer any sort of option in attack is pure speculation. He hasn't shown that he can do that in any grade.
Samuela's just shouldering too much of the burden making him a target for the opposition.

 

[tiger05premier]

Bula is a quality player and Richardson has said in the ABC interview the club will activate his clause for 2027. He is the type of player you want injecting himself when he senses an opportunity, not doing hit ups which can be done by other players. He will be even more effective with Latu Fainu a genuine threat every time he has the ball in hand. I am looking forward to the combination they build

Hopefully he signs an extension when the time comes to negotiate with him

 

[Jolls]

Bula is a quality player and Richardson has said in the ABC interview the club will activate his clause for 2027. He is the type of player you want injecting himself when he senses an opportunity, not doing hit ups which can be done by other players. He will be even more effective with Latu Fainu a genuine threat every time he has the ball in hand. I am looking forward to the combination they build

That may be true but he has to be there to inject himself. Bula is rarely in around the back of the ruck looking to take advantage of May's offload or a Pole half break. This is a key weakness.

 

[madgey76]

It looks like we now have decent depth all round except for the back row and KPP will help out on that front.
Sukkar was acceptable in defence but if you're playing NRL you really can't be serving up 4 runs for 27 metres in 80 minutes.
If an edge is offering nothing it just gives the opposition too much of a leg up. He really was the invisible man out there.
Other than that our squad really is starting to look good with the pressure that our KOE boys are providing.

You need to go listen to Adel Hage with Bechara on the game today Adel mentioned Sukkar and made a great point, good podcast I watch it every week

 

[pawsandclaws1]

You need to go listen to Adel Hage with Bechara on the game today Adel mentioned Sukkar and made a great point, good podcast I watch it every week

Sukkar was mentioned by one of the commentators yesterday as playing very well. I cannot remember which Roosters' forward it was but Sukkar and Seyfarth made the tackle and it was Sukkar who hit him hard under the rib cage. There was tremendous drive in the tackle and the Rooster felt it. That is typical of him

 

[clontarfkid]

ADs effort in recent years has been very inconsistent..sometimes hehas a crack..sometimes he doesnt
Noticable than since hes realised hes gonna be unemployed .hes really put in with probably a prod from his new manager

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

Bula is a quality player and Richardson has said in the ABC interview the club will activate his clause for 2027. He is the type of player you want injecting himself when he senses an opportunity, not doing hit ups which can be done by other players. He will be even more effective with Latu Fainu a genuine threat every time he has the ball in hand. I am looking forward to the combination they build

I listened to Richo on the ABC yesterday.
In regard to Bula he only said that there's a clause in the Tigers favour and IF they choose to activate it is up to the club.
He was very positive, but it's still an if.

 

[Tom Shines]

How many starting first grade games has he played ?

I think that was his second start …

I don’t want to knock him too much .., he certainly had an ok game in defence with 37 tackles and 3 missed …

But you gotta make more of an effort than that in attack whether it’s your 1st or 200th

Unless of course he is playing to the coach’s instructions… but that would be odd

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I listened to Richo on the ABC yesterday.
In regard to Bula he only said that there's a clause in the Tigers favour and IF they choose to activate it is up to the club.
He was very positive, but it's still an if.

Doesn’t activating it mean they’d be paying him 900k? And it’s till the end of 28 isn’t it?

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

Doesn’t activating it mean they’d be paying him 900k? And it’s till the end of 28 isn’t it?

Yep.
Personally I prefer what Turuva offered, Bula will never be a player that involves himself enough.

 

[Odessa]

I think that was his second start …

I don’t want to knock him too much .., he certainly had an ok game in defence with 37 tackles and 3 missed …

But you gotta make more of an effort than that in attack whether it’s your 1st or 200th

Unless of course he is playing to the coach’s instructions… but that would be odd

A young kid playing his second I think he went well lots of upside to him

Hopefully he can be in the 17 for the rest of the year

 

[pawsandclaws1]

A young kid playing his second I think he went well lots of upside to him

Hopefully he can be in the 17 for the rest of the year

Sione Fainu and Tony Sukkar are two good prospects who have emerged from our non-development system.

 

[Odessa]

I think that was his second start …

I don’t want to knock him too much .., he certainly had an ok game in defence with 37 tackles and 3 missed …

But you gotta make more of an effort than that in attack whether it’s your 1st or 200th

Unless of course he is playing to the coach’s instructions… but that would be odd

I remember a kid at the dogs years ago a young number 7 playing for the dogs in his second or third game from the bench dropped the ball 3 times in about 25 minutes two of them easy takes and missed 4 tackles but the way he moved you could see something about him

He went on to play for the Cowboys for many years became a very good player sometimes you just need some time to adjust