Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[GNR4LIFE]

Anyone notice TDS is still listed in our squad on our site?

 

[weststigerman]

100% coach is playing busted players , Skelton and Toa I feel ,

Yep. For all the criticism of Madge doing this, Benji is doing the same thing.

To’a can’t use his fend so is ineffective in attack and not tackling like he did earlier in the year.

Samuela has been playing injured all year too.

 

[tigahhh]

richo needs to raid that Wahs NSW cup team, sell them a path to first grade
some great forwards in there
benji can use that kiwi connection

 

[Tiger Stripes]

I actually thought Luai’s kicking game was too long yesterday ! He has a longer boot than I thought … but seems to overreach on the bombs ..

Agreed, he kicked so long the chasers gave up 20m from where the ball landed so they took up defensive positions. Benji's instructions, "play it in their half"?
Why didn't Benji get the message to Luai, "not so deep" its not working.
The original game plan needed adjustments as our troops weren't up to it. But no plan B?

 

[Tom Shines]

richo needs to raid that Wahs NSW cup team, sell them a path to first grade
some great forwards in there
benji can use that kiwi connection

I watch that teams highlights most weeks … a lot of good young kids there

 

[Tiger Stripes]

Turuva isn’t a long term prospect at the back.
He is extremely one dimensional and even though that has been a breath of fresh air so far, opposition defences will soon understand that there is zero nuance to his attack. There is no deception, no ballplaying, just hard fast returns.
Bula offers a hell of a lot more and I have no doubt we’d still be 2 & 2 had he been there as those two wins were against a side missing most of their team and the worst performed side in the comp

I don't recall Turuva ever passing the ball? No intension to set up plays.
Head down, arse up at full speed..........THAT'S IT, there is no more.

 

[Ron Brodrick's Spirit]

[Edit: post removed]

Yeah , they're both the same.
Twal hasn't missed a tackle since Jesus was a boy and Klemmer's a turnstyle.


Can I ask why the abusive insults are necessary?
Just have an adult conversation.

 

[Tiger Stripes]

Agree with this. KPP and Sam Fainu in the team replace Sukkar and Bird. Makasini is projected to be a starter next year. Bula comes in and Turuva takes over his wing spot. We don’t need a lot but we need quality in certain positions. Lock, Prop, utility, back row depth.

We need better play from our spine if we ever get them playing multiple games together.

Cleary did bugger all in that game other thank kick. With all the time in the world to do so?
Where was Latu when we had the ball. Seemed to be smothered in defenders so passed it to Luai.
Where was he standing? Where were his protectors?
Some serious questions Mr Benji and attack coach.

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

roycey’s run in that first try 👀

Is it possible what my eyes have witnessed in that vid, he looks to have trimmed down some, if it's not an optical illusion bring him in next game, we are really missing a big man's runs.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

Not sure I like us writing off Skelton.

He is very clearly not 100%.

He is not worth having,
His reading of play both in attack and defence is terrible.

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

We could sign Andrew Johns in his prime but Marshall would tell him to just kick on last that’s it. Clubs going no where till he’s gone.

 

[TigerBurnsy]

We could sign Andrew Johns in his prime but Marshall would tell him to just kick on last that’s it. Clubs going no where till he’s gone.

spot on, benji and all of his assistants (his mates who can't get a job at another club) are an absolute handbrake on any progress for this club

 

[TigerBurnsy]

and

View this content on Instagram

View this content on Instagram

roycey’s run in that first try 👀

idk why we dont bring up some players from cup to replace our injured players, the magpies have been in good form for a while now and benji is playing people at 50%

 

[TYGA]

Cleary did bugger all in that game other thank kick. With all the time in the world to do so?
Where was Latu when we had the ball. Seemed to be smothered in defenders so passed it to Luai.
Where was he standing? Where were his protectors?
Some serious questions Mr Benji and attack coach.

Our issues summarised as someone that played the game for a long time. Not NRL level.

1. Line speed and contact in defence, wrestle is poor teams make too many metres and kick off the front foot and often pin us back. We get limited to no kick pressure.

2. Back 3 outside or Turuva and before injury Skelton make no metres out of trouble.

3. When we kick its off a slow play the ball and from deep in our own end.

4. Our kickers Latu and Luai are good but don’t have massive boots.

5. We have errors in us fielding kicks particularly Skelton who gets targeted often.

Teams like Penrith which grind retain field position and strangle us to a bitter end. Like clockwork they bomb the wingers and pin is back.

There is only one way out of it recruit players that can do these things and train the house down in the offseason.

I wish it was the coach that’s an easy solution for wishful thinkers or those that have an axe to grind. Teams that play like Penrith with their quality will beat us 99/100 times when motivated. This is the end of the season we get beat down by premiership sides.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

I don’t know mate …. Isn’t one of Richo’s main functions to find them ? You can’t say that contracted players won’t become available ,,,they are made available every offseason

I added Twal to the list … the 4 I mentioned need to be down the depth chart and out of the Best 17 ,, I don’t think they need to be “moved on” … we have KPP and Sam to come in…. Leaves 2 more spots at a minimum to be filled …

Sam who.

 

[BUGSY MALONE]

Klemmer was a better option than Twal, let that sink in.

WINNIE I agree with you in respect of A.T! Seems like a great fella and is very good at singing the Team Song after a win (though he hasn't had to exercise his tonsils of late) but seriously he has been part of a threepete Wooden Spoon side. He would a huge success as the Captain of the Wests Magpies NSW CUP side.

 

[Tom Shines]

Teams like Penrith which grind retain field position and strangle us to a bitter end. Like clockwork they bomb the wingers and pin is back.

I agree with this point in particular ..Ok we all know that Penrith are a pretty damn good and well coached side ( still), but most other teams also are more than happy to grind away up the middle all day when they play us, minimising errors and playing the field position game… they know that provided they don’t beat themselves, they will eventually get on top and win the game …

Until our players get mentally tougher and play for 80 ( won’t happen this season ) I think it’s kinda pointless for WT also choosing to playing this style… although playing another way is probably harder to do…

Sam who.

Fainu … he didn’t play yesterday right ?

 

[weststigers]

Benji wanted to “get into the grind “ with the Panthers last night… how did that work for them 🤔… our boys had 20 minutes only in them playing this way .. why play a game style that suits the opponent ?

Also … any chance they can contest some attacking kicks every once in a while? Most other teams successfully disrupt attacking kicks and get repeat sets inside the opponent 20 .. we don’t even try… the only one all season that attempts this is Bula

The non-competing on the bomb shits me no end. When they actually do it, they get results.

 

[Ermo]

Our attack has zero structure and when we hit the ball up it’s very easy to gang tackle.

I’d be happy for the attacking coach to watch every game of the top 4 teams this year and just copy their plays. Would have to be better than the shite dished up so far.

 

[BUGSY MALONE]

I’m not sure why it’s relevant who is on the other side ? If it was Martin, then 95 percent of the opposition attack would be coming Seyfarth’s way ..so there is that…

Seyfarth has no business being an NRL starter in my view …. I know he does his best but he lacks the physicality…his better games this year have been off the bench , so that’s where I would consider him exclusively

There is no shame in hoping for a better player than Twal to push him out of the 17,,., if he is the first middle reserve he will still end up playing half the games minimum .. Hunt has had a go already and failed … I dont know why there would be an expectation things would be better the next time … seems like deckchairs on the Titanic planning …even last year in a better forward pack he was only playing 10-15 minutes … we need better

You have SHINED TOM with your comments above on Seyfarth! Just like Alex Twal, Seyfarth has been an integral part of the side that has won three Wooden Spoons in a row. I also agree with you on moving Rex Hunt on and sadly it is also bye bye BIRDIE!