I agree that as an all rounder, Critta is better.
But as a centre, and just a centre, I think they are basically on par - but with Taylans speed and acceleration off the mark, he'd be my preferree option...
Food for thought:
I reckon if the Bulldogs played Critta at 6 and Burton at 7 (instead of the failed Galvin experiment) they could have won the comp this year.
Critta looks soooooooo damn dangerous when he's drifting across field.. he draws in soooo many more defenders than your average 6 or 7 because of his size.. and he can throw a very strong and fast passes to his outside men once the overlap is created.. h
I can't remember which bulldogs game it was this year, but critta got more involved and basically took on the role as 1st/2nd receiver.. the dogs looked the best in attack they had all year... I was surprised Ciraldo didn't shift gears and give him more of that responsibility