Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

what is ADs best position ? This is the problem with him … whilst I agree there have been times over the past two years he has been our best player ( we are one of the weakest teams in the comp) .. there doesn’t appear to be a natural fit for him… a half must be able to pass the ball and set up outside players… I also really question his motor to play at 13 …this leaves him with a bench spot which I could deal with , although I’m not sure his ego will.

I think to give him a now three year committment is looking like a poor decision .,even at $500k per year …

I really question what the plan is for Andrews … you think if there was mutual interest they would have gone in hard to lock him up already ,,,he can now sign elsewhere for 2028 and he is QLD boy that might look north for his next opportunity
AD is clearly best as a dangerous ball running 6, with a dominant 7 alongside him, as evident when Jock was the dominant 7 early on in the 2026 season.
As recently spoken about by Kevin Walters, your dangerous ball runners are most effective when you have dangerous ball running edge back rowers who are regularly running good lines to get the opponents attention. That rarely happened after round 9 in the 2026 season.
Neither Latu Fainu or Javon Andrews would be starting halves at any rival NRL club just yet.
Both have undeniable talent and they are hopefully our long term NRL halves pairing, but while they are still maturing into NRL quality halves, why not plan to start them as our NSW Cup halves pairing in 2027 and if they are playing well enough they can overtake the players in front of them during the season.
Assuming we would be paying Doueihi approximately 500k and Fogarty approximately 600k, that is still very cheap for NRL halves and means it’s no major issue if younger, lesser paid players are playing so well that they take their NRL positions during the season.
 
Last edited:
You find another way to get Fogarty. This kid has been screwed around enough. And if @kade7 is to be believed, I only feel further justified in what I said. Their acknowledging that they have failed in their handling of him.

How about this logic ? Don’t move Latu at all to sign a 34 year old half …

Yes Kade said he will remain at the club or be elsewhere in 2027…. I can guarantee with 100 percent certainty one of those two things will happen
 
I hope he goes to a good club and gets some proper guidance and doesn’t come back. Best thing he’ll do for his career
He goes to a good club, he’s not coming back. I don’t care if the club thinks they are being diligent in re-signing him. Sullivan had two years left here. Given how easily players get out of contracts you’re playing with fire if you send a player away for a year who you genuinely value.
 
The only way I would even be remotely happy with all of this would be if the following were to occur:
  • The club announces that Latu has been signed for 2028 and 2029 to the satisfaction of the Fainu's and their manager.
  • The Fainu's (whole family) state that they are happy with Latu going on loan somewhere else for one season to give him guaranteed NRL experience to assist with the development that he has not been able to receive here in his favoured halves position.
  • That whoever takes Latu for a season guarantees that he plays a minimum guaranteed number of NRL games subject to him being available to play. ie. not injured or suspended and that he does not languish in reserve grade or is played out of position.
  • That the club that takes him on loan for the season pays full freight or close to it for the year that they have him and there is little or virtually no salary cap cost to the Wests Tigers, a reason we are currently being told is needed so that we can sign other players.
  • That a list of potential clubs is released that can guarantee they will meet the above conditions.
When all the above is provided I might consider this to be beneficial to both Latu and the club, until then it's not worthy of consideration.
 
How about this logic ? Don’t move Latu at all to sign a 34 year old half …

Yes Kade said he will remain at the club or be elsewhere in 2027…. I can guarantee with 100 percent certainty one of those two things will happen
32, not 34. I’m sure that Latu isn’t going to make or break that deal.
 
Mate , Galvin wanted out before he played a first grade game … he refused to even look at their over the odds offer … his pathway was never blocked ,,,,far from it ,,,they put him in the NRL as soon as they could ,,,the reality is that he was never going to stay here …didn’t want to and he was always going to have other options

Latu could have been handled better , although from memory this time last season you weren’t that keen either to play him in the NRL team in 2026… his injury issues have hampered his development primarily IMO..
Incorrect on Galvin, he wanted out after Luai entered and started his power trip.
 
AD is clearly best as a dangerous ball running 6, with a dominant 7 alongside him, as evident when Jock was the dominant 7 early on in the 2026 season.
As recently spoken about by Kevin Walters, your dangerous ball runners are most effective when you have dangerous ball running edge back rowers who are regularly running good lines to get the opponents attention. That rarely happened after round 9 in the 2026 season.
Neither Latu Fainu or Javon Andrews would be starting halves at any rival NRL club just yet.
Both have undeniable talent and they are hopefully our long term NRL halves pairing, but while they are still maturing into NRL quality halves, why not plan to start them as our NSW Cup halves pairing in 2027 and if they are playing well enough they can overtake the players in front of them during the season.
Assuming we would be paying Doueihi approximately 500k and Fogarty approximately 600k, that is still very cheap for NRL halves and means it’s no major issue if younger, lesser paid players are playing so well tgat they take their NRL positions throughout the season.

Agree to disagree that AD is a half … it doesn’t mean that he isn’t an NRL player ,.. but that’s not a great position for him, and I think it has contributed to our clunky style and struggles in the opposition 20..

I see no reason why Latu could not be the 7 to start the season if fit
 
Incorrect on Galvin, he wanted out after Luai entered and started his power trip.

Why ? His postion In the team was never in question ? They picked him in the NRL team as soon as he was of age and never dropped him until he was out the door..

If anything Luai actually deferred to him on the field
 
I think the harm is that Latu is the half we have that can really tear oppositions apart but he is the one being held back constantly.
Agreed, but based on how his development as a halve has already been mishandled over the past couple of years, don’t you think it’s a good idea to at least start him playing NSW Cup in 2027 preferably alongside Javon, to let him build his confidence and work on areas that need improvement such as him taking ownership and his kicking game?
If he strings together sone quality games, than get him into our NRL team straight away.
 
Last edited:
Mail
the club wants latu to spend time in cup next year, latu open to it, club also happy for him to play elsewhere including superleague they do see him as our future, but want to make sure he isnt thrown into a furnace like every other prodigal son that we heap pressure on to

the club will not let him leave until a deal is done, his brothers are locked in, club working with nrl to clear a path for mainse
The club wants Latu to spend time in Cup? Then why didn’t they do that this year instead of jerking him around and wasting him on the bench with scrap minutes at hooker every now and then instead of just playing him in Cup at 7 with Javon???

You can’t make this shit up, we’re such a dumb [This word has been automatically removed]ing club.
 
Let’s split the difference…he turns 33 in a couple of weeks …

How much do you like 33 year old half backs ?
Better than a 26 year old spare parts halfback and another guy who would rather play 7 in reserve grade than lock in first grade. I’m usually the first person to shit can mid 30’s signings. Mann and to a lesser extent Frizell are pretty average signings imo. But Fogarty is kind of essential given the corner we’ve backed ourselves into with our halves.
 
Better than a 26 year old spare parts halfback and another guy who would rather play 7 in reserve grade than lock in first grade. I’m usually the first person to shit can mid 30’s signings. Mann and to a lesser extent Frizell are pretty average signings imo. But Fogarty is kind of essential given the corner we’ve backed ourselves into with our halves.

you are entitled to your opinion as am I … I think he had a down year at Manly which at his age can be a big flashing warning sign ..

When he was first connected with the club, my thoughts were he might be an ok signing for 1 year given Latu ‘s injury concerns and the problems with AD at the position … also on the provision Manly we’re going to pick up a big chunk of the freight …

He certainly in my mind isn’t worth causing dramas with having to move on other young players even for 1 season …makes no sense to me ..
 
you are entitled to your opinion as am I … I think he had a down year at Manly which at his age can be a big flashing warning sign ..

When he was first connected with the club, my thoughts were he might be an ok signing for 1 year given Latu ‘s injury concerns and the problems with AD at the position … also on the provision Manly we’re going to pick up a big chunk of the freight …

He certainly in my mind isn’t worth causing dramas with having to move on other young players even for 1 season …makes no sense to me ..
Don’t think it’s a year either he’s contracted for 2028
 
Absolute sh*tshow of a Board at HBG. Reading between the lines, the rugby league faction is now scared of the soccer faction.
Exactly what I was thinking. I was wondering what all these unspecified charges are and wonder whether you can validly stand people down without advising what they're suspected of, and who will do the investigation. Dennis B has to be kept as far away as possible of that bit
 
Nothing about this makes sense. Also, if you loan him, you cant guarantee what role he will gave, you lose control of his development. This shows how poor Benji is as a coach, it really does.
Thats my concern right from the start of this...if its al l true....if his loan club only has him for a year theyre not going to be concenrned at all for his future and well-being.
Its like having a company car you know will be replaced in 2 or 3 years...theyre not looked after as well as a vehicle.privately owned
 
Don’t think it’s a year either he’s contracted for 2028

Yes .. I’ve always been against 2 years ..: I think there would need to be an understanding tnat at the club’s discretion he moves on next to the ESL in 2028 .. we have seen other oldies do this ( most recently Bird) .., if he didn’t want to agree to this I would be saying no deal
 
Back
Top