Adam Doueihi #227

Vicious said:
You know more than Cronk, maybe we can get you on our coaching staff ?
Doueihi‘s recent form has been a fluke, we don’t want halves who have a long kicking game, are a running threat, make line breaks, score tries, dig into the line to create opportunities and line breaks for others.
Why would we want all of that ?
Click to expand...
He's played 2 games at halfback and 1 at 5/8 all season. One of them we got thumped by last placed Parramatta. Relax.
 
Tucker said:
Clearly I don’t agree.
Luai has been phoning it in most of the year.
He talks a big game off field then does little on it. The bloke couldn’t organise a root in a brothel so he’s the sticking point…we have one half and supposed leader who is not living up to his promise and enormous price tag and we are baulking at offering a bloke who is displaying more in both areas the opportunity to earn a third of that salary.
It appears once again we will let a non PI walk away. You need a balanced squad. Hive minds do not work.
Click to expand...
Bogan assumptions are not helpful
 
Merlot said:
thats funny ,besides the last month Adam has done jack in the last 3 years . He is the king of mediocrity, telling us all he is a captain worth twice the price , but giving mostly nothing but lip serive
Click to expand...
What is even funnier is you totally disregarding that it’s quite usual for a player with a high grade partial tear of an ACL to have a recovery period of 12 to 18 months.
I don’t think it’s being overly generous to acknowledge the courage and determination that he showed to get back on the park.
He’s come back better than ever. He’s taking every opportunity and not letting go.
We have nobody better than Adam in 2 positions he plays 13 & 7, and unless we see some kind of divine intervention it will remain this way for the next 2 seasons.
 
hank37w said:
I thought we have signed him twice now on a one year deal or extension, what ever way you want to call it.
Click to expand...
I think that’s correct. Still doesn’t change things. He’s only been getting one year extensions so he hasn’t had a chance to slacken off. And that’s taking into account all of his injuries.
 
Halbrowne61 said:
Given all the hoo ha about Latu, and whilst I get what you’re saying, imho it was still a bold move to play him at 7.
Click to expand...
Bold? Maybe, our emphatic win vs Panthers at Bathurst in 2023 would have been top of Benji’s thoughts. It was vintage Tim Sheens showing Benji how to win in the rain. That time our kicker was Luke Brooks, keeping the premiers on the back foot.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
I think that’s correct. Still doesn’t change things. He’s only been getting one year extensions so he hasn’t had a chance to slacken off. And that’s taking into account all of his injuries.
Click to expand...
My thoughts about the short contact extensions are that he has only been able to perform in a handful of games and those being very much towards the end of this latest contract.

Kind of makes you think of what he might be thinking, "Gee, I haven't got much time left to impress for a new contract, I better pull my finger out and show something." 🤣

They are just my thoughts on him, just want to see something from him on a more regular basis and time is running out.
 
hank37w said:
My thoughts about the short contact extensions are that he has only been able to perform in a handful of games and those being very much towards the end of this latest contract.

Kind of makes you think of what he might be thinking, "Gee, I haven't got much time left to impress for a new contract, I better pull my finger out and show something." 🤣

They are just my thoughts on him, just want to see something from him on a more regular basis and time is running out.
Click to expand...
Well, to this point, he’s almost our player of the year. Definitely the player who’s had the most influence on the field. I remember he had a blinder in the Parra trial, but it was a trial, so didn’t really get that much fanfare. But the signs were there even then. He’s easily earned a two year deal.
 
I'm really torn over the guy, not sure if he is only putting in now looking for a contract and then there is that constant injury concern, I guess at the sub $500k (maybe $450k tops) for two years he currently looks like better value than some of our current signings.

I guess we will probably end up doing it and if he does get another serious injury then that is probably game over for him and we probably get a top 30 spot back and cap relief, so probably not the worst thing we could do.
 
hank37w said:
My thoughts about the short contact extensions are that he has only been able to perform in a handful of games and those being very much towards the end of this latest contract.

Kind of makes you think of what he might be thinking, "Gee, I haven't got much time left to impress for a new contract, I better pull my finger out and show something." 🤣

They are just my thoughts on him, just want to see something from him on a more regular basis and time is running out.
Click to expand...
Gee Hank, I’d hate to think AD, or any of our players, could just flick a switch and go from mediocre to outstanding just like that ! Whilst he’s had a standout month I think there are other factors in play, as well as maybe some increased effort.
Either way, the $64 questions are, where does he play long term, how much do we offer and how long do we keep him.
The way it’s going it looks like we won’t have to worry coz $350k looks like our top offer, which actually means, we don’t want or need you
 
Halbrowne61 said:
Gee Hank, I’d hate to think AD, or any of our players, could just flick a switch and go from mediocre to outstanding just like that ! Whilst he’s had a standout month I think there are other factors in play, as well as maybe some increased effort.
Either way, the $64 questions are, where does he play long term, how much do we offer and how long do we keep him.
The way it’s going it looks like we won’t have to worry coz $350k looks like our top offer, which actually means, we don’t want or need you
Click to expand...
I think AD would be smart to accept 350K next year with a clause in there for 27’ based on his performance at lock. If he can nail that down it prolongs his career and would earn him better coin.
 
Demps said:
He's insanely overrated as a player, a commentator and a "personality" ... hard to call him that because he lacks any personality imo.

I agree.
Click to expand...
gee that's rough.

Forget the winning record, but even his style of playing, his kicking game, short passing game was elite. He was a great clutch player. He is considered a tier below Smith, Slater, JT etc but he should be in the same class as them.

As a commentator, I agree, he is quite bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moh
tig_prmz said:
gee that's rough.

Forget the winning record, but even his style of playing, his kicking game, short passing game was elite. He was a great clutch player. He is considered a tier below Smith, Slater, JT etc but he should be in the same class as them.

As a commentator, I agree, he is quite bad.
Click to expand...
As big of a douchebag as he is, I think he was always in that top tier.
 
BAGNF05 said:
I think AD would be smart to accept 350K next year with a clause in there for 27’ based on his performance at lock. If he can nail that down it prolongs his career and would earn him better coin.
Click to expand...
Maybe yr 2 is a club option for $500k??
That cls work for all parties except maybe Dragons,,,if theyre actually offering more (and it cld just be I Moses dicking around)
 
BAGNF05 said:
I think AD would be smart to accept 350K next year with a clause in there for 27’ based on his performance at lock. If he can nail that down it prolongs his career and would earn him better coin.
Click to expand...
He is not a 13 and doesn’t want to play 13, he wants to play his best position which is somewhere in the halves.
Considering he continues to show he is our most influential player when he plays 7, you would think common sense tells you that’s where we would continue to play him.
But not Wests Tigers and its fans, when something works well we decide it’s a good idea to throw that in the bin and try something different.
And we wonder why it’s been so long since we last played finals.
 
Vicious said:
He is not a 13 and doesn’t want to play 13, he wants to play his best position which is somewhere in the halves.
Considering he continues to show he is our most influential player when he plays 7, you would think common sense tells you that’s where we would continue to play him.
But not Wests Tigers and its fans, when something works well we decide it’s a good idea to throw that in the bin and try something different.
And we wonder why it’s been so long since we last played finals.
Click to expand...
Works? After 1 game? Way more time needed to see if he can play halfback. Definately better than 5/8th though. He's pretty fast but his acceleration is not.

Shame he doesn't want to play lock because it could work.
 
Vicious said:
He is not a 13 and doesn’t want to play 13, he wants to play his best position which is somewhere in the halves.
Considering he continues to show he is our most influential player when he plays 7, you would think common sense tells you that’s where we would continue to play him.
But not Wests Tigers and its fans, when something works well we decide it’s a good idea to throw that in the bin and try something different.
And we wonder why it’s been so long since we last played finals.
Click to expand...
Well just have to disagree on that one mate. One hot day doesn’t make a summer for mine. He’s been playing really good lately but he’s not a first grade playmaker imo. I’m happy for the lock experiment to continue though.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 512 (members: 40, guests: 472)
Back
Top