Apologise to Seyfarth HERE

Have we become that disillusioned as supporters that as soon as anyone does anything good we must praise them and apologise for every saying anything negative
 
@chicken_faced_killa said in [Apologise to Seyfarth HERE](/post/1363313) said:
@demps said in [Apologise to Seyfarth HERE](/post/1363311) said:
Hahahahah.
Keep the apologies coming.

Nofo next?

One for each so next week we can have the TAKE BACK your apologies threads.

Got to keep the forum moving
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Lolllll
 
No apology from me. I said he was good. Big mobile and has an impact because he is a different type of prop.
 
LOL this is absolutely a stupid thread. It was me poking fun at the other apologise thread and how ridiculous that was.

But to his credit, Seyfarth WAS good tonight. For mine he showed up Mikaele in the effort areas and should keep his spot.
 
Sincere apologies Mr seyfarth. This new quick game suits you. I didn’t think you should be in the team but you didn’t look out of place tonight. Well done!!!!
 
I had not commented on Seyfarth before but I would drop him.

Tamou, Twal and Seyfarth are all good defenders but we need some forwards who are good defenders that also average over 150m per game. Seyfarth averages 46.

Seyfarth played well tonight and got a few great turnovers but I would use him as a backup in case Twal or Tamou are injured or suspended.

Hopefully Musgrove and Stefano can become the top tier forward that we need. Mikaele is doing well this year as a 25-30min impact player.
 
@cochise said in [Apologise to Seyfarth HERE](/post/1363298) said:
These apology threads are stupid, no one should have to apologise for an opinion.
Click to expand...

A bit off track with my post @cochise but there is a bloke that looks a lot like you in the Upper Hunter electorate in the upcoming State election.
He's running under the Sustainable Australia banner.
Any relation to you?
 
@magpies1963 said in [Apologise to Seyfarth HERE](/post/1363392) said:
@cochise said in [Apologise to Seyfarth HERE](/post/1363298) said:
These apology threads are stupid, no one should have to apologise for an opinion.

A bit off track with my post @cochise but there is a bloke that looks a lot like you in the Upper Hunter electorate in the upcoming State election.
He's running under the Sustainable Australia banner.
Any relation to you?
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Funnily enough I don't know him but just looked him up and considering his last name is Blair and he grew up around Lake St Clair I would think he is a part of my step Grandmothers very extended family lol.
 
Apologising for what lol? He is what most of thought he was. He's improved since last year where he was arguably the worst forward in first grade, but he's still far from an impactful player.

He's a good defender, has a good motor for a prop and understands the game. However he offers very little impact off the bench. We can carry two of Tamou, Twal and Seyfarth type players at most.

The Seyfarth type isn't really useful in the current high speed game. You either need to be a big post-contact metre forward who can get over the advantage line or be a forward with ball-playing ability and footwork who can create second phase play or generate quick play the balls. He'll never be the first, but with some work could be passable in the second role.

There's no problem with him being in first grade for the time being, but Utoikamanu and Musgrove offer significantly more upside in a team where we realistically will be carrying Tamou and Twal for the foreseeable future.
 
@lukic said in [Apologise to Seyfarth HERE](/post/1363544) said:
Apologising for what lol? He is what most of thought he was. He's improved since last year where he was arguably the worst forward in first grade, but he's still far from an impactful player.

He's a good defender, has a good motor for a prop and understands the game. However he offers very little impact off the bench. We can carry two of Tamou, Twal and Seyfarth type players at most.

The Seyfarth type isn't really useful in the current high speed game. You either need to be a big post-contact metre forward who can get over the advantage line or be a forward with ball-playing ability and footwork who can create second phase play or generate quick play the balls. He'll never be the first, but with some work could be passable in the second role.

There's no problem with him being in first grade for the time being, but Utoikamanu and Musgrove offer significantly more upside in a team where we realistically will be carrying Tamou and Twal for the foreseeable future.
Click to expand...

Carrying Twal? The guy who averages 116m a game and has a 95% tackling efficiency?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 310 (members: 42, guests: 268)
Back
Top