goldcoast_tiger
New member
@Nors05 said:@Balmain Boy said:If Austin play's 5/8 it puts a lot of pressure at the feet of Brooks as the sole playmaker in the side. For Brooks' development he needs someone who can contribute straight away with the passing and kicking games. If Brooks is our best junior we have to nurture him, if we expect him to carry the team already it could damage his development.
Austin is just a runner, as has been said many times before. Unless Taylor teaches him how play in the halves in the off season he needs to play centre or bench.
Moses can organise, pass, kick, and run. His defence is actually no worse than Austin's. Austin made a lot of grabs at thin air don't forget. And Moses is the same size as James Malloney so anyone saying he needs another 5kg before he can play first grade is full of prejudiced, regurgitated crap.
You make a damn fine point.
Like most of you I want Austin in the starting 17\. He does play more like a ball runner than a half, which is why I think he would make a better Fullback than 5/8.
It does put us in a pickle with Teddy already at Fullback but still, I like Austin at fullback
I don't see a pickle at all, if Tedesco comes back somewhere close to his form early this year, he is the fullback. Full stop.
Or are we going to continue the usual time honoured practice of weakening two positions to slot someone in . I have no problems in Austin being in the team,but it will depend on how Moses and Blake start the year.
Moses will get a lot out of a full off season with the F/grade side and will hopefully have more confidence.
This competition for places is what we want. It's what the top sides always have. Both players have a lot to learn before either will be a top first grader.