Blood Young Guns Or Not?

[tigertye]

Here's my thoughts.

I thought Benji would try to go out on good terms and play with his heart on his sleeve and can't believe I defended him to an extent a while back. The last month he has just proved to me he is an egotistical, over-paid toss. Anasta should just quit for gods sake.

BUT….
If we drop these two FOR Brooks and possibly Moses with a Brooks/Siro or Brooks/Moses combo. Is it worth it? NO.

As much as I'd love to see them in first grade, it could be a disaster. If we bring them in and they get flogged they'll lose a lot of confidence and take that back to the NYC. In my opinion at least there or in the NSW Cup they are going to play finals footy. Which is probably more beneficial for their development instead of playing in a team where most of the senior players are planning their lunches for the next day during the game.

I'd still drop Anasta and Benji just to put the boot up them. Ayshford can take the year off.

Would like to here others opinions?

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

 

[Snake]

Leave the young ones this season they could get another run in a GF.. I hope Potter continues to play the same guys that are producing the rubbish week in week out,then finally all will see these overpaid FAKES for what they are !!!

 

[MacDougall]

I'd bring Brooks onto the bench next week. Put Sironen into the centres to replace Ayshford. Play him if it seems right to but don't feel obliged. Start Marshall and Anasta. Least that way you have someone to put on when they inevitably deserve to be hooked.

 

[tigertye]

I'd bring Brooks onto the bench next week. Put Sironen into the centres to replace Ayshford. Play him if it seems right to but don't feel obliged. Start Marshall and Anasta. Least that way you have someone to put on when they inevitably deserve to be hooked.

I'd promote Hitchcox or Fine to the centres (depending on Koroibete's injury, then move Lote to the centres).
Drop Benji and Anasta. Play Siro/Madden or Siro/Fulton for the rest of the year and bring in another backrower or impact prop like Paasi. Better then what is being tossed up right now.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

 

[Mccarry]

Don't play them. Let them keep winning. Keep them away from this rubbish.

Need Anasta to retire.

 

[pHyR3]

Maybe one game off the bench against the dragons for brooks. that's it.

 

[Eye_Of_Da_Tiger]

Give the young guns a go against St George. Out of respect give Benji his farewell against the Rabbits

 

[happy_tiger]

Not

If we were going to do it , we should have done it earlier ,give them a few games

I can't see the use of one game to the overall future of Brooks or Moses

 

[Tim Sheens]

Not!

 

[tigergirlz]

The NYC have a good chance of moving up the ladder in coming weeks. It everything into that. Of there is anyone half decent in State Cup, give them a go.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

 

[happy_tiger]

The NYC have a good chance of moving up the ladder in coming weeks. It everything into that. Of there is anyone half decent in State Cup, give them a go.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

x 2 TG I rather finish 15th in the NRL and give ourselves a huge chance in the NYC to go back 2 back than maybe beat the Saints finish 14th and miss out on the chance of of the NYC winning

 

[Newtown]

The NYC have a good chance of moving up the ladder in coming weeks. It everything into that. Of there is anyone half decent in State Cup, give them a go.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_

Mania Rudolph is in NYC but is a very steady footballer and goalkicker and appears to have a wisdom beyond his age.

 

[Defiant]

Dump the two hookers, Benji, Anasta, Ashford for the dragons and give the two u20s halves one crack.
\
\
Then play Benji,Anasta and Ash as our 8,9 and 10 against Souths :slight_smile:

 

[TJL]

No, leave the young blokes until next year you don't want them contaminated by playing with the current rabble who deserve to wallow in their own hopelessness.

 

[Winnipeg]

I overheard some info that they won't play, and it's simply not possible cos of the salary cap, even if Potter wanted to play them [pretty sure he would]

if I were Benji I would stand myself down

 

[tigerbenji]

I thought we should of given Brooks a run against the Eels & Dragons but i have changed my mind, leave him where he is & bring him up next year. Would put Rory Brien in for Ashford as he couldnt do any worse.