Brett Stewart

[MAFIA]

I would rather see us take the field with 12 blokes than have that low life manly scum in our team.

 

[Mulga_Bill]

Could not picture myself at game yelling out Go Benji, Go Chris, Go Sicko. And then if his brother tagged along Go Weirdo.
Just wouldn't feel right IMO

Sicko & Weirdo - That's Gold !!

 

[whoneedstherapy]

I would take him in our team any day of the year. He has the ability to score a try from nothing and also create an overlap like few can. His attitude may be bad, but drag him away from his brother and into a team who possess class both on and off the field and he would be a revelation. Can't see him wanting to play for the Tigers though, especially with Blair in our squad.

He is a class player, it's just a shame his attitude doesn't match. I would have liked to have seen Carney at the Tigers too, but as others have already pointed out, it was just never on the cards considering our own issues with player behaviour.

I'd sooner take Dugan.

There is something about Dugan I dont like. I cant put my finger on it, but he falls into the catorgory of love to hate!

Realistic fullbacks i'd want (well at least possible) would be one of the Penrith boys, Coote or the flash, one of the million brisbane options, Kahu, Beale, Gagai, hoffman or probably best of all one of the Warriors excess the fish, Omar or Kevin locke.
Any of them would be great. I think Tedessco will be as good as any of them, but as we all know alot can happen between future star and current star!

You're not on your Robinson Crusoe there either Goose. A lot of my mates don't like Dugan either.

I'd be ecstatic if we ever picked up Flash or Locke. Both are brilliant players in their own right. I'm hoping Teddy will get a look in over the next year or so. Even just to be given a taste.

I'm on that Dugan bandwagon as well. I think it's the really poor body language when he gets up out of a tackle that irks me. Some of his defence is suspect too, especially near sidelines.

 

[Rambo2714]

I heard a rumor , from an unreliable source , that he wont be coming to Wests .
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

 

[hammertime]

Do I have to remind everyone the last time we signed some A-grade manly scum?

Hopoate and Terry Hill anyone?

Lets not go back to those dark days!!!

 

[rossop]

I dont like the man but as a fullback I rate him up there with Slater. If he came to the Tigers and played to his full potential I think a lot of people would forgive him.
Anyway, it looks like Saints are after him and his brother so everyone will be able to hate him just like before!

 

[stryker]

Do I have to remind everyone the last time we signed some A-grade manly scum?

Hopoate and Terry Hill anyone?

Lets not go back to those dark days!!!

Haha yeah…however the Stewarts are infinitely better players than those two.

 

[851]

Maybe Smoking Gun can shed some light here,if Dugan is done to Saints why are they after Brett Stewart,either Dugan is not sealed at Saints,or the Tele are just guessing again,either way Manly are on the ropes.

 

[Tigersmurf]

Last I heard, Dugan was a chance of staying at the Raiders. I always thought the Chooks were the ones that had apparently already tied up his services. I expect he has likely signed a letter of intent with the Chooks some time ago - not that that means much these days.

I would love to see him in Black White and Gold, but expect we will most likely see him in Red White and Blue (and I don't mean playing for the US Patriots!)

 

[hammertime]

Maybe Smoking Gun can shed some light here,if Dugan is done to Saints why are they after Brett Stewart,either Dugan is not sealed at Saints,or the Tele are just guessing again,either way Manly are on the ropes.

I'd say that the tele is just guessing mate.

In all likelihood, if they exercise a dezzie get out clause, I would think it would be to follow dezzie to the doggies.

 

[Tigersmurf]

I don't understand what all the fuss is about loyalty wise…...Dessie was my year 6 teacher and it didn't make me want to do year 6 again!!

 

[Goose]

Do I have to remind everyone the last time we signed some A-grade manly scum?

Hopoate and Terry Hill anyone?

Lets not go back to those dark days!!!

I think that Terry Hill was our best buy of that era, he used to always give 100% and was our best player of the era.
Craig Field on the other hand!

 

[Original_Magpie]

He would be better at full back than the imposter moltzen

 

[Tigersmurf]

Agreed Goose, McKracken was pretty good too until his untimely injury

 

[Captain_Awesome]

No thanks, they can go to England or Rugby

 

[1_4_chicken_chips]

Yeah why would anybody want a Clive Churchill meadlist and his brother,i mean they have only won a couple of premierships ,played for their state and country.Yeah two deadset bums.

 

[LaT]

Yeah why would anybody want a Clive Churchill meadlist and his brother,i mean they have only won a couple of premierships ,played for their state and country.Yeah two deadset bums.

I would take B Stewart, I don't think his attitude issues run deeper then the resentment to Gallop over his accused rape and resulting standing down. If he gets over that he could easily return to the top.

I think Brett is heading towards Origin selection again, unless Dugan maintains his weekly phone call to Sticky again.

 

[1_4_chicken_chips]

Dosent matter ,both are still contracted to Manly ,Brett for next season ,his brother the next two seasons.

 

[LaT]

But the recent speculation around Brett has been because of a supposed "get out clause" he has now that Hasler has moved on.

So if he wanted too he could be a free agent right now.

 

[Guest]

Dosent matter ,both are still contracted to Manly ,Brett for next season ,his brother the next two seasons.

I thought both boys had get out clauses in the event of Hasler being moved on.