Brian Smith - Wests Tigers consultant

Personally I think this is a great move by the club, the bloke may not be a great coach (or even a good one) but he has a massive amount of experience that has come across some of the strongest teams in the competition. I'm sure Ricky Stuart was thanking him for the team he put together when he came on at the Roosters and won a premiership on the back of his coat tails!!

Like all consultants he will only be putting forward recommendations based on his experience and what he has uncovered in our club as a person looking from the outside in. What the club chooses to do with those recommendations is totally up to Mayer and Co.
 
We've already gotten rid of the deadwood. The coaching structure is set, the youth developing is fine. Now it's about results. I don't think he's the man for getting us the right results on the field that we need in the short term.

Hope ok wrong

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Wish people would relax and actually read the article. It says nothing about him taking a role in any kind of coaching capacity.
 
I like the idea of keeping things fresh. We have seen this year what new ideas can do. Give him a chance before writing the bloke off.

If he can help wests get to 3 GF's then I'm all for it.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
@GNR4LIFE said:
Wish people would relax and actually read the article. It says nothing about him taking a role in any kind of coaching capacity.

Yes but it says he will review the coaching structure and look at our youth pathways bla bla. All that's done.

What we need now is results on the field- he isn't gonna do anything about that.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
@GNR4LIFE said:
The guy is misunderstood imo. I can understand why people don't like him, i never use to either. As someone who can't cop Parra, i often took great delight in how often he came up short coaching them. However, he does serve a purpose at a club. His role, even though he's been around as long, isn't a Bennett or Sheens type role where he steps into a club and takes control of them for a decade, its not what he's geared for. His role is to come and clear the deadwood and build them from the ground up, he's a good hatchet man, a mercenary. After 2 or 3 yrs you move him on his way before he's had a chance for the rut to set in. His record at Newcastle and the Roosters is evidence of this. Hits the ground running and makes a real impact, before the rut. You just sign him to a short term deal and get the most out of what he has to offer.

Excellent summary; but even this sells him a bit short IMO. 3 Grand Finals - ok 3 losing Grand Finals but that is a record few have matched.
 
@tig_prmz said:
@GNR4LIFE said:
Wish people would relax and actually read the article. It says nothing about him taking a role in any kind of coaching capacity.

Yes but it says he will review the coaching structure and look at our youth pathways bla bla. All that's done.

What we need now is results on the field- he isn't gonna do anything about that.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_

We **are** seeing results on field
This year we are 6/5
Last year we were 3/8
 
Brian Smith seemed to have the knack of loosing the players respect. But he did have some good results without the crowning glory. I see no problem with an experienced person assisting with a **neutral** review.
 
@innsaneink said:
Brian Smith has been employed as a consultant with the Wests Tigers

James Hooper and David Riccio EXCLUSIVE
The Sunday Telegraph
June 01, 2014 12:00AM
\
\
\
![](http://resources3.news.com.au/images/2014/05/31/1226938/335647-851007d6-e7d3-11e3-ba62-a129b4e220c3.jpg)

YES, he’s back. But Tigers supporters can rest easy, ex-NRL coach Brian Smith is not gunning for the off-contract Mick Potter’s job at Concord.

The Tigers have hired one of league’s most polarising figures in a consultancy role as the club embarks on a review of its football operations.

Tigers CEO Grant Mayer confirmed Smith is midway through a month-long examination of the club, from its coaching pyramid to the playing roster, junior development and key football staff.

A sighting of Smith at the Tigers’ Concord headquarters last Thursday triggered conjecture about whether the veteran coach was being interviewed to replace Potter next season.

But Mayer has hosed down the notion of Smith making a return to the NRL coaching ranks, with the off-contract Potter expected to be rewarded with a new deal over the next fortnight.

“Brian is the first one to say coaching is behind him now. I think he genuinely believes he’s got a role to play and so do we. I spoke to Brian four months ago initially about this sort of project,” Mayer said.

“He still loves the game and wants to be involved in some way. We need some experience and Brian fits the bill as a completely independent individual. I can categorically say he’s not interested in coaching again. The reality is we want to pick his brain. Brian Smith has a varied experience base in elite football and also junior development.

“I want him to speak to people in our club who have also come from varied backgrounds. His job is to basically extract as much information out of the people in the business as he can so we can continue to grow our business.”

Smith, who coached 601 NRL matches in a career spanning five clubs and 28 seasons, last week was busy interviewing staff and players and will file an internal report to the Tigers in the next fortnight.

Players and staff being interviewed are told to speak as frankly as possible in an anonymous format, with Smith to refrain from detailing who said what in his final report.

Tigers coach Potter, who played under Smith at St George from 1989 to 1993, welcomed the review and said he held no fears in terms of his own job security coming under threat from his ex-coach.

“I can understand people coming up with an equation by seeing Brian Smith wherever they’ve seen him and coming up with an assumption,” Potter told The Sunday Telegraph.

“He’s been around and he’s put some great programs in place over the years and I don’t think his experience should go unnoticed and unused.

“We’re hoping to get a little bit of a restructure out of it and to also implement some best practice procedures.

“Whether that be around facilities, medical, junior league development, it’s far reaching as far as our department is concerned.”

Potter confirmed star fullback James Tede$co, who announced his defection to Canberra last week, was expected to be available for next Sunday’s match against Newcastle at Hunter Stadium.

Injured young gun Curtis Sironen also played his second match of NSW Cup against Wentworthville on Saturday and the promising rookie is expected to soon press for inclusion in the Tigers NRL line-up.

With six wins and five losses this season, Potter only needs one more victory to equal the Tigers’ win-record posted last season, underlining how the coach has earned the right to be tabled a new contract.

Hahaha… Love the use of the $ sign for tede$co. Classic..
 
@innsaneink said:
@tig_prmz said:
@GNR4LIFE said:
Wish people would relax and actually read the article. It says nothing about him taking a role in any kind of coaching capacity.

Yes but it says he will review the coaching structure and look at our youth pathways bla bla. All that's done.

What we need now is results on the field- he isn't gonna do anything about that.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_

We **are** seeing results on field
This year we are 6/5
Last year we were 3/8

yes and we need to get better.. getting even better results on the field is a bigger priority than off field stuff atm. and brian smith is doing off field stuff.
 
I like the sound of it. The article is completely clear and unequivocal….he will not be coaching, so we can move on from talking about that.

I think this will really help point out our weakness and show our board how far behind we are in certain areas. Smart move to engage him for this purpose.
 
Has anybody given a thought to the possibility that the club is looking at the bigger picture RE the massive junior leagues that Wests and Balmain have . Unless Balmain get there club up and running in a year and pay the millions owing reality is that part of the puzzle is gone ,leaving a disenfranchised junior league .Maybe this type of thinking is to get a structure in place for that day ,and we should not just think this might not happen. Many changes are a foot at the Tigers ..new board and probable a new direction…The Balmain scenario .
 
All he is doing is a totally independent review of our football operation, if you read the article, he has been talking to players and the coaching staff and letting them speak their mind.

Now this cant be a bad thing and at the end of a month or so he will submit a report and some recommendations. Than it is up to the board to either run with his recommendations or discard them.

I just like the idea of having a completely independent person doing this review who has no previous connections with the club.
 
4 grand finals he made but was i think favourite to win in only one 2001

1992 and 1993 against Brisbane team that would break the salary cap two fold in now days

2001 were favourites but outclassed by Immortal A Johns and one Ben Kennedy

2010 very lucky to make GF (would of been kicked out first week if Heigno jumped on ball) and lost to huge favourites St George

So he shouldnt be knocked too much. He can certainly get average players to improve but has never really had the cattle to win the big one
 
@BigUnit said:
4 grand finals he made but was i think favourite to win in only one 2001

1992 and 1993 against Brisbane team that would break the salary cap two fold in now days

2001 were favourites but outclassed by Immortal A Johns and one Ben Kennedy

2010 very lucky to make GF (would of been kicked out first week if Heigno jumped on ball) and lost to huge favourites St George

So he shouldnt be knocked too much. He can certainly get average players to improve but has never really had the cattle to win the big one

Completely agree. Cops a lot of flack for not winning grand finals but no one could compete with those broncos teams. Also look at how parra's juniors have regressed dramatically since he left. Might not have been the greatest coach but he cops a lot of unfair criticism.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Back
Top