Brooks Why????

[Needaname]

@happy_tiger
I get what your saying happy but ET is like our 4th option for Hooker.
The blame should be on the club not securing a number of back up hookers.
Let’s hope they don’t make the same mistake for next year.
Even Lichaa would be a better option than ET, makes just as many tackles too.

 

[happy_tiger]

@happy_tiger
I get what your saying happy but ET is like our 4th option for Hooker.
The blame should be on the club not securing a number of back up hookers.
Let’s hope they don’t make the same mistake for next year.
Even Lichaa would be a better option than ET, makes just as many tackles too.

We got even bigger problems now .....if Liddle is a ACL he won't be back until back end of SOO ..we have no back ups

 

[TIGER]

I'll say it again, we will do nothing as long as Brooks is our 7.
Been repeating myself since his first full season.
Always thought Moses was the better player, seen nothing to change that.

 

[shane2801]

@weststigerman Im not saying we lost because of Brooks. Im saying he is useless

 

[TrueTiger]

I'll say it again, we will do nothing as long as Brooks is our 7.
Been repeating myself since his first full season.
Always thought Moses was the better player, seen nothing to change that.

I honestly think that Farah and Benji have stifled Brooks career somewhat...he hasn't the toughness to put them in their place and take control of the team from the start...

 

[Geo]

1. Dumb, dumb play to knee the opponent in the head when wests tiger had the ball, and that brain snap will see him suspended.
2. Get Cooper Cronk to be his mentor in the off season.

It was only a Manly guy..I'm sending him a medal..

 

[BZN]

Good evening @Spacecub: re your "we should have kept mitch moses".
Cough cough splutter splutter!!! If we had not got rid of mitch moses, our club would have imploded well and truly by now. I personally don't care if he is a good player or not, as I believe we need players who put the club before themselves because they love the club. Imo mitch Moses failed on both accounts, and we are much better off without him.

 

[BZN]

G'day @TrueTiger: there was only one person that had the toughness to put farah in his place, and that was Jason Taylor. Hopefully, farahs leg will not mend in time for him to reappear this season.

 

[TrueTiger]

Fair point Magpies63,if only some in authority would have the same visions...

 

[happy_tiger]

@Geo

I rarely agree , but how the Manly player hasn't been cited for attempting to bite Brooks and giving him some weird disease ......

Has the NRL forgotten who everyone hates

 

[BZN]

Leave Brooks alone @shane2801: the shiteagles forwards ran at him all night, and he pulled off a great tackle every time. How can you expect the bloke to do great things in attack constantly, when he is made to do 'more' than his fair share of defence.

```

 

[BZN]

Good suggestion @Tiges19: being a great defensive player he would certainly tighten up the centre :v:

 

[TYGA]

Brooks was terrible can’t defend him this game.
His best is very good but he has to get his decision making right and Madge has to get him some ball runners out wide. Brooks has no hope with this lineup. It’s easy to bag the quarterback but when your receivers drop passes and have no speed and the offensive line doesn’t block up front you are under pressure.

 

[Tim Sheens]

Brooks was terrible can’t defend him this game.
His best is very good but he has to get his decision making right and Madge has to get him some ball runners out wide. Brooks has no hope with this lineup. It’s easy to bag the quarterback but when your receivers drop passes and have no speed and the offensive line doesn’t block up front you are under pressure.

And a quality fullback opposite also cuts down the already limited options.

 

[hobbo1]

1. Dumb, dumb play to knee the opponent in the head when wests tiger had the ball, and that brain snap will see him suspended.
2. Get Cooper Cronk to be his mentor in the off season.

It was only a Manly guy..I'm sending him a medal..

He’ll get off !
NRL hate us lol

 

[BZN]

I totally concur with your thought re Luke Brooks @formerguest. I just can't understand the criticism of him from admittedly, a small minority of forumers, who just fail to see the excellent work he does.

 

[Telltails]

I'll say it again, we will do nothing as long as Brooks is our 7.
Been repeating myself since his first full season.
Always thought Moses was the better player, seen nothing to change that.

I honestly think that Farah and Benji have stifled Brooks career somewhat...he hasn't the toughness to put them in their place and take control of the team from the start...

In other words he is not a leader.

 

[happy_tiger]

I'll say it again, we will do nothing as long as Brooks is our 7.
Been repeating myself since his first full season.
Always thought Moses was the better player, seen nothing to change that.

I honestly think that Farah and Benji have stifled Brooks career somewhat...he hasn't the toughness to put them in their place and take control of the team from the start...

In other words he is not a leader.

I must agree I'd like Brooks to have moments with players like Proctor did with Tyrone Roberts coming off at HT a few weeks ago

He should have absolutely blasted Taylor when we had the chance to get back to 26-18 with 6 to go

That was embarrassingly unforgivable from Taylor

 

[BZN]

G'day @Milky: you obviously watch the Wests tigers games, with the express purpose of finding fault with Brooks. Try changing your attitude and you will certainly notice all the good stuff he does, and then you will enjoy the game much more.

 

[hobbo1]

I'll say it again, we will do nothing as long as Brooks is our 7.
Been repeating myself since his first full season.
Always thought Moses was the better player, seen nothing to change that.

I honestly think that Farah and Benji have stifled Brooks career somewhat...he hasn't the toughness to put them in their place and take control of the team from the start...

In other words he is not a leader.

I must agree I'd like Brooks to have moments with players like Proctor did with Tyrone Roberts coming off at HT a few weeks ago

He should have absolutely blasted Taylor when we had the chance to get back to 26-18 with 6 to go

That was embarrassingly unforgivable from Taylor

What’s Godinet up to ?