Brooks Why????

Status
Not open for further replies.

shane2801

New member
Why do WE have Brooks and no other side??
Just plain horrible. The purest of plodders. Will never stand up when the chips are down. Average in every facet of his game. What about his kicks for touch? I would make further yards.
What I would give for him to get a big money offer from England and ask for a release.

WT would be stupid enough to say no though.

He will never ever be anything more than what you saw tonight.
 
Not that we need another brooks thread, but he is just not what we need as a club.

this team needs a cultured player, someone who has a football brain, who is calm, who leads with authority. Brooks does not. never has, and never will have any of those traits.

he is a flash in a pan. and until we replace him, nothing, will ever change. Yup....doom and gloom reply. but thats how it has been for the last 7 or so years he has played for us and been our "main man"....you can't argue against this. that is fact.
 
Brooks had a good game against Saints once at the SCG. We need him to make 2m from touch finders and to delicately lob the ball to the opposition on the last tackle.
 
We are getting run roughshod over through the middle and forward edges and have only had some one third of the ball, so they want to blame the halfback. Yeah right.
 
@formerguest

Yea see i just don't agree with that wholly. i get it, our pack is pretty sub standard. but ONE player can certainly make a massive difference. Brooks is in a position where authority and skill and leadership is a priority, ledaing by the front, dictating plays......he does NONE OF THIS
 
@Zach said in [Brooks Why????](/post/1049016) said:
@formerguest

Yea see i just don't agree with that wholly. i get it, our pack is pretty sub standard. but ONE player can certainly make a massive difference. Brooks is in a position where authority and skill and leadership is a priority, ledaing by the front, dictating plays......he does NONE OF THIS

He makes poor decision after poor decision, maybe some people see that as a good thing?
 
he is a average half that has solid skills. He would be decent next to a really good half. I rate him like ash taylor you can see theres talent but they really dont do much. The excuse for him not taking control this week cant be robbie so i guess it will be something like bad service or benjis a bully
 
@fair-dinkum said in [Brooks Why????](/post/1049040) said:
@Zach said in [Brooks Why????](/post/1049016) said:
@formerguest

Yea see i just don't agree with that wholly. i get it, our pack is pretty sub standard. but ONE player can certainly make a massive difference. Brooks is in a position where authority and skill and leadership is a priority, ledaing by the front, dictating plays......he does NONE OF THIS

He makes poor decision after poor decision, maybe some people see that as a good thing?

so does the coach and the rest of the team
 
@Joelcainenumber1fan said in [Brooks Why????](/post/1049058) said:
@fair-dinkum said in [Brooks Why????](/post/1049040) said:
@Zach said in [Brooks Why????](/post/1049016) said:
@formerguest

Yea see i just don't agree with that wholly. i get it, our pack is pretty sub standard. but ONE player can certainly make a massive difference. Brooks is in a position where authority and skill and leadership is a priority, ledaing by the front, dictating plays......he does NONE OF THIS

He makes poor decision after poor decision, maybe some people see that as a good thing?

so does the coach and the rest of the team

Dumbest team in sporting history.
 
There's no more excuses for him. He should have been running this side years ago. The speed in which he agreed to his current contract showed then that even he must be aware he couldn't make it in another side.

How long do we have for again??
 
@shane2801 said in [Brooks Why????](/post/1049073) said:
There's no more excuses for him. He should have been running this side years ago. The speed in which he agreed to his current contract showed then that even he must be aware he couldn't make it in another side.

How long do we have for again??

2 years i think
 
He could be a good hooker with his skillset but he's just too dumb to run a team.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top