@ said:
:laughing:
Brutal Reality - We lack talent
- Thread starter Eddie
- Start date
:laughing:
Elderslie_Tiger
Well-known member
Common guys we've had two trials with two different starting line ups,we're not going to win every game we have a very hard start to the season as long as we're competitive and put in each week cant ask for much more. You're either ON THE BUS OR GET OFF BEFORE WE START ROLLING
Tiger_Watto
New member
yeah no thanks… I'll walk :unamused:
851
Well-known member
@ said:
How good would that be 😛ray:
I think we have a talented forward pack - maybe a bit thin on the edges, but plenty of good middle fwds.
Brooks is a concern, as is the uncertainty at FB.
I think we're a back or two short - hopefully we can get another body in.
We're not going to win the comp this year, but there's enough in the squad as it is to get into the 8\. There's a few teams that are chock full of talent, and then huge questions marks over the other dozen or so.
I expect we'll have a tough start, given both the draw and the amount of new signings starting out, but Cleary will have them going well sooner rather than later. Keep the faith.
Brooks is a concern, as is the uncertainty at FB.
I think we're a back or two short - hopefully we can get another body in.
We're not going to win the comp this year, but there's enough in the squad as it is to get into the 8\. There's a few teams that are chock full of talent, and then huge questions marks over the other dozen or so.
I expect we'll have a tough start, given both the draw and the amount of new signings starting out, but Cleary will have them going well sooner rather than later. Keep the faith.
I hate negativity as much as the next guy but I don't need positivity shoved down my neck if I don't believe it or its not warranted.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion (you are starting to get that fact Cairnstigers).
If you think players we are apparently interested in signing e.g. RTS, Moylan etc. come on our Forum to see if there is any negativity and if there is, wouldn't sign - you are having yourself on mate.
Everyone knows they ring Happy to see if they should or shouldn't. Lol
Everyone is entitled to their opinion (you are starting to get that fact Cairnstigers).
If you think players we are apparently interested in signing e.g. RTS, Moylan etc. come on our Forum to see if there is any negativity and if there is, wouldn't sign - you are having yourself on mate.
Everyone knows they ring Happy to see if they should or shouldn't. Lol
Tim Sheens
Well-known member
@ said:
It wouldn't matter if you continually poured fluid into the glass of some as it would remain half empty regardless.
@ said:
Mate I don't think anything that gets said on here is going to affect the players' performance one way or another.
I doubt anyone who's nervous about the quality of this squad wants them to go badly. I know for myself that I'd dearly love this team to turn out to be the little engine that could, running out a steady stream of backs-against-the-wall 10-8 wins and securing a premiership against the odds. Hell, I'd love to see them win 50-0 every week and stroll to the title undefeated.
But it's also not wrong to look at what's in the squad and have some pretty significant concerns. Specifically, I just don't see how anyone can argue with the idea that it doesn't look like the squad has a lot of points in it. As other posters have said, where are the game breakers? We have nothing to speak of in edge back row, extremely uninspiring halves and it's looking like we might not even play our genuine x-factor in the backs (Lolohea). Who is there who is going to scare other sides? I just don't see it. If you're saying it's Aloai or someone like that I'm afraid you're dreaming.
I'd dearly love to be proved wrong. I'm not basing this on one trial performance. And I'm not going to turn on the coach. I certainly like to think the defence is going to be a lot better in 2018 - though the thought that we're _still_ going to be running out Naiqama and Nofo doesn't help my confidence even on that score. But it just seems palpably obvious that we're either going to have to win a lot of games 16-12 or we're going to lose a lot of games 18-10\. And in those matches where it's 12-all with 10 minutes to go I just don't have a lot of confidence that we're going to win more than we lose.
Basically, it seems to me that hoping this side is going to be a lot better than it has been for the past couple of years depends more on blind faith than anything else. In other words, through some combination of coaching and secret sauce a bunch of players need to be better than we've seen with our own eyes that they have been over multiple seasons. Because the cattle as it stands isn't any better than what we've had. If we're lucky, Matulino and Packer = Woods and Seumanafagai. Reynolds isn't as good as Moses. Lolohea or, seriously I can't believe I'm saying this, Thompson aren't on the same planet as Tedesco. And the other additions are no better than solid first grade standard.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
If club supporters behaviour weighed on the minds of players, the Bulldogs would never be able to field a team.
You can just imagine RTS
"Wow the money i'm being offered is great, and i can really see the club challenging for a premiership. But the posters on their forum are so negative and mean. Nevermind"
You can just imagine RTS
"Wow the money i'm being offered is great, and i can really see the club challenging for a premiership. But the posters on their forum are so negative and mean. Nevermind"
goldcoast_tiger
New member
@ said:
Well for Gods sake spend it on someone who has something that’s a rare thing around here…. Speed!!!
You know, when people move quickly over the ground, remember it??
goldcoast_tiger
New member
@ said:
The Bus is in for modifications, they had to widen the door so LoLo could get on : :smiley:
Tiger_Watto
New member
@ said:
Maybe its the bus to Callan Park?
Cosimo_Zaretti
New member
@ said:
Technically yes.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
@ said:
At the time, it was a clever little off the cuff comment by Cleary, and the club were smart to run with it. It was a clever way to deal with the player exodus to get people behind the club. But now its a new year, everyone is ready for the new season, we don't need cliche's anymore. Drive the bus into a ditch and leave it there.
Pawsandclaws
New member
@ said:
I agree it was clever at the time GNR. We look at the trial games and 2 of the 3 standouts in games were players we lost last year. It is difficult for strong clubs to recover from the loss of 3 influential players, but for a minnow like WTs it is potentially devastating. Without Cleary at the helm, we would have no hope of attracting the players we did.
