@Jazza said:
@GNR4LIFE said:
@Bazzinator said:
@GNR4LIFE said:
I'm sure the knives will be out for someone by the time Watson is due back, especially if they lose this test. The Aussie public alwayz need to drop somebody after a loss
i dont think u can say that. watson is the vice captain of the team. and has been the best player for the last 2 years prior to his injury.
would people on here be calling for someone to be dropped if it was benji and not watson that was returning from injury
Not sure what you mean. I'm not saying he shouldn't be back, i'm saying by the time he is due back, somebodies head will most probably be on the chopping block like it usually is with the fickle, disloyal Aussie public
I'm not sure you can say that when you consider the outrage when Katich was dropped, and that a 38 year old is still in the side despite not scoring a century for 2 years and has only averaged 36 since India last toured here 4 years ago.
If anything the selectors have been too loyal in recent years, it backfired with Marcus North and it has backfired with Johnson too. It backfired with Hussey who had a long bare patch until 2 good series against England and Sri Lanka before losing it again
This is what Chris Cairns alluded too a few weeks ago, selectors had a ruthlessness about them but in recent years it has been conservative and out of form players have been given too much of a run in the side for not enough in return.
When the likes of Slater, M Waugh, Boon, Taylor and alike were moved on from either the test or ODI, the selectors could be ruthless, they had a number of players knocking the door down demanding selection, when we brang in the the likes of Lehman, Love, Langer, Hayden, Martyn, Elliot etc, we knew they would come in and do the job, it was only a matter of how much they'd excell. They had scored loads of runs year on year in shield and county cricket.
At the moment the next tier of batsman are blokes like ferguson who has 5 first class hundreds. (if you exclude Katich, D Hussey, White and Klinger who wont get a look in despite being the best first class performers
We even have blokes in the side who are yet to prove themselves at first class level, Dave Warner is in good form but only has about 8 first class matches to his name and 3 first class hundreds, 1 of which was against Zimbabwe. I m not against selecting Warner, given there is no one else putting pressure on, it is tough to be ruthless with proven performers when no one else is sticking there hand up.
Punter now has 5 half centuries in the last 6 tests or something.
Hussey was our leading runscorer in 2010 and will now finish 2011 as our leading runscorer as well, and people want to drop him.
IMO they have both done enough to stay in the team.