Farah not suited for Origin - Roach

[happy_tiger]

Didn't Buderus just go off with an Achilles injury in the knights game? They're kidding themselves if the pick Buderus. Ricky will probably pick gidley at hooker under his were better having players in the side playing out of position than not in the side at all philosophy. Stuart's a dope, he's more interested in talking about how to win origin and what it's all about in the media rather than actually doing anything about winning the series at all. Ricky you don't own origin champ!
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

Gidley dislocated his shoulder in the game tonight too. He's now a shoe in for Origin

Lucky we didn't get Mason Has done a hammy already

 

[RatedRKO]

In the post game show they were talking about the hooking role with Buderus possibly out, and Tallis says 'Why was Sheens criticised for pushing Robbie when Bennett did the same thing with Buderus and no one said anything?'. Dead silence. :laughing:

 

[IronTiger]

In the post game show they were talking about the hooking role with Buderus possibly out, and Tallis says 'Why was Sheens criticised for pushing Robbie when Bennett did the same thing with Buderus and no one said anything?'. Dead silence.

Gutless Johns won't criticise tele mate Stuart. Good on Gordy, poor Rowdy stuck in the middle.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Coast_Tiger]

t

It seems strange to me that when Sheens tries to talks up Robbie to play SOO, Ricky Stuart and everyone else has a problem with it. But a few weeks ago when Bennett was doing the exact same thing with Buderus and last year with Soward, none of this went on.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

Good point, every one just bowed and said "yes master"

i think the main difference is Bennett probably told them what they wanted to hear anyway. There also seems to be a perception that if a player is coached by bennett, he therefore MUST be the best.

Gordon Tallis just made this point on Fox. Nobody on the panel could answer why he didnt blow up about Bennett's comments.

Stuart is a joke. I'd love to see an Origin coach who didn't play everything out in the media.

 

[gold_on_black]

In the post game show they were talking about the hooking role with Buderus possibly out, and Tallis says 'Why was Sheens criticised for pushing Robbie when Bennett did the same thing with Buderus and no one said anything?'. Dead silence.

Gutless Johns won't criticise tele mate Stuart. Good on Gordy, poor Rowdy stuck in the middle.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

Rowdy just shut up… Smart man... He knows Ricky has favorites and he doesn't wanna do anything to get on his bad side
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[ball_main]

In the post game show they were talking about the hooking role with Buderus possibly out, and Tallis says 'Why was Sheens criticised for pushing Robbie when Bennett did the same thing with Buderus and no one said anything?'. Dead silence.

I just watched it and thought to myself is someone going to answer. How much influence does Ricky have. Maybe the panel want a job for NSW
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[GNR4LIFE]

After about a 5 second awkward silence Gasnier came out with a hypocracy claim. I don't understand that seeing as how that was the Australian team and Sheens only picked the incumbant Smith ahead of Farah anyway. That realy is a nothing arguement and just a cop out imo

 

[innsaneink]

The more I think about it the more disgraceful it is….a member of the coaching staff all but omitting a potential player 3 weeks out
Should ensure Blocker is NEVER EVER welcome at this club, I wonder what Jnr & Sirro think of his comments. You wouldnt hear this crap from them.

 

[Tigermac]

The more I think about it the more disgraceful it is….a member of the coaching staff all but omitting a potential player 3 weeks out
**Should ensure Blocker is NEVER EVER welcome at this club, I wonder what Jnr & Sirro think of his comments. You wouldnt hear this crap from them.**

****
\
\
x 1,000000

 

[Tigermac]

I really can't believe the players thrown up if Buderus and Ennis are Hurt.

Hinchcliffe ?????????????

Wow

Johhny Morris might even get a crack. :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

Poor Chrissy, get out of there son, you are too intelligent for those drongos

 

[georgebeema]

Steve is a roach

Sour grapes

Has never been a Wests tiger and never will be

Should be sacked from SOO duties for his comments, because they have been pumping Robbie up last few weeks incl. CC saying he has a genuine chance.
Poor fella, never did

Neither do NSW
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Gazman]

What are the odds of a massive backflip over the next few days by Stuart & Blocker eg we were taken out of context thats not what we meant to say blah blah blah. ….

 

[tiga4eva]

What are the odds of a massive backflip over the next few days by Stuart & Blocker eg we were taken out of context thats not what we meant to say blah blah blah. ….

They would appear dumber than they do already. Is that possible?
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[RatedRKO]

What are the odds of a massive backflip over the next few days by Stuart & Blocker eg we were taken out of context thats not what we meant to say blah blah blah. ….

I think they've gone too far now to come back. If Buderus doesn't play, I'm expecting either Ennis or Hinchcliffe will be picked. The fact that Robbie is miles better than either of them doesn't matter.

 

[joe_s_magpies]

Simple with gidley also injured they should go Farah to start and hichcliff on the bench.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[DJZ]

Or Robbie gets picked and says he would rather watch it on the big screen with Jamie Lyons at home !

 

[happy_tiger]

What are the odds of a massive backflip over the next few days by Stuart & Blocker eg we were taken out of context thats not what we meant to say blah blah blah. ….

I think they've gone too far now to come back. If Buderus doesn't play, I'm expecting either Ennis or Hinchcliffe will be picked. The fact that Robbie is miles better than either of them doesn't matter.

I think with what has happened that Fulton or Meaney has more hopes than Farah

It's funny when you think about So many on here want Sheen's head but no threads about Ricky's sacking At least there is logic behind Sheens decisions Their is just blind pigheadedness behind Stuart Leave your ego at home Stuart and admit you are w w w w w rong Fonz Stuart

 

[Flippedy]

This is a complete travesty of justice. A highly talented player's rep career is virtually being shut down by a bunch of morons getting their knickers in a knot in the media. So, once again, and despite all other hooking options failing to impress week in, week out, it seems that Farah has NO chance of being selected for NSW. He does not deserve this crap - it's a bloody disgrace!!! I'm more angry about this than the team's capitulation yesterday, tbh - I didn't think that was possible.

 

[BornBlack_amp_Gold]

The more I think about it the more disgraceful it is….a member of the coaching staff all but omitting a potential player 3 weeks out
Should ensure Blocker is NEVER EVER welcome at this club, I wonder what Jnr & Sirro think of his comments. You wouldnt hear this crap from them.

I dont want to see the big buffoon on the game plan talking about or being referred to by the shows host as "bleeding black and gold " or some such comment ever again either, i think it will make me sick!
To publicy state that the clubs captain is not capable at that level of the game is a massive insult, which can and will be taken personally im sure!
I do suspect his words are more from the genius mind of his little old mate bobby fulton rather than his own original thoughts however.And that probably makes it even worse really, and causes me to respect him even less.

 

[tiga4eva]

Considering both said he was the best player in City v Country just shows you what a bunch of morons were dealing with here.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_