Grand Final thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guest
  • Start date Start date
you have 4 players on the bench for a reason. TO USE THEM. he should have made full use of all his players. some looked very tired out there last in the 1st hald n during periods of the 2nd half.
in saying that i was so proud of the boys. excellent effort by everyone; however very disappointed bu lui. he was the weakest link and when we are defending he might as well sit on the sideline coz he does nothing.
great game and very very unlucky not to win with that final try being a definite knock on. he pushed the ball sideways with his finger, not downwards, which would have constituted in downward pressure.
 
Melbourne Storm beat Wests Tigers in Toyota Cup Grand Final

* By David Beniuk
* From: AAP
* October 04, 2009 4:37PM

ENGLISH-born Melbourne young gun Gareth Widdop clinched the Toyota Cup grand final for the Storm with a 74th minute try and pressure conversion, his side downing the Wests Tigers 24-22.

Widdop finger-nailed a late grubber - his second try of the match - to draw his side level at 22-22 before calmly potting the conversion and delivering the second version of the national under-20s competition to Melbourne.

The Storm scored four of their five tries in the first half to lead 18-10 at the break before a burst of two four-pointers in three minutes from the Tigers took them to a 22-18 lead after 56 minutes.

The Tigers had looked to be coming home with a wet sail before Widdop,who missed three first-half conversions, made the difference in a match where the lead changed five times.

The match became a virtual showdown between two gun fullbacks as Wests Tigers tryscoring machine Jake Mullaney took his season tally to 29 tries from 27 games in 2009 with a double of his own.

The speedy Tigers fullback also scored a try on either side of halftime and set up five-eighth Robert Lui's four-pointer for the Tigers' second-half lead.

Melbourne, who finished third in the regular season, had held the ascendancy before that, and led 18-10 at the break with, ironically, Widdop's goal-kicking letting his side down.

The Storm had also been denied three times in the first half, twice with players held up, but scored tries through winger Matt Duffie, lock Billy Rogers, Widdop and centre Justin O'Neill.

Billy Slater clone Widdop, 20, was born in Halifax, England, and came to Australia as a 16-year-old.

Melbourne halfback and captain Luke Kelly, highly rated by great No.7 Andrew Johns, won the Jack Gibson Medal as man-of-the-match.

Tigers coach Grant Jones said the grounding of Widdop's second try "raised eyebrows", and believes in-goal officials should be replaced by video referees in grand finals.

"I didn't have a good look but there was a consensus that that may not have been a try," Jones told a media conference.

Tigers captain Darren Nicholls added: "I thought he touched it and he knocked it on."

But Storm skipper Kelly said Widdop had been certain he got the ball down.

"He put it down," Kelly said.

Melbourne coach Brad Arthur said Widdop had been his side's standout player in 2009.

"When Gareth takes the field we know exactly what he's going to give us and it's his best every week," the coach said.

" … He'll bide his time and he might play a bit of six (five-eighth) for the NRL (side in 2010)."

MELBOURNE 24 (G Widdop 2, M Duffie, B Rogers, J O'Neill tries, G Widdop 2 goals) bt WESTS TIGERS 22 (J Mullaney, 2 R Curran, R Lui tries, J Mullaney 3 goals) at ANZ Stadium.
 
Like most posts on the Tiger Cubs I am of the opinion that Simon Dwyer is going to be a future Tiger star and I also think that Andrew Fifita is a future powerhouse NRL player.

But when it comes to post Grand Final excitement then go no further than Jake Mullaney!

I originally thought he may be too small and possibly 1-2 years away from 1st grade but after today he is ready now. I know the step up is enormous but he has all the credentials to play fullback:

Speed
Good under the high ball
Great support player
Knows where the try line is
Can kick goals (not a prerequisite)

Brett Hodgson was just as small and if Mullaney has just as much ticker as Hodgo then he could be ready in 2010.

I hope the story doing the rounds that he has signed with the White Pointers is just that a story.
 
@innsaneink said:
Why would I say he got a hand on it?
Look at it in slo mo on IQ, yoy see the trajectory of the ball change its course as his hand touches it, just before it gets to ground.

We got beat…it happens

I have IQ and if you post a forwarding address I'll send you a spare pair of glasses I have. Knocked it on at best and "grounded" it with his CHIN! Not even a torso.

And despite a team's mistakes or failure to put the opposition away still doesn't mean they should lose off a ref's error.

No try.
 
Sorry Bill…youre wrong, plain & simple.
Maybe emotional attachment is clouding your judgement. Something is.
 
@Birchgrove bill said:
@innsaneink said:
Why would I say he got a hand on it?
Look at it in slo mo on IQ, yoy see the trajectory of the ball change its course as his hand touches it, just before it gets to ground.

We got beat…it happens

I have IQ and if you post a forwarding address I'll send you a spare pair of glasses I have. Knocked it on at best and "grounded" it with his CHIN! Not even a torso.

And despite a team's mistakes or failure to put the opposition away still doesn't mean they should lose off a ref's error.

I have IQ and watched it a few times and thought there was separation which should have been no try.

But in saying that i have seen trys this year awarded by the video ref which was very simalar.

It was a 50 -50 not so clear cut maybe benefit of doubt try.
 
I stopped, paused, slowed it down, went back and forth.

NO TRY.

I believe if there was a video ref involved - it would have been ruled a NO TRY.

If the shoe had have been on the other foot, I would be saying exactly the same thing.
 
Back
Top