@ElleryHanley said in [Help me \(and others\) keep faith in Madge\.\.\.](/post/1235404) said:
To those defending Madge, I appreciate the posts and I 'want' to believe...
But can anyone answer the following:
1. What is our defensive structure? They just seem to rush up and that is it. No cohesion at all. Airport lane holes have been there all year without any adjustment. Surely the coach had to react?
More importantly...and this is what concerns me the most...there seems to be absolutely ZERO attempt to get our spine ready for 2021. This period was a crucial chance to try a few things. Instead we got the ancient mariners who are not even wanted for 2021.
We are almost in October 2020 and our 2021 spine is:
1. no one knows
6 and 7 brooks will be one / no one has a clue who the other will be / massive concern.
9. Liddle / Simpkins
Penrith used their dead rubber games to experiment in 2019 and it helped them start 2020 well and build. Madge has done absolutely nothing to use this time to get a head start on 2021.
Here me out .. what if that was a game to showcase potential suitors of our dead wood.
Mate the defence is crap for 2 reasons . The middles don’t put their body in front , and the down benjis side don’t seem to trust each other . Ie. trust that the person can make the 1 on 1 stop. You watch brooks’ side . This used to happen to him all the time . Line breaks galore . Then he got his technique sorted , and they leave him to make the tackle . It doesn’t work all the time , as nothing is perfect , but if you trust your inside man , you can slide onto the shape forming in front of you , as if the ball player hits the under run , the bloke inside has that covered . It’s about trust and intent. There’s no trust , which leads to lack of intent , as you’re on the back foot thinking way too much .
If it was a showcase...then the show was very ugly.
Reality is any team after Reynolds and Packer would know by now what they offer / what they don't offer.
IMO it should have been used to get some rookies and kids game time. Build some combos for 2021.
I don't like setting kids up for failure and putting them into a losing side when they haven't played any football since February is asking too much in my opinion. Get them training in their roles and give them the preseason to and trials to get ready for their debuts.
Valid points.
Who do you see as our spine in 2021 mate?
Mate that is the million $ question, it is looking like Brooks at 7, Liddle at 9 and Mbye at 1. The 6 is what I think is really up in the air with it being between Reynolds, Walters and Madden with Doueihi a smaller possibility. My personal preference would be to give Madden the trials to see how he goes.
Looks that way. I can't see that spine getting a team to the finals though.
Hoping for JAC and / or Burton.