I think the issue is Sheens

The_Patriot said:
Ohhhh please. You've spammed the forum with your defence of Brooks but you want to blame it all on a kid with 30 something games.

Ten in the bin.

Have a good look at yourself.
Click to expand...

I just had a good look at myself and I admit I got it 100% correct.

Stef has had two shockers in a row. It's a massive concern. Are you stating he was good ? Were his errors acceptable ?

I'll correct one point though. There is no way I am blaming it all on a kid with 30 something games. He was just the worst in the team in relation to unforced errors.

*** Added after:- I'm not even sure who you are talking about here. I assume now you are talking about AD. He was terrible. Absolutely terrible. If you are sticking up for AD that changes the situation. There is no excuse at all for his performance out there.
 
Last edited:
Earl said:
I just had a good look at myself and I admit I got it 100% correct.

Stef has had two shockers in a row. It's a massive concern. Are you stating he was good ? Were his errors acceptable ?

I'll correct one point though. There is no way I am blaming it all on a kid with 30 something games. He was just the worst in the team in relation to unforced errors.

*** Added after:- I'm not even sure who you are talking about here. I assume now you are talking about AD. He was terrible. Absolutely terrible. If you are sticking up for AD then changes the situation. There is no excuse at all for his performance out there.
Click to expand...
His errors weren't the reason we couldn't score in their red zone, we got down there way more than enough, the forwards for the most part have done their job and weren't the issue these past couple weeks, the halves were, or whoever the 'play makers' are in this team. 13 runs 135m is not a bad outing, we had way more than enough tackles in opposition 20, Stef is the least of our concerns. But go on keep defending brooksie ya

same guy who also reckons toa should be starting center laughable
 
Last edited:
Earl said:
The mistakes are our biggest issue and Stef has been the biggest problem.
Click to expand...
Yes, very distressing. I tipped him for a ripper season but just seems lost in both attack and defence. There must be something going on in his life to be so lackadaisical ?
 
Halbrowne61 said:
Yes, very distressing. I tipped him for a ripper season but just seems lost in both attack and defence. There must be something going on in his life to be so lackadaisical ?
Click to expand...

I think he is trying really hard especially off the field. My impression is that he is pretty happy and just focused on footy.

I think it's just a lack of form. He needs to focus on playing simple footy.
 
Earl said:
I just had a good look at myself and I admit I got it 100% correct.

Stef has had two shockers in a row. It's a massive concern. Are you stating he was good ? Were his errors acceptable ?

I'll correct one point though. There is no way I am blaming it all on a kid with 30 something games. He was just the worst in the team in relation to unforced errors.

*** Added after:- I'm not even sure who you are talking about here. I assume now you are talking about AD. He was terrible. Absolutely terrible. If you are sticking up for AD that changes the situation. There is no excuse at all for his performance out there.
Click to expand...
No talking about you being happy to call out Stefano but spamming the forum in defense of Brooks

Here's a tip.

If you are upset with Doueihi don't use brooks to make your point. It devalues your opinion.
 
Earl said:
I think he is trying really hard especially off the field. My impression is that he is pretty happy and just focused on footy.

I think it's just a lack of form. He needs to focus on playing simple footy.
Click to expand...
Spot on Earl, but not 5 hit ups and a kick.
Straighten the attack, draw and pass, extra man plays are all fairly simple .
And have a look at some the other teams crisp passing, ours always seems a bit clunky !
 
The_Patriot said:
No talking about you being happy to call out Stefano but spamming the forum in defense of Brooks

Here's a tip.

If you are upset with Doueihi don't use brooks to make your point. It devalues your opinion.
Click to expand...

I'm okay with calling out about Stefano but I didn't mean it that way.

I completely disagree about comparing Doueihi and Brooks. They have the same role in the team now. They are to me directly comparable in relation to their on field performances.
 
Earl said:
I'm okay with calling out about Stefano but I didn't mean it that way.

I completely disagree about comparing Doueihi and Brooks. They have the same role in the team now. They are to me directly comparable in relation to their on field performances.
Click to expand...

No you are upset with Doueihi so are pumpming up Brooks because he is being called out by the fanbase for another avegare performance. You think that is unfair because Doueihi should cop more criticism.

You are supporting Luke to have a go at Adam.

Brooks has had enough excuses. Period!

Even worse you are now going Stefano to pump up Luke.
 
The_Patriot said:
No you are upset with Doueihi so are pumpming up Brooks because he is being called out by the fanbase for another avegare performance. You think that is unfair because Doueihi should cop more criticism.

You are supporting Luke to have a go at Adam.

Brooks has had enough excuses. Period!

Even worse you are now going Stefano to pump up Luke.
Click to expand...

No I'm not. You've created a false narrative in your head.
 
The_Patriot said:
The 20 or 30 leave Luke Brooks alone posts says otherwise.
Click to expand...
That was a simple response to the game on the weekend where Brooks was in my opinion our best player. I wasn't the only one who thought that as well.

I suggest that the narrative wasn't mine but the fans who want to blame Brooks for every loss no matter what happens on the park. I responded to that narrative.
 
Earl said:
That was a simple response to the game on the weekend where Brooks was in my opinion our best player. I wasn't the only one who thought that as well.

I suggest that the narrative wasn't mine but the fans who want to blame Brooks for every loss no matter what happens on the park. I responded to that narrative.
Click to expand...
Exactly my point.

Thanks for admitting it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 972 (members: 28, guests: 944)
Back
Top