Jayden "Bud" Sullivan #278

Snidest 0 said:
No coach justifies individual selections to the team...

It is NOT a fricking committee meeting!

It is what was said to Sullivan that counts - and the consistent message is selections will be based on performamce!

Sezer was on the bench - so surely the message was clear enough that there was very little between the two to start despite Sezer's lack of training with the team!
Click to expand...
In my experience coaches almost always explain why they go a certain way in player selections to the team (though not always directly). Typically it is discussed as part of the video sessions and game planning, particularly when it is a key position player.
 
gregjm87 said:
In my experience coaches almost always explain why they go a certain way in player selections to the team (though not always directly). Typically it is discussed as part of the video sessions and game planning, particularly when it is a key position player.
Click to expand...
That doesn't happen!

The video session after the Canberra game he will explain why Bud was pulled - but not discuss selections with the team!
 
Snidest 0 said:
That doesn't happen!

The video session after the Canberra game he will explain why Bud was pulled - but not discuss selections with the team!
Click to expand...
I agree they don't have open discussions with the team regarding selections. But they do have constant messages about what they want a player/position to deliver. They then pick the team based on who best delivered that in preseason. They then do a pregame video session where they gameplan and again outline what they want a player to deliver before going out and practicing what was discussed in that pregame meeting.
So no a coach does not discuss selections or outline individual decisions simply as I had originally quoted but that message can certainly be strongly implied depending on what was said in all of the above.
 
Snidest 0 said:
Absolute BS!!

Sullivan was there because Sezer had not trained with the team for a fortnight - and Sezer was still retained on the bench despite the lack of training.

Bennett picked O'Sullivan at 7 in Rd.1 - only to change his mind for Rd.2 after a poor loss!

Benji may be a rookie - but he is the head coach and has the entitlement to make changes on a weekly basis if necessary when players do not meet expectations!
Click to expand...
Maybe Sezer was carrying a niggling injury?
 
Bud Sullivan should start again next week. It was a lapse in concentration but we got back in the game afterwards.

I say it a lot, but I feel like this team has a history of being over-coached. Over-coached in the sense that coaching becomes so monotonous that the team forgets to concentrate. That's where you see moments like what happened with Sullivan in our last match. You need a senior playing group driving effort and concentration on the pitch as much as the coaches do on the training ground. Let be fair we haven't got that and we haven't for over a decade. Thats just my thesis.

Having said that I think Bud Sullivan gets another run in the side. It'll do him a world of good to have another crack in front of a home crowd. Deserves run in the side and not just a single chance. Take it on the chin and try again.
 
While Benji has the right to choose whom ever he wants, in this instance, after hooking both Seyfarth and Bud, I believe his hand is forced not to select them.

He would be criticised heavily if he selected them next week and they had similar level games.
 
Asu Kepaoa's #1 Fan said:
Asu Kepaoa earned his spot but Benji must have missed his name or something. Probably an admin error. Expect to see him back this week.
Click to expand...
I was surprised he didn’t lead both the backs and the forwards to a huge Magpie win in Reggie’s.
 
TIGERS said:
Bud Sullivan should start again next week. It was a lapse in concentration but we got back in the game afterwards.

I say it a lot, but I feel like this team has a history of being over-coached. Over-coached in the sense that coaching becomes so monotonous that the team forgets to concentrate. That's where you see moments like what happened with Sullivan in our last match. You need a senior playing group driving effort and concentration on the pitch as much as the coaches do on the training ground. Let be fair we haven't got that and we haven't for over a decade. Thats just my thesis.

Having said that I think Bud Sullivan gets another run in the side. It'll do him a world of good to have another crack in front of a home crowd. Deserves run in the side and not just a single chance. Take it on the chin and try again.
Click to expand...
"Deserves" it based on what? Never mind the lapse in concentration as if it was a single incident, he was woeful the whole time he was out there.
 
Harvey said:
He was almost as bad in the trials. He was worth a shot. Wasn’t worth 4 years
Click to expand...
Maybe not H but that’s what he got so now up the coaches to correct his shortcomings and play him wherever is best for the team, not the individual.
And the sooner he reverts to his natural hair colour the smaller the target on him will be !
 
TIGERS said:
Bud Sullivan should start again next week. It was a lapse in concentration but we got back in the game afterwards.

I say it a lot, but I feel like this team has a history of being over-coached. Over-coached in the sense that coaching becomes so monotonous that the team forgets to concentrate. That's where you see moments like what happened with Sullivan in our last match. You need a senior playing group driving effort and concentration on the pitch as much as the coaches do on the training ground. Let be fair we haven't got that and we haven't for over a decade. Thats just my thesis.

Having said that I think Bud Sullivan gets another run in the side. It'll do him a world of good to have another crack in front of a home crowd. Deserves run in the side and not just a single chance. Take it on the chin and try again.
Click to expand...
He had 5 runs in an hour of footy and was woeful in defence. That's an awfully long lapse in concentration or the dude just ain't got it....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 378 (members: 36, guests: 342)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top