Joel Reddy

@Drewby said:
Jack Reed, Clinton Toopi, Bodene Thompson, Joel Moon, Shaun Berrigan, Jamal Idris, Kane Linnett, Brent Tate, Brad Tighe, Ryan Morgan, Jarrod Croker, Junior Sa’u, Keith Lulia, Ben Pomeroy, Colin Best

all starting this weekend, and i'd say all apart from the dogs would swap their current centre(s) out
Click to expand...

I said starters mate not the second rate replacements
Bulldogs Idris and Morris no , Manly Lyon and Matai no ,Tigers Lawrence and Ayshford No , Penrith jennings and Tighe No , Broncos Hodges and Reed (Reed is the best up and coming centre in the game ) No , Storm Nielsen and Blair No ,Cowboys Tonga and Tate No , Croker and Thompson No ,Saints Cooper and Gasnier No ,Roosters Linnett and Shaun Kenny Dowell Linnett is faster and better footwork No , Warriors Mannering No other guy Yes ,Souths Inglis No farrell Yes , Knights Junior Sau No ,Lulia maybe , Parra yes for both , Cronulla Best Yes Pomeroy No ,Titans Michaels Yes Toopi Yes So he's better than 7-8 out of 32 . Thats a great record . As have said I think unless there is another signing he is more likely to be a fullback . So there are 75% better centres out there Linnett is out of contract he is a better buy in my opinion without all the injury baggage that Reddy has .
 
Thats your opinion of course.
Im actually excited to have Reddy next year. Have always rated him very highly.

To me it sounds like you think the only good players are the ones that get hyped up by the media. Reddy is a great attacking and and defending player who rarely makes mistakes.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
Anyone who could cover the deficiencies of Mortimer and Grothe in the same game is worth aiming to get
 
I reckon Brown has to be fullback in 2012.

By the way I hope we get Reddy, a change of clubs will probably do him the world of good.

He's big and fast, sounds perfect to me.
 
@Sabre said:
Thats your opinion of course.
Im actually excited to have Reddy next year. Have always rated him very highly.

To me it sounds like you think the only good players are the ones that get hyped up by the media. Reddy is a great attacking and and defending player who rarely makes mistakes.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Click to expand...

No Sabre my issue is Lawrence and Ayshford are better centres .So what position will he play
Rhinos not leaving so Blake doesn't need to go to lock .
Prefer to keep Lote and Utai on the wings .
So the only position I can see him playing is fullback . Thats the point I am trying to make . He came to Parra (I believe ) as a fullback but because of Hayne and the lack of centres Parra have he got stuck there .
Sheens must have no intention of keeping Brown or he would be playing fullback this weekend as why would you train a fullback for another club See the point I am making now Sabre and Drewby :brick:
 
Everyone's entitled to their opinion and mine is that he's a top centre, very undervalued.

Put his stats up against Ayshfords and he smacks him for 6… and Ayshford is up there!

Either way if Heighno stays we've a surplus of very good players and will be good to see where we'll end up!
 
Another injury prone player sorry over this need to purchase this type ..a step backwards as I've said before a major clean out then sign injury prone players just crazy.
 
http://forums.leagueunlimited.com/showthread.php?t=383205&highlight=joel+reddy&page=2

thats the parras fans opinion of him…they dont seem to upset when he got a season ending injury earlier this year.
 
Lets see he is better under the high ball then what we have, he is better in attack , he is better in defence, is 25 and has played city country - yep horrible signing

I think some people on hear would have been hating any signing - if we had signed Thurston to play halfback inside benji they would of said it was a horrible signing we don't need him
 
I think he will be a good signing, not sure where he fits in with Ayshford and Lawrence but I'm sure he will be in the team somewhere and prove his worth
 
Welcome Joel may your stay at the tigers be successful so that you can make some of these negative supporters eat humble pie.

You're okay in my book any player wanting to play for the tigers must be made of the right stuff….....
 
Looks like my mail was right when I started this thread and Joel Reddy did in fact sign with us. Personally, I'm ok with Reddy. The current culture or vibe in the team has not been great with many of the players leaving and it shows in the team body language and performance recently. Some new blood and passion with a point to prove may be a good thing for us.

Welcome aboard Joel. Hope you have a great season with the Tigers next year and beyond..
 
@Demps said:
Lame as.
Reddy is no better than Ryan.
Pfft, LAME!
Click to expand...

He's a million times the player Ryan is…
Doesn't mean he's great by any stretch... just Ryan is terrible.

I think he's a smart buy though. If the rumours surrounding Vidot are true, with Ryan and Moltz moving on, we need someone to cover the Bench back / utility spot.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 513 (members: 2, guests: 511)
Back
Top