Josh Reynolds

[Bones]

Police and prosecution don’t just lay DV charges for the sake of it. Just because this woman may be and probably is mentally unwell doesn’t mean josh didn’t do anything. Got to see how the courts decide it.

It doesn't work like this mate. They charge first and then let the legal system work it out. The problem is all the political correctness in society today impacts the legal system and we get situations like this.

It's plain wrong and hopefully a bunch of posters on here including yourself will learn a lesson not to judge people like Josh too harshly in these situations.

Women beaters aren't good people but neither are women that use the legal system to play games.

So the way he spoke to her is okay now?

How would you speak to someone if you had just found out you had been scammed for several thousand dollars, had falsely led you through the emotions of believing you were about to become a parent, only to crush that when they could no longer substantiate their lies. Someone that you had broken up with and asked to leave, only for them to keep hanging around looking to bait you for one last pay day.

You would have to be the most intelligent and emotionless person to not have an explosive reaction.

There is no way of knowing if the video was made after or before he found out about her actions or what led up to his actions towards her. Both sides of this are still just allegations.

Only one side appears to have corroborating witnesses, the one that alleges that she is a criminal fraudster who has obtained money from a number of victims based on lies such as illness, pregnancy, family tragedy.

Reynolds has already had his reputation smashed, lost his white ribbon ambassador role (much like Hazem did based on the false allegations of a disgruntled ex), and was probably within a day or 2 of having his career taken away through the NRL's no ~~fault~~ evidence stand down policy.

While all that stuff makes for good reading and good news clicks it all has nothing to do with whether or not she was assaulted on the evening in question. Obviously she isn’t all there mentally, however to just assume this exonerates JR is throwing the black and gold blinkers on. And the video is the video. Can’t unseee it

I’m no legal expert but being not guilty isn’t necessarily the same as being innocent. Since this is a case of his word against hers all they need to do is prove her version of events isn’t reliable and it would seem that may be the case. Unless of course they have further evidence the other way.

 

[Rugba]

Welp looks like some of us were to quick to judge even tho we knew we didn’t haven’t the full story...

This claim had been posted on the kennel at the time of the video , but this thread had been closed,so couldn’t be shared .

I will tell you One thing at least on that forum the posters that claim to have inside info actually do

 

[Tiger5150]

Police and prosecution don’t just lay DV charges for the sake of it. Just because this woman may be and probably is mentally unwell doesn’t mean josh didn’t do anything. Got to see how the courts decide it.

It doesn't work like this mate. They charge first and then let the legal system work it out. The problem is all the political correctness in society today impacts the legal system and we get situations like this.

It's plain wrong and hopefully a bunch of posters on here including yourself will learn a lesson not to judge people like Josh too harshly in these situations.

Women beaters aren't good people but neither are women that use the legal system to play games.

So the way he spoke to her is okay now?

How would you speak to someone if you had just found out you had been scammed for several thousand dollars, had falsely led you through the emotions of believing you were about to become a parent, only to crush that when they could no longer substantiate their lies. Someone that you had broken up with and asked to leave, only for them to keep hanging around looking to bait you for one last pay day.

You would have to be the most intelligent and emotionless person to not have an explosive reaction.

There is no way of knowing if the video was made after or before he found out about her actions or what led up to his actions towards her. Both sides of this are still just allegations.

Only one side appears to have corroborating witnesses, the one that alleges that she is a criminal fraudster who has obtained money from a number of victims based on lies such as illness, pregnancy, family tragedy.

Reynolds has already had his reputation smashed, lost his white ribbon ambassador role (much like Hazem did based on the false allegations of a disgruntled ex), and was probably within a day or 2 of having his career taken away through the NRL's no ~~fault~~ evidence stand down policy.

While all that stuff makes for good reading and good news clicks it all has nothing to do with whether or not she was assaulted on the evening in question. Obviously she isn’t all there mentally, however to just assume this exonerates JR is throwing the black and gold blinkers on. And the video is the video. Can’t unseee it

I’m no legal expert but being not guilty isn’t necessarily the same as being innocent. Since this is a case of his word against hers all they need to do is prove her version of events isn’t reliable and it would seem that may be the case. Unless of course they have further evidence the other way.

What is weird about this case is that by the reports, Reynolds supposedly went to the Police himself about this and he was charged from that.

 

[cochise]

Welp looks like some of us were to quick to judge even tho we knew we didn’t haven’t the full story...

This claim had been posted on the kennel at the time of the video , but this thread had been closed,so couldn’t be shared .

I will tell you One thing at least on that forum the posters that claim to have inside info actually do

I doubt that the claim would have been allowed on this forum anyway as it is much better moderated than the kennel!

 

[jirskyr]

After the new grenade of public evidence, I reckon this topic is best avoided until the courts actually deal with it. Too much speculation still.

 

[TrueTiger]

Answer is no. I didn’t know that I was responding to DV. It’s worse than I thought. Again assault is a threshold. If he whacked her, he should be gone and is a pig.

Agree that no one should hit a woman,however I have seen plenty of women king hit men,hit them with chairs and glasses,all comes from working within the hotel industry for over 40 years..If a woman told me twice that we lost twins as a way of trying to rort me as she has done to Josh,I couldn't help but knock her clean out without thinking twice....you want to know why...because as a man who loves children and life itself,to get excited about the birth of MY children and then being deflated by losing those beautiful babies,its not only devastating but mentally and emotionally scarring..
And for all the critics Im about to receive,just let you know I had a mate whose child was stillborn...he committed suicide...if you think what she has caused JR and he should cop it on the chin,then he is a great man,if he smacked her in the head for telling such a horrendous lie,in my opinion good on him...

 

[cochise]

Answer is no. I didn’t know that I was responding to DV. It’s worse than I thought. Again assault is a threshold. If he whacked her, he should be gone and is a pig.

Agree that no one should hit a woman,however I have seen plenty of women king hit men,hit them with chairs and glasses,all comes from working within the hotel industry for over 40 years..If a woman told me twice that we lost twins as a way of trying to rort me as she has done to Josh,I couldn't help but knock her clean out without thinking twice....you want to know why...because as a man who loves children and life itself,to get excited about the birth of MY children and then being deflated by losing those beautiful babies,its not only devastating but mentally and emotionally scarring..
And for all the critics Im about to receive,just let you know I had a mate whose child was stillborn...he committed suicide...if you think what she has caused JR and he should cop it on the chin,then he is a great man,if he smacked her in the head for telling such a horrendous lie,in my opinion good on him...

Sorry, I can't agree

 

[TrueTiger]

Answer is no. I didn’t know that I was responding to DV. It’s worse than I thought. Again assault is a threshold. If he whacked her, he should be gone and is a pig.

Agree that no one should hit a woman,however I have seen plenty of women king hit men,hit them with chairs and glasses,all comes from working within the hotel industry for over 40 years..If a woman told me twice that we lost twins as a way of trying to rort me as she has done to Josh,I couldn't help but knock her clean out without thinking twice....you want to know why...because as a man who loves children and life itself,to get excited about the birth of MY children and then being deflated by losing those beautiful babies,its not only devastating but mentally and emotionally scarring..
And for all the critics Im about to receive,just let you know I had a mate whose child was stillborn...he committed suicide...if you think what she has caused JR and he should cop it on the chin,then he is a great man,if he smacked her in the head for telling such a horrendous lie,in my opinion good on him...

Sorry, I can't agree

Don't have to mate ,its my opinion and what I would do,sorry,but some women in this world act pretty low at times and because they are female can say and do as they like...they want equality,same pay rates,play up with other men and want the ex partner to pay maintenance etc they can expect a man to lose his cool at times..
goes back to the old saying "how much can a man take"pressure sometimes makes people do out of character things,we are all different...but its easy to sit back and call a bloke a pig because he finally cracked and hit a woman,if that's true of course...why do you think we have organisations like beyond blue etc...they are here to help...
they are here so all can reach out when in need,maybe if a bloke hit a woman out of anger because of stressful circumstances,he should be given help and not chastised because we don't KNOW the circumstances...lets help first...

 

[JD Tiger]

Well there is now more to this story, based on evidence.

There was no evidence provided in that story for either side! Everything in that story were allegations and claims of having evidence!

but she’s just lost a whole lot of credibility…

She most definitely has!

I’d say her parents are a primary source! But hey maybe 6 ex partners and her own family have banded together and are all out to get her for no reason.

Just had a weird thought. If Josh currently played for the Roosters or the Storm, I wonder how many people would think that these 6 people and the family were paid off by those clubs. I admit, the thought would cross my mind.

Im not saying WT would do that. But if it were Benji we might consider something like that, its not totally unfathomable.

 

[JD Tiger]

Answer is no. I didn’t know that I was responding to DV. It’s worse than I thought. Again assault is a threshold. If he whacked her, he should be gone and is a pig.

Agree that no one should hit a woman,however I have seen plenty of women king hit men,hit them with chairs and glasses,all comes from working within the hotel industry for over 40 years..If a woman told me twice that we lost twins as a way of trying to rort me as she has done to Josh,I couldn't help but knock her clean out without thinking twice....you want to know why...because as a man who loves children and life itself,to get excited about the birth of MY children and then being deflated by losing those beautiful babies,its not only devastating but mentally and emotionally scarring..
And for all the critics Im about to receive,just let you know I had a mate whose child was stillborn...he committed suicide...if you think what she has caused JR and he should cop it on the chin,then he is a great man,if he smacked her in the head for telling such a horrendous lie,in my opinion good on him...

Sorry, I can't agree

Don't have to mate ,its my opinion and what I would do,sorry,but some women in this world act pretty low at times and because they are female can say and do as they like...they want equality,same pay rates,play up with other men and want the ex partner to pay maintenance etc they can expect a man to lose his cool at times..
goes back to the old saying "how much can a man take"pressure sometimes makes people do out of character things,we are all different...but its easy to sit back and call a bloke a pig because he finally cracked and hit a woman,if that's true of course...why do you think we have organisations like beyond blue etc...they are here to help...
they are here so all can reach out when in need,maybe if a bloke hit a woman out of anger because of stressful circumstances,he should be given help and not chastised because we don't KNOW the circumstances...lets help first...

I definitely think in the scenario you described the woman should be punished, but i disagree with your suggested method however. I cant offer an alternative though, I cant think of anything bad enough.

I had my ex-partner tell me after we separated that she was pregnant, and she was having an abortion. I know she was trying to get me back, but to this day years later I still dont know whether she was lying or not. I will never know. Im not a man who will punch on, but right or wrong I can sure understand how situations can get to the extreme where that may instinctively happen.

I have no confidemce that the courts will sort it out either, how is the judge going to magically know what happened. They'll just hear both sides, and make an educated guess. They might get it wrong, they do sometimes.

I just hope whatever happened, both these people can move past it, if one or both did do things they shouldnt have that they can make peace with themselves and not reoffend, and that Josh can get back on the paddock for us.

What position would he even play in our 2020 team?

 

[LARDS]

Well there is now more to this story, based on evidence.

There was no evidence provided in that story for either side! Everything in that story were allegations and claims of having evidence!

but she’s just lost a whole lot of credibility…

She most definitely has!

I’d say her parents are a primary source! But hey maybe 6 ex partners and her own family have banded together and are all out to get her for no reason.

Just had a weird thought. If Josh currently played for the Roosters or the Storm, I wonder how many people would think that these 6 people and the family were paid off by those clubs. I admit, the thought would cross my mind.

Im not saying WT would do that. But if it were Benji we might consider something like that, its not totally unfathomable.

I can't imagine you could pay off a parent to do that to there own child. It would be easier to pay off the girl.

 

[Snake]

Maybe after reading about the alleged web of decent this woman has spun with multiple men ...trial by media has been exposed for what it is , the worst part many here live by this doctrine and post accordingly
very sad ☹️!

 

[Moh]

Happy this has all come out now, obvious there was more to it but didn't stop some people with wild accusations.

Nice one smokey, yet again proving you're all class.

 

[Spartan117]

After the new grenade of public evidence, I reckon this topic is best avoided until the courts actually deal with it. Too much speculation still.

This is entirely correct especially on a privately owned and runned website such as this.

I hate people who take advantage of others.

If true and someone has indeed faked pregnancy... man thats.... 《fill in the blank in yourhead》

 

[TCL]

Answer is no. I didn’t know that I was responding to DV. It’s worse than I thought. Again assault is a threshold. If he whacked her, he should be gone and is a pig.

Agree that no one should hit a woman,however I have seen plenty of women king hit men,hit them with chairs and glasses,all comes from working within the hotel industry for over 40 years..If a woman told me twice that we lost twins as a way of trying to rort me as she has done to Josh,I couldn't help but knock her clean out without thinking twice....you want to know why...because as a man who loves children and life itself,to get excited about the birth of MY children and then being deflated by losing those beautiful babies,its not only devastating but mentally and emotionally scarring..
And for all the critics Im about to receive,just let you know I had a mate whose child was stillborn...he committed suicide...if you think what she has caused JR and he should cop it on the chin,then he is a great man,if he smacked her in the head for telling such a horrendous lie,in my opinion good on him...

Some woman can be feral, manipulative and darn right rotten but the same can be said for men however men often have the ability to physically over power a woman.

Many a man has the blinkers on to a woman’s personality when the only thing on their mind is getting into her bed and then act surprised when the woman turns out to be a bunny boiler. The reverse is also true.

While I don’t condone or agree with hitting a woman or man (although some people do deserve to have the ever loving Jebus belted out of them), it’s not unacceptable in my mind if JR grabbed this woman by the arm and removed her from his room/house.

 

[TheDaBoss]

Wasn't it reported during the season about how Josh lost his two twins......


Was that farce by her as well ?

Cause I felt preety bad for him at the time

 

[shifty]

Wasn't it reported during the season about how Josh lost his two twins......


Was that farce by her as well ?

Cause I felt preety bad for him at the time

Apparently it was

 

[cochise]

Wasn't it reported during the season about how Josh lost his two twins......


Was that farce by her as well ?

Cause I felt preety bad for him at the time

It was reported last night that he was told on 2 seperate occasion that she was pregnant with twins and she miscarried both times and that he was told a third time she was pregnant which she also miscarried. CH 9 stated that these events were fabricated.

 

[Spartan117]

Please BE Careful to directly accuse eitjer party as this is before the courts.

 

[Elderslie_Tiger]

It just goes to show we can all have our ideas and opinions but until it all comes before the courts we know diddley squat