Josh Reynolds

[Muffstar]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

 

[Geo]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

Bwaith

 

[avocadoontoast]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

Bwaith

Certainly most unlikeable

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Still did infinitely more than Anasta.

In fact, that game he did more in the one game where he was on the field for eight minutes before doing his hammy than Anasta did the whole time he was with us. And that dog had the hide to complain about strapping and Gatorade. Not sure what use energy drinks and strapping have when you do nothing.

 

[Tcat]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

Mbye is still up there for me. Hes played so much more than Josh Rey, yet i feel hes contributed less to the team. At least Josh looked like he gave a ?.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

Mbye is still up there for me. Hes played so much more than Josh Rey, yet i feel hes contributed less to the team. At least Josh looked like he gave a ?.

Mbye has made contributions, and I generally think he's a good player. He's just maligned so heavily due to his overinflated salary. If he was on $400k he wouldn't get the same criticism.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

Mbye is still up there for me. Hes played so much more than Josh Rey, yet i feel hes contributed less to the team. At least Josh looked like he gave a ?.

Mbye has made contributions, and I generally think he's a good player. He's just maligned so heavily due to his overinflated salary. If he was on $400k he wouldn't get the same criticism.

Also suffered from the utility tag and moved around too much. An expensive Kurt Gidley.

 

[Speed2burn]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Russell Packer enters the building and says hi

Atleast when Jrey got on the field he gave it his all. Can’t say the same about Packer

 

[TillLindemann]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Russell Packer enters the building and says hi

Atleast when Jrey got on the field he gave it his all. Can’t say the same about Packer

Disagree with all of you. Our worst signings are Matterson and Aloioai.

I'd rather an overpaid dud who's never on the field who respects us, than a decent player who dogs our club and trashes our jersey.

 

[Spartan117]

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

I trully never understood this recruitment descission...

He was busted at Manly for many years prior

 

[sleeve]

Agree with Muff and 117, That had to be a brown paper bag job.

 

[Russell]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Still did infinitely more than Anasta.

In fact, that game he did more in the one game where he was on the field for eight minutes before doing his hammy than Anasta did the whole time he was with us. And that dog had the hide to complain about strapping and Gatorade. Not sure what use energy drinks and strapping have when you do nothing.

He just wanted to prove - once a DOG, always a DOG!

 

[851]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

A JT special, that buy also ended up costing us a $700k of cap to watch Farah play at souths, plus $375k salary cap penalty for 2 years as well, plus the roll on effect, that was the very worst buy in the clubs history for a variety of reasons.
I maintain that buy and the treatment of Farah by JT was a big factor in the big 3 leaving.

 

[earl]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

Mbye is still up there for me. Hes played so much more than Josh Rey, yet i feel hes contributed less to the team. At least Josh looked like he gave a ?.

Mbye has made contributions, and I generally think he's a good player. He's just maligned so heavily due to his overinflated salary. If he was on $400k he wouldn't get the same criticism.

Mbye has played and done a decent job for us. Reynolds is our worst ever signing and it's not even close.

 

[earl]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

A JT special, that buy also ended up costing us a $700k of cap to watch Farah play at souths, plus $375k salary cap penalty for 2 years as well, plus the roll on effect, that was the very worst buy in the clubs history for a variety of reasons.
I maintain that buy and the treatment of Farah by JT was a big factor in the big 3 leaving.

My impression is that Robbie being at the club is a big reason they left. I don't think they liked Robbie or at least the only one out of the 3 that left that hurt definitely didn't like him.

I actually think JT was trying to shaft Robbie to keep some of those guys happy.

 

[jadtiger]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

Ballin was only subsidised for the first year,he was another poor purchase

 

[InBenjiWeTrust]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

and how about ‘the best decoy runner ever’??

 

[jadtiger]

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

I trully never understood this recruitment descission...

He was busted at Manly for many years prior

It was all to do with JT and his ego and the club suffered because of it

 

[Speed2burn]

Geez 21 games across 3 seasons on his money has to make him our worst ever signing. He had to go.

Matt Ballin, 40 minutes playing time in 2 years would be up there too.

Ballin didn't really cost anything, was heavily subsidised by Manly. Overall, Reynolds is the worst signing in WT history imo.

Mbye is still up there for me. Hes played so much more than Josh Rey, yet i feel hes contributed less to the team. At least Josh looked like he gave a ?.

Mbye has made contributions, and I generally think he's a good player. He's just maligned so heavily due to his overinflated salary. If he was on $400k he wouldn't get the same criticism.

Mbye has played and done a decent job for us. Reynolds is our worst ever signing and it's not even close.

I cannot even think of one highlight to take from mbye in 2020, solid player who gives you the bare minimum a first grade player should, but that’s about it

If reynolds played the same amount of game time as him there would have been daylight.

Not even sure if Mbye has received one MOTM award playing for us? Grub has received multiple