100%. I actually feel for Madge on this but it's also an issue he has created because we have no one at all stepping up in reggies going pick me, infact we suck in lower grades atm as well. To'a is the exception. He should be picked but we all know next week if everyone is fit he won't be. Even looking at our injuries most people last year weren't fans of AJ or TT either.
Our recruitment strategy has been terrible the last few years and we have no light at the end of the tunnel for this or next season (haven't acquired anyone yet) when it comes to our backline currently either.
I said before he came that Gildart size and lack of experience against bigger size players will be an issue, defensively he will be found out but what I didn't expect was how slow he actually is compared to other NRL backs which shows how slow the ESL really is (because he looked decent there speed wise). I actually think his lack of speed is creating more of a defensive issue for him than the size.
But in saying that I wish all our backs would put in the effort Gildart does, you can see he is at least trying and putting in the effort, he has a high work rate compared to our other backs but he just isn't NRL quality right now.