Klein

[Fade_To_Black]

I absolutely abhor violence towards referees but someone would be wholly justified in decking this goose. He's a cheat. 3 or 4 very poor calls against us so far. Would be nice to at least get an even share of the rub of the green. Sick of it.

 

[MacDougall]

Thought he was okay tbh.

 

[innsaneink]

I dont like him, hes usually bad with us but I thought he was OK tonite.

Which calls?

 

[stevetiger]

I have no issues with the refs tonight. A couple of dropped balls from us and some missed tackles that were tough to make was the difference.

 

[stevetiger]

I have no issues with the refs tonight. A couple of dropped balls from us and some missed tackles that were tough to make was the difference.

 

[cktiger]

Their markers sure had plenty of leeway - no worries about being square tonight.

 

[maxxy86]

Yeah it wasn't the refs tonight…....we just played like the dumb team we are!!!!!!//

 

[happy_tiger]

I have no issues with the refs tonight. A couple of dropped balls from us and some missed tackles that were tough to make was the difference.

Refs were pretty good , if anything I reckon we got a few calls , especially the Moses knock on after he twisted his ankle

 

[Tim Sheens]

A big call was him allowing Perret to take Rankin out despite a hand on him when the ball was on the ground, thus tackle completed. Another set for our tiring defence that was already starved of possession was a killer.

Letting him be carried back by three players and nearly put in goal early was also wrong, as he was airborne and forward progress had well and truly been stopped. Not much point having a rule if it is never used.

 

[hobbo]

Klein's a joke …. This week he was 0/2 in sending decisions upstairs .
Last week the ref's were 0/2 in sending decisions upstairs .
If anyone thinks ref's don't have agendas in ruling in games they're off with the pixies !

 

[innsaneink]

**A big call was him allowing Perret to take Rankin out despite a hand on him when the ball was on the ground, thus tackle completed. Another set for our tiring defence that was already starved of possession was a killer.**

Letting him be carried back by three players and nearly put in goal early was also wrong, as he was airborne and forward progress had well and truly been stopped. Not much point having a rule if it is never used.

Unfortunatley taht was a correct call….first tackler dropped off, moentum took him over...there was no hand on him

 

[cktiger]

**A big call was him allowing Perret to take Rankin out despite a hand on him when the ball was on the ground, thus tackle completed. Another set for our tiring defence that was already starved of possession was a killer.**

Letting him be carried back by three players and nearly put in goal early was also wrong, as he was airborne and forward progress had well and truly been stopped. Not much point having a rule if it is never used.

Unfortunatley taht was a correct call….first tackler dropped off, moentum took him over...there was no hand on him

After the first guy put his hand on him you would have thought it would have been a surrender tackle.
Rankin should have pushed further infield anyway - shocker of a game all round from him.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

i think this is the first time in 2016 we have won the penalty count.
We got some cheap and easy ones where the dogs were harshly punished
Mbye and Moses incident comes to mind for one
Fine got pinned a couple of times, once i thought when he shouldnt have been

 

[Tim Sheens]

**A big call was him allowing Perret to take Rankin out despite a hand on him when the ball was on the ground, thus tackle completed. Another set for our tiring defence that was already starved of possession was a killer.**

Letting him be carried back by three players and nearly put in goal early was also wrong, as he was airborne and forward progress had well and truly been stopped. Not much point having a rule if it is never used.

Unfortunatley taht was a correct call….first tackler dropped off, moentum took him over...there was no hand on him

Looked like he was on the ground before the hand lost contact to me and on replay as well, but been wrong before

 

[happy_tiger]

**A big call was him allowing Perret to take Rankin out despite a hand on him when the ball was on the ground, thus tackle completed. Another set for our tiring defence that was already starved of possession was a killer.**

Letting him be carried back by three players and nearly put in goal early was also wrong, as he was airborne and forward progress had well and truly been stopped. Not much point having a rule if it is never used.

Unfortunatley taht was a correct call….first tackler dropped off, moentum took him over...there was no hand on him

Looked like he was on the ground before the hand lost contact to me and on replay as well, but been wrong before

Iky's right , the tackle hadn't been completed , but I'm 100% behind you with players getting lifted and carried back

As I mentioned in the lifting thread ,it was banned to protect players

So much for protecting players :deadhorse:

 

[shane2801]

I absolutely abhor violence towards referees but someone would be wholly justified in decking this goose. He's a cheat. 3 or 4 very poor calls against us so far. Would be nice to at least get an even share of the rub of the green. Sick of it.

I'm so sick of seeing posts like yours Whinging about refs. Just Shut Up. :imp:

 

[pHyR3]

yeah refs seemed fine

nothing too horrendous, maybe some offsides but im sure that went both ways

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

I absolutely abhor violence towards referees but someone would be wholly justified in decking this goose. He's a cheat. 3 or 4 very poor calls against us so far. Would be nice to at least get an even share of the rub of the green. Sick of it.

I'm so sick of seeing posts like yours Whinging about refs. Just Shut Up. :imp:

Is this Shane Hayne ?
You took it personally, relax, we have bigger issues to deal with

Like the non existent defence of Sir Nofo and Sir Kevvy

 

[jadtiger]

Ref didnt cost us the game tonight i thought he was pretty equal in his decisions not favouring either side>i am more than happy to get that each week

 

[shane2801]

It was a very good game. Why can't people be content that the Wests Tigers played well and the Dogs got the better of us late in the game. Every week without fail someone has to carry on about the poor refereeing.
The bunker got everything correct and referee's are human. We were very disciplined which is why we were in the game for so long. The refs did well, The Tigers did well and so did the Dogs.