Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot

rihannafan1

Well-known member
https://www.weststigers.com.au/news/2021/03/11/liddle-ready-to-make-the-most-of-starting-spot/

ahhhh that hand in the background is a little creepy 😂😂😂
 
He’s useless …
Woeful service and he’s gassed after 20 mins ..
Give Harry 1 million a season to come home
 
Can not play in the semis with the game being produced from this key position. Isolating the contribution that this position can produce and comparing it overall to some of the dummy halves going around, we would have to be close to the worst.
It is very disappointing because Liddle has some great qualities and potential, but he just isn’t producing enough or delivering for long enough in a game.
 
@tigersj said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439453) said:
Can not play in the semis with the game being produced from this key position. Isolating the contribution that this position can produce and comparing it overall to some of the dummy halves going around, we would have to be close to the worst.
It is very disappointing because Liddle has some great qualities and potential, but he just isn’t producing enough or delivering for long enough in a game.

Liddle is a bench hooker at best and we ask him to play 80mins
 
@aceshigh said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439454) said:
Bloody ordinary , Marshall King offers much more than our bloke

Great comedy. Liddle is an average first grader but he’s miles better than Marshall King.
 
@innsaneink said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439465) said:
He didn't play 80 today (I think) and he was still the same (average)

No but did play 60 straight. Gets asked to do too much defence.

I would love a Smith/Radley type that could start at hooker and then play in the middle.

I noticed that again there were metres plenty for the dogs up the middle when he was off.
 
@tyga said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439475) said:
@aceshigh said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439454) said:
Bloody ordinary , Marshall King offers much more than our bloke

Great comedy. Liddle is an average first grader but he’s miles better than Marshall King.

If you watched the game Marshall looked 3 times the player. Liddle has regressed alarmingly. He needs a spell and let’s get simpkin back.
 
@tigerpower said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439609) said:
@tyga said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439475) said:
@aceshigh said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439454) said:
Bloody ordinary , Marshall King offers much more than our bloke

Great comedy. Liddle is an average first grader but he’s miles better than Marshall King.

If you watched the game Marshall looked 3 times the player. Liddle has regressed alarmingly. He needs a spell and let’s get simpkin back.

On today’s performance okay Liddle was horrendous. Unfortunately I watch alot of dogs games JMK is bad, really bad. A good runner at times.
 
@tyga said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439614) said:
@tigerpower said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439609) said:
@tyga said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439475) said:
@aceshigh said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439454) said:
Bloody ordinary , Marshall King offers much more than our bloke

Great comedy. Liddle is an average first grader but he’s miles better than Marshall King.

If you watched the game Marshall looked 3 times the player. Liddle has regressed alarmingly. He needs a spell and let’s get simpkin back.

On today’s performance okay Liddle was horrendous. Unfortunately I watch alot of dogs games JMK is bad, really bad. A good runner at times.

Liddle was great for a while. But he’s last couple of weeks have been terrible. I also blame madge who just cannot seem to adjust to how players are going and not putting Simpkin on the bench.
 
Good for 15 minutes, then gasses. After that, his passing gets sloppy and he stops running. After 35 minutes, his defence falls apart. After 55 minutes he's cooked and a complete liability.
 
@tigerpower said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439616) said:
@tyga said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439614) said:
@tigerpower said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439609) said:
@tyga said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439475) said:
@aceshigh said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439454) said:
Bloody ordinary , Marshall King offers much more than our bloke

Great comedy. Liddle is an average first grader but he’s miles better than Marshall King.

If you watched the game Marshall looked 3 times the player. Liddle has regressed alarmingly. He needs a spell and let’s get simpkin back.

On today’s performance okay Liddle was horrendous. Unfortunately I watch alot of dogs games JMK is bad, really bad. A good runner at times.

Liddle was great for a while. But he’s last couple of weeks have been terrible. I also blame madge who just cannot seem to adjust to how players are going and not putting Simpkin on the bench.

Simpkin needs time physically. The club knows he’s the future and we are going nowhere this year. We have a lack of quality depth at the club which has to be fixed.
 
@kazoo-kid said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439624) said:
Good for 15 minutes, then gasses. After that, his passing gets sloppy and he stops running. After 35 minutes, his defence falls apart. After 55 minutes he's cooked and a complete liability.


I don't think the problem is he gets gassed and can't tackle. I think he's tackling more than he should because we have some slow, inexperienced and lazy middles who are happy for him to make first contact - this is why he gets gassed.

He started well and did nicely to set up the first try. Madge knows he can't play 80 minutes and it was fairly apparent there was going to be a change with Cini on the bench.

I thought Mbye was really average at 9. He runs at the wrong time, throws poor balls and doesn't make contact as well as Liddle. Mbye is not the answer at 9. If we need to rest Liddle I'd be giving Simpkins another go with the knowledge he'll probably only be good for 30 minutes.
 
I'm prepared for the club to cut their losses on him. As Hobbo said, chuck a million at Harry. Make an offer he can't refuse. I can't imagine Melbourne paying him, Hughes, Pappy and Munster all close to a million when they still have NAS, Bromwich 1 & 2, possibly the Cheese and Welch who would all command good money too.
 
@cultured_bogan said in [Liddle ready to make the most of starting spot](/post/1439770) said:
I'm prepared for the club to cut their losses on him. As Hobbo said, chuck a million at Harry. Make an offer he can't refuse. I can't imagine Melbourne paying him, Hughes, Pappy and Munster all close to a million when they still have NAS, Bromwich 1 & 2, possibly the Cheese and Welch who would all command good money too.

I don't know what Liddle is on (say $300k), do you believe Grant will make a $700k difference to us?

I just think, we have other priorities than a 9 atm.
 
Back
Top