Loss of the magpie

  • Thread starter Thread starter sue_watsford
  • Start date Start date
They were the days. Johnny Purcell battling with Shane Day for the Magpies number 12 jersey. Both excellent hookers too.

And yeah, this thread has fired old Snoddy up a tad.
There is an imbalance … and Wests diehards feel this imbalance season after season.
So I pledge that from 3.40 Sunday the whatever of November to do my bit to redress said imbalance by referring to the JV club from here in and for ever more as WESTS and WESTS only.

I have vowed to uphold a monastic emblem of silence.

Carn WESTS ... WESTS to win ... I support WESTS ... Great try WESTS ... Robbie Farah's is a WESTS legend ... WESTS are on fire ... WESTS .... WESTS ... WESTS ...

Now that was really quite cathartic

Yeah, that works for me.
 
@Snodgrass said:
They were the days. Johnny Purcell battling with Shane Day for the Magpies number 12 jersey. Both excellent hookers too.

And yeah, this thread has fired old Snoddy up a tad.
There is an imbalance … and Wests diehards feel this imbalance season after season.
So I pledge that from 3.40 Sunday the whatever of November to do my bit to redress said imbalance by referring to the JV club from here in and for ever more as WESTS and WESTS only.

I have vowed to uphold a monastic emblem of silence.

Carn WESTS ... WESTS to win ... I support WESTS ... Great try WESTS ... Robbie Farah's is a WESTS legend ... WESTS are on fire ... WESTS .... WESTS ... WESTS ...

Now that was really quite cathartic

Yeah, that works for me.

Newtown is a foundation club and was a 1st grade club from 1909 until 1983 until they were unceremoniously dumped from 1st grade. Newtown were initailly known as the Bluebags which changed in the 1970's to the Jets, the same name they were known by when Newtown played its last 1st grade game in 1983\. The NRL later showed there great benevolence towards this foundation club status by later allowing Newtown to play Premiere League (State Cup as it is currently known). Today the Newtown club is still known as Jets but are now principaaly a feeder club to a team, Roosters/Eastern Suburbs, which for decades they had great rivalry with. My point is the name Wests Tigers very much represent two great original clubs, Western Suburbs (Wests) and Balmain (Tigers), who are now working together as one great club. West and Tigers supporters should be glad that they they can support Wests Tigers in 1st grade competition. Unfortunately 1st grade status is a sad memory for Newtown supportors.
 
Call us Balmain Magpies and we still would have complaints because some refer to the club as "Balmain" and not "Magpies".

It shouldn't be an issue anymore. We can't expect our board to stop this faction BS, working against one another, if our fans won't do the same.

Instead of celebrating the history we have, we are being held back because of it.
 
@Newtown said:
@Snodgrass said:
They were the days. Johnny Purcell battling with Shane Day for the Magpies number 12 jersey. Both excellent hookers too.

And yeah, this thread has fired old Snoddy up a tad.
There is an imbalance … and Wests diehards feel this imbalance season after season.
So I pledge that from 3.40 Sunday the whatever of November to do my bit to redress said imbalance by referring to the JV club from here in and for ever more as WESTS and WESTS only.

I have vowed to uphold a monastic emblem of silence.

Carn WESTS ... WESTS to win ... I support WESTS ... Great try WESTS ... Robbie Farah's is a WESTS legend ... WESTS are on fire ... WESTS .... WESTS ... WESTS ...

Now that was really quite cathartic
Yeah, that works for me.

Newtown is a foundation club and was a 1st grade club from 1909 until 1983 until they were unceremoniously dumped from 1st grade. Newtown were initailly known as the Bluebags which changed in the 1970's to the Jets, the same name they were known by when Newtown played its last 1st grade game in 1983\. The NRL later showed there great benevolence towards this foundation club status by later allowing Newtown to play Premiere League (State
Cup as it is currently known). Today the Newtown club is still known as Jets but are now principaaly a feeder club to a team, Roosters/Eastern Suburbs, which for decades they had great rivalry with. My point is the name Wests Tigers very much represent two great original clubs, Western Suburbs (Wests) and Balmain (Tigers), who are now working together as one great club. West and Tigers supporters should be glad that they they can support Wests Tigers in 1st
grade competition. Unfortunately 1st grade status is a sad memory for Newtown supportors.

I feel for you Henson … And I also feel very sorry for all those disenfranchised Norths people.
I'm hearing you regards being thankful for what we've got ... And I am.
However all this is relative.
And when something feels out of kilter it's very hard to keep a permanent grin.
99% of the JV fans can tell the 1% to get over it (and they do on here regularly) but people like Snoddy and relatives of Johnny Purcell etc are allowed to feel uneasy, and to even express that uneasiness.

As I said, it is all relative. If Newtown had merged with the Roosters back before the purge and became the Newtown Roosters ... I'm sure you'd be irritated by 90% of media references calling the club The Roosters, the colours being red, white and blue with the blue hue being a noticeably dark blue, the spiritual home being refered continually as Bondi Junction, and whenever a comment is sort from a club legend the camera zooms in on Brad Fittler or Luke Ricketson etc etc ...

Of course this sounds like a dream come true given the NSW Cup future the Jets\Bluebags have been resigned to.
If Wests had stayed axed after that horrible night back in 1983 when both the Magpies and Jets were shown the door I'm sure I'd feel exactly as you do ... I'd probably be getting stuck into Balmain supporters bemoaning the fact that Parramatta are dominating their floundering partnership ... Adding, you don't know how lucky you are.

It's all relative ... I could add - at least Newtown are in first division and premiers at that ... Try being a Glebe supporter ... Bit tough for those poor buggers ... Did I say, it's all relative?
 
@Snodgrass said:
They were the days. Johnny Purcell battling with Shane Day for the Magpies number 12 jersey. Both excellent hookers too.

And yeah, this thread has fired old Snoddy up a tad.
There is an imbalance … and Wests diehards feel this imbalance season after season.
So I pledge that from 3.40 Sunday the whatever of November to do my bit to redress said imbalance by referring to the JV club from here in and for ever more as WESTS and WESTS only.

I have vowed to uphold a monastic emblem of silence.

Carn WESTS ... WESTS to win ... I support WESTS ... Great try WESTS ... Robbie Farah's is a WESTS legend ... WESTS are on fire ... WESTS .... WESTS ... WESTS ...
\
\
It's been working for me since 2000 Snoddy. Never has the word "Tigers" been screamed from my lungs. :smiley:

Now that was really quite cathartic

Yeah, that works for me.
 
@Snodgrass said:
They were the days. Johnny Purcell battling with Shane Day for the Magpies number 12 jersey. Both excellent hookers too.

And yeah, this thread has fired old Snoddy up a tad.
There is an imbalance … and Wests diehards feel this imbalance season after season.
So I pledge that from 3.40 Sunday the whatever of November to do my bit to redress said imbalance by referring to the JV club from here in and for ever more as WESTS and WESTS only.

I have vowed to uphold a monastic emblem of silence.

Carn WESTS ... WESTS to win ... I support WESTS ... Great try WESTS ... Robbie Farah's is a WESTS legend ... WESTS are on fire ... WESTS .... WESTS ... WESTS ...

Now that was really quite cathartic

Yeah, that works for me.

It has been working for me since 2000 Snoddy.
 
Snoddy I don't know what you do for a crust but your talents are going to waste IMO
I could see you working for Hallmark, possible bringing back bush poetry or even writing the messages inside fortune cookies for Chinese restaurants. I thoroughly enjoy reading yours and AHX posts and outlook on things. Keep up the good work champ!
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
@shane2801 said:
@Snodgrass said:
They were the days. Johnny Purcell battling with Shane Day for the Magpies number 12 jersey. Both excellent hookers too.

And yeah, this thread has fired old Snoddy up a tad.
There is an imbalance … and Wests diehards feel this imbalance season after season.
So I pledge that from 3.40 Sunday the whatever of November to do my bit to redress said imbalance by referring to the JV club from here in and for ever more as WESTS and WESTS only.

I have vowed to uphold a monastic emblem of silence.

Carn WESTS ... WESTS to win ... I support WESTS ... Great try WESTS ... Robbie Farah's is a WESTS legend ... WESTS are on fire ... WESTS .... WESTS ... WESTS ...

Now that was really quite catharti

Yeah, that works for me.

It has been working for me since 2000 Snoddy.

Happy for you Shane.
Truly I am.

Perhaps I just need to keep taking the pills.
Not the orange ones Doc, I just can't pop those orange ones !
 
@weststigers4life said:
Snoddy I don't know what you do for a crust but your talents are going to waste IMO
I could see you working for Hallmark, possible bringing back bush poetry or even writing the messages inside fortune cookies for Chinese restaurants. I thoroughly enjoy reading yours and AHX posts and outlook on things. Keep up the good work champ!
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

Thanks Wests–---4life. Too kind.
I'm actually between illusions just at the moment ...
But I do like the Chinese fortune cookie suggestion ... Confucius likes pearls of wisdom infused with a Lidcombe Oval softening up period ... east meets west ...
 
@Snodgrass said:
@weststigers4life said:
Snoddy I don't know what you do for a crust but your talents are going to waste IMO
I could see you working for Hallmark, possible bringing back bush poetry or even writing the messages inside fortune cookies for Chinese restaurants. I thoroughly enjoy reading yours and AHX posts and outlook on things. Keep up the good work champ!
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

Thanks Wests–---4life. Too kind.
I'm actually between illusions just at the moment ...
But I do like the Chinese fortune cookie suggestion ... Confucius likes pearls of wisdom infused with a Lidcombe Oval softening up period ... east meets west ...

You certainly have a talent with how you express yourself. This ex tiger respects you.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
Imagine how the steelers are feeling, they get called either St.George or the dragons. On rare occasions do you hear St.George-Illawarraw and never "
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
"The Steelers" sorry accidentally sent previous post before finishing and I can't edit either
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 
seriously there should be a separate forum for the whingers titled "Done to Death" because this topic has been just that. im over hearing the people complaining from both sides of the merger its getting a real pain in the a**e. mods can just merge any new threads along these lines into it and people can froth over it there on their own.
we can only have one logo, the fact we have one main logo and the other on the shoulder is wrong in my opinion. there should be one and one only, the merger was settled and one got name the other got the logo. we should be thankful our old clubs are still around in some form with the merger, there's a long list of clubs since foundation that arent around anymore never to be seen again, if wests or balmain opted to go it alone they would of been on that list also.
 
@glebe_tiger said:
seriously there should be a separate forum for the whingers titled "Done to Death" because this topic has been just that. **im over hearing the people complaining from both sides of the merger its getting a real pain in the a**e.**

Oh really?

mods can just merge any new threads along these lines into it and people can froth over it there on their own.
we can only have one logo, **the fact we have one main logo and the other on the shoulder is wrong in my opinion. there should be one and one only, the merger was settled and one got name the other got the logo.** we should be thankful our old clubs are still around in some form with the merger, there's a long list of clubs since foundation that arent around anymore never to be seen again, if wests or balmain opted to go it alone they would of been on that list also.

Oh

really?
 
@weststigers4life said:
I don't think anyone was happy about having to merge when it happened but once I accepted it, i personally thought that Balmain and Wests was a better fit than the failed Northern Eagles where Manly were the dominate stakeholders or likewise with St George Illawarra were Saints are the dominate stakeholders. Both pre merger clubs still have a pathway for the juniors to make it to the NRL until they get to the 20's were they come under the WT umbrella.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

Spot on WT4L, well said.
 
snoddy i here your argument, but i think people tend to notice the things you dont associate with more, you often here refeences to fibros, plenty call them Wests and often they interview tommy raudonkis or noel kelly and from time to time rthur summons as former club legends. We have a predominantly white strip at times.
When you make compromises it is easy to note the sacrifices your making, less so the sacrifices the other party makes.
 
I'm surprised people still go to the effort of typing " just get over it". The thread tittle pretty much outlines what you are going to expect to find in here. Just a suggestion fellas, it's not mandatory to reply in a thread especially if your input is either "get over it" or " blah blah past blah wingers blah blah". That's advice you can use in many places on the net btw.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
 

Latest posts

Back
Top