Lui
- Thread starter tiger05
- Start date
happy_tiger
Well-known member
Defensively horrible at times tonight Attack was not great either but I don't think at times it would be easy being the 7 in this side . Last week Farah looked like at times he was playing for Origin and this week they did not gel . He still has it but our go forward needs to improve . Suppose that will happen when we don't have 17 turnovers in a game
Marshall_magic
New member
He was not up to standard tonight.
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@Cultured Bogan said:
I do have one question CB If Lui is still playing as bad as he has last 2 weeks in a months time 'what then ???
tigerbenji
Well-known member
Ididnt like his defence to-night as he was grabbing @ them & it makes you look bad. but he wasnt the only ordinary player out there to-night.
G
Guest
Guest
@tiger05 said:
1 try assist, 1 grubber kick resulting in a line drop out, 20 tackles and he missed 2 tackles, one of which the Panthers scored from. Not a great game by any means but far from the dribble you are trying to make it out to be. I've seen plenty of performances worse than that from previous Tigers halfbacks.
Haha this thread is a classic. Lui has a poor (not bad) and the usual suspects react by trying to drag moltz into it as cover!
Lol
Could see this coming from a mile away!
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Lol
Could see this coming from a mile away!
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
biggest_tigers_fan
New member
@Kul said:
But you are in the moltz 7 fan club kul :laughing:
851
Well-known member
Lui was shocking,his handling his defence is ordinary,I said 2 weeks back,Miller is our future,anyone who watched the TC today,or any week for that matter would know this.
He is aggressive in defence,his options in attack are usually spot on,he should be given the 7 jumper,Lui is playing on last years cred,his defence is worse than Sandow's,his option taking and hands are poor,and his fitness looks below NRL level.
He is aggressive in defence,his options in attack are usually spot on,he should be given the 7 jumper,Lui is playing on last years cred,his defence is worse than Sandow's,his option taking and hands are poor,and his fitness looks below NRL level.
Kul, I'm merely pre-empting the typical knee jerk reactions to a bad performance. I'll concede he didn't set the world on fire but he wasn't woeful as some have us believe.
Generally the Moltzen brigade come out in force when Lui puts in an ordinary performance.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Generally the Moltzen brigade come out in force when Lui puts in an ordinary performance.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
TigersFan4Life
New member
That touch finder that gained about ten metres was a shocker.
C
crystalpink74
Guest
Good on you Willow. Was at the game & watching it again now, Yes i agree that Lui didn't have a good game BUT DAMN let's face it there is definetly something up with our boys in general. I'm so over the whole LUI v's MOLTZEN crap, get over it!!!! They're both in our team & both ONLY 21, give em a break. They BOTH have ALOT to learn & lets leave it at that. Sorry guys for going on but 1 player alone doesn't win or lose a game.(Except for Ennis, Origin 3, 2010, hehehe).
gallagher
Well-known member
@TigersFan4Life said:
Benji put in a similar kick. Lets really disrupt the halves that got us within a penalty of the g/f and sack them both. farah half and moltz 5/8???
Tigerdave
Well-known member
@tiger05 said:
I think you may need to go back and watch some John Morris at half games….
The bulk of the side was out of sorts last night, bit rough to target just 1 guy.
Who is the best option for half?
@Tigerdave said:
I couldn't stand Morris at 7 but Lui last night took it to a new level. There was a point where I was saying just don't give him the ball. They did and sure enough he dropped it.
I still think he is the best option at half. Moltzen could be an option but we haven't seen him there in ages so I don't want to go down that path. Miller looks a gun but I think he needs a lot more time before being given another chance.
I suppose I'd stick with Lui but if that continues you'd have to think that Moltzen or Miller would need to come into the team.
I started the thread in frustration with his performance not looking for another option.
Tiger_Watto
New member
Anyone pointing the finger at Lui has no idea… Have a closer look at your "6" boys and girls!!!
If Tim Sheens has any balls, we will line up in the halves next week with 7\. Lui 6\. Moltzen... Sadly, it wont happen and sadly we will be the same team week in, week out.
If Tim Sheens has any balls, we will line up in the halves next week with 7\. Lui 6\. Moltzen... Sadly, it wont happen and sadly we will be the same team week in, week out.
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@Tiger Watto said:
I think that Benji ,Lui and Farah have littl faith in the outside backs(apart from Ayshford) and that is half the problem
Bit of an overreaction, but it only proves that he's simply not a halfback. He's the furthest player from a halfback we've got. He's a good 5/8th, but not at all a halfback.
He's young and talented, but he's not going to reach any heights here at halfback. Moving to a team where he could play 5/8th outside of a genuine halfback would help him a lot more. A team like the Panthers, who struggle for creativity.
He's young and talented, but he's not going to reach any heights here at halfback. Moving to a team where he could play 5/8th outside of a genuine halfback would help him a lot more. A team like the Panthers, who struggle for creativity.
AndTheKungFoSing
New member
@Tiger Watto said:
You are kidding!
Moltzen should be nowhere near first grade. Let only in the halves….
Benji has 2 poor games, despite be leaps and bounds ahead of any player prior and he should be dropped?
I used to be long critical of Marshall, but this year he has been outstanding imo. (Last night though was very poor).
