Q. How do you turn a good player into an average player?
A. It can take a few years, but on a positive note, it’s something we have been good at.
So you don’t put any onus on the player?
It’s all the clubs fault, is it?
Don’t think so.
I don’t think it’s fair to say that Brooks’ poor form rests on his shoulders alone. You may mount an argument that we are all masters of our own destiny, but at the same time, we all behave in accordance with the expectations of others. It’s in our DNA, and particularly so in a team environment. In a team sport, just as a coach can improve performance of a team and individuals in that team, it stands to reason that a coach (or poor club culture) can produce the opposite. As much as us fans get frustrated at a players poor performance when we know he has the skill, we need to acknowledge external influences and cultural expectation.
If your club operates without organisational discipline, pays overs for players at the end of their careers, mismanages the cap to the extent that it has to buy affordable plodders or unwanted players, then yes I do think that has an affect on club morale and consequently individual player performance.
However you want to look at it, the guy hasn’t stepped up to control the side, everyone wants to blame other players except the bloke whose job it was.
I hope he turns it around, but he really does control his own game and his footy future.
I suppose the lights are shining on Brooks because of the position he plays? So which players in the team have had stellar performances throughout 2020?
I just don’t want to see Brooks get turfed when we’ve not fixed the real problem. The cause of his, or any other players poor performance?
How do we fix the real problem, the cause of all the players problems if we don't turf any of them?
Cochise, I don’t know what the real problem is, but I do know that a team’s poor performance is a reflection of it. It is a symptom, not the problem itself. I honestly believe the club has given up trying to be comfortable with mediocrity, it gets harder to justify as time goes by. I just don’t believe in wasting money moving players (with skill) on due to poor performance until we discover and rectify the issue. If it’s a deeply embedded attitude issue which cannot be changed then a change of scenery can do wonders. All that information is above my pay rate, but I do suspect there have been fairly simple reasons why we haven’t played finals for a decade? Is it the 7?
What’s your view mate?
My post was more tongue in cheek, no I don't think our problems are Brooks.
I see we have 2 real issues squad strength and mental toughness and these both manifest themselves in similar ways.
In relation to squad strength, to compete with the better team we need to be red lining, basically playing the edge of our ability the entire game while the better teams get sit in a comfortable space. This results in us making mistakes at crucial times do to having to maintain our best football for long stretches of time. This was evident in the games against Parra and Penrith last year, though while we were competitive you always knew we were going to be the team to break 1st as we were playing harder to be competitive.
This comes to the 2nd point, mental toughness, when we do break we don't have the toughness to overcome the setback. This is shown through our inability to win the big moments, both in a game and throughout the course of the season, it is the reason for our winning the hard games and losing the supposedly easier games.
Now I believe both of these are being addressed but they are what I believe to be the reasons for our 9 years without finals.
I agree, that those two deficiencies you elude to are the reason we have been losing games. What I don’t understand is why we have not addressed those issues during such a long period of time? This is the question which leads me to believe that the solution will not be found bubbling on the surface in the public domain. As previously stated, I’ve always believed that the strength of the entire organisation is on display on game day. Those players reflect the traditional values held by others in the club.
It is a very difficult thing to fix because the mental weakness aspect gets past from player to player. You really need the right people to come in and identify the issues and how to fix them. Now when you are turning over coaches every 2 years it is impossible to rectify.
We have the right people here now to fix it but they need to be given the time to fix it.
Isn’t that a major issue for us now, time?
What is it now, 10 years?
We need to get mentally tougher players if that is the case, which brings us back to Brooks, we have basically changed the whole team while he has been here.
I still think he will be on very thin ice if he doesn’t deliver this season.
You can't change the entire team at once.