Madge Maguire - Mega Thread

[Newtown]

Came down to the side line, do a little dance for the cameras.

Pick the same team next week.

Rinse, repeat...

@cochise ; Remember when I use to claim you were accepting of medocority and pleased with us coming 9th? What I would do for a 9th place finish.... very dark years ahead I believe.

Hopefully next week Ivan can help get another coach out of wests

Why did we sign Madge when he was kicked out from souths and no other club wanted him ? Wests Tigers, cut your future financial losses and sack him now.

 

[Newtown]

You know what the difference is between us and say,Storm,Rabbits Panthers and Roosters....
those other teams players ,support the ball carrier ,move up in defense,cut out errors.always strive to be on the front foot,complete sets and PLAY FOR EACH OTHER....

thats what we lack because our guys are young and error riddled...its called Pressure and they cant handle it....today proved that ...they score first and then turn to water under the pressure of defending the lead....downvote me call me whatever you want ...Truth hurts a lot of people ...but I stand by what I say...

The team cannot play for each when they all dislike Madge immensely.

 

[Guest]

Just watched the post-match press conference - there's a bloke who was struggling to contain his emotions. Looked to me like he wanted to cry and break something at the same time. Very disappointed with the team's mentality - but that's been a problem for years where they don't aim up when it matters most.

Disappointed in how easy we lost the ruck, no line speed in defence and no one willing to do the hard yards to turn that around. Disappointed that the Sharks back 5 went through the WT middle - said they had prepared for it but just didn't deal with it. Another disappointing end to the season.

 

[Guest]

You know what the difference is between us and say,Storm,Rabbits Panthers and Roosters....
those other teams players ,support the ball carrier ,move up in defense,cut out errors.always strive to be on the front foot,complete sets and PLAY FOR EACH OTHER....

thats what we lack because our guys are young and error riddled...its called Pressure and they cant handle it....today proved that ...they score first and then turn to water under the pressure of defending the lead....downvote me call me whatever you want ...Truth hurts a lot of people ...but I stand by what I say...

The team cannot play for each when they all dislike Madge immensely.

How do you know they dislike him?

 

[TrueTiger]

You know what the difference is between us and say,Storm,Rabbits Panthers and Roosters....
those other teams players ,support the ball carrier ,move up in defense,cut out errors.always strive to be on the front foot,complete sets and PLAY FOR EACH OTHER....

thats what we lack because our guys are young and error riddled...its called Pressure and they cant handle it....today proved that ...they score first and then turn to water under the pressure of defending the lead....downvote me call me whatever you want ...Truth hurts a lot of people ...but I stand by what I say...

The team cannot play for each when they all dislike Madge immensely.

Do you have facts that they DISLIKE MADGE IMMENSLEY or are you listening and reading what suits the narrative...

 

[Snake]

Came down to the side line, do a little dance for the cameras.

Pick the same team next week.

Rinse, repeat...

@cochise ; Remember when I use to claim you were accepting of medocority and pleased with us coming 9th? What I would do for a 9th place finish.... very dark years ahead I believe.

Hopefully next week Ivan can help get another coach out of wests

Why did we sign Madge when he was kicked out from souths and no other club wanted him ? Wests Tigers, cut your future financial losses and sack him now.

There is no financial loss the club pays zip if he is punted apparently in his contract !

 

[Snake]

You know what the difference is between us and say,Storm,Rabbits Panthers and Roosters....
those other teams players ,support the ball carrier ,move up in defense,cut out errors.always strive to be on the front foot,complete sets and PLAY FOR EACH OTHER....

thats what we lack because our guys are young and error riddled...its called Pressure and they cant handle it....today proved that ...they score first and then turn to water under the pressure of defending the lead....downvote me call me whatever you want ...Truth hurts a lot of people ...but I stand by what I say...

The team cannot play for each when they all dislike Madge immensely.

Do you have facts that they DISLIKE MADGE IMMENSLEY or are you listening and reading what suits the narrative...

Does this team have a commitment to the coach ? The results tell you that no narrative just check the results ! They do not lye !

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Just watched the post-match press conference - there's a bloke who was struggling to contain his emotions. Looked to me like he wanted to cry and break something at the same time. Very disappointed with the team's mentality - but that's been a problem for years where they don't aim up when it matters most.

Disappointed in how easy we lost the ruck, no line speed in defence and no one willing to do the hard yards to turn that around. Disappointed that the Sharks back 5 went through the WT middle - said they had prepared for it but just didn't deal with it. Another disappointing end to the season.

I just viewed it on tv, which is the usual deer in headlights performance. Come on Justin sack him and let's move on.

 

[TigerTownSFS]

My god he looked broken in the press conference. He’s not going to last

 

[mike]

You know what the difference is between us and say,Storm,Rabbits Panthers and Roosters....
those other teams players ,support the ball carrier ,move up in defense,cut out errors.always strive to be on the front foot,complete sets and PLAY FOR EACH OTHER....

thats what we lack because our guys are young and error riddled...its called Pressure and they cant handle it....today proved that ...they score first and then turn to water under the pressure of defending the lead....downvote me call me whatever you want ...Truth hurts a lot of people ...but I stand by what I say...

The team cannot play for each when they all dislike Madge immensely.

Do you have facts that they DISLIKE MADGE IMMENSLEY or are you listening and reading what suits the narrative...


Does this team have a commitment to the coach ? The results tell you that no narrative just check the results ! They do not lye !

Correlation is not causation. Your assertion is based on diddly squat.

 

[TrueTiger]

You know what the difference is between us and say,Storm,Rabbits Panthers and Roosters....
those other teams players ,support the ball carrier ,move up in defense,cut out errors.always strive to be on the front foot,complete sets and PLAY FOR EACH OTHER....

thats what we lack because our guys are young and error riddled...its called Pressure and they cant handle it....today proved that ...they score first and then turn to water under the pressure of defending the lead....downvote me call me whatever you want ...Truth hurts a lot of people ...but I stand by what I say...

The team cannot play for each when they all dislike Madge immensely.

Do you have facts that they DISLIKE MADGE IMMENSLEY or are you listening and reading what suits the narrative...


Does this team have a commitment to the coach ? The results tell you that no narrative just check the results ! They do not lye !

The players get paid to win games,if they cant play for the coach maybe they should be the ones people vent their hate against...its big business,if you sign up to do a job you do it to your utmost ability,its how it works,if you cant maybe have a good hard look at yourself and find another career...

 

[aturkey]

Anyone thinking Madge can coach this team is as delusional as him at this point.

Presser today : he says "anything can happen" from here.

We are 4 out of the 8 with two games left...and 100 points behind on F and A.

Last two weeks were against extremely poor opposition with half their sides missing...yet he claims 'those' games showed what we can be. Really? Today we had a step up in class vs a team minus half their best players...50 conceded.

Any coach with a brain would know the season has been shot for ages and used the past 6 weeks to build for 2022. But not our bloke, still playing Luc L for the entire game and then wondering why that edge leaks tries....not a word about his mate 'Dave' dancing around rather than committing one way or the other on overlaps...

Nothing will change whilst he is the coach. We have the best injury record in the NRL...teams above us have been decimated for months. Yet we are 13th.

Same old clueless clichés post game...at this point I have just accepted nothing will change until him, Brooks and Nofa go.

No point even getting upset or debating it anymore.

Theres nothing to debate. Everything you say is objective and true. This season has been a disaster.

 

[ElleryHanley]

Anyone thinking Madge can coach this team is as delusional as him at this point.

Presser today : he says "anything can happen" from here.

We are 4 out of the 8 with two games left...and 100 points behind on F and A.

Last two weeks were against extremely poor opposition with half their sides missing...yet he claims 'those' games showed what we can be. Really? Today we had a step up in class vs a team minus half their best players...50 conceded.

Any coach with a brain would know the season has been shot for ages and used the past 6 weeks to build for 2022. But not our bloke, still playing Luc L for the entire game and then wondering why that edge leaks tries....not a word about his mate 'Dave' dancing around rather than committing one way or the other on overlaps...

Nothing will change whilst he is the coach. We have the best injury record in the NRL...teams above us have been decimated for months. Yet we are 13th.

Same old clueless clichés post game...at this point I have just accepted nothing will change until him, Brooks and Nofa go.

No point even getting upset or debating it anymore.

Theres nothing to debate. Everything you say is objective and true. This season has been a disaster.

Sadly, it has reached that point mate. The debate, back and forth, different views...there is just nothing left to say.

It is like debating whether a horse that has had 30 starts without winning... and just placed second last in a country maiden...might one day win an Arc De Triomphe...

 

[Guest]

I switch off when he starts to rattle off his cliches and I only have to endure a weekly press conference.
The players' eyes must glaze over every time he opens his mouth.

 

[yeahcaz]

I can’t believe he said “you never know what could happen in rugby league” like we are still a chance. Just fall on your bloody sword seriously.

 

[sheer64]

The biggest mistakes Madge has made is the re contracting of under performing players.

 

[getagrip]

You know what the difference is between us and say,Storm,Rabbits Panthers and Roosters....
those other teams players ,support the ball carrier ,move up in defense,cut out errors.always strive to be on the front foot,complete sets and PLAY FOR EACH OTHER....

thats what we lack because our guys are young and error riddled...its called Pressure and they cant handle it....today proved that ...they score first and then turn to water under the pressure of defending the lead....downvote me call me whatever you want ...Truth hurts a lot of people ...but I stand by what I say...

The team cannot play for each when they all dislike Madge immensely.

Do you have facts that they DISLIKE MADGE IMMENSLEY or are you listening and reading what suits the narrative...


Does this team have a commitment to the coach ? The results tell you that no narrative just check the results ! They do not lye !

This " team" has no commitment to themselves , their club or their coach. Why not??

 

[Droppy]

Just get rid of him. Players are not playing for him. We have to do something and this seems to be the easiest thing to do.We can't do worse than what we have in the last 3 years.

 

[TrueTiger]

Just get rid of him. Players are not playing for him. We have to do something and this seems to be the easiest thing to do.We can't do worse than what we have in the last 3 years.

He hasnt had this ROSTER for 3 years....be at least a little fair in your critique of the guy....

 

[mike]

Just get rid of him. Players are not playing for him. We have to do something and this seems to be the easiest thing to do.We can't do worse than what we have in the last 3 years.

Easiest is not necessarily the best. We could do a lot worse ruining our junior development in the process. aka Ivan Cleary, it’s taken this long to get it back on track