Marshall should finish NRL career at Wests Tigers: Lawrence
- Thread starter innsaneink
- Start date
Yep at 3 or 4
He needs to come home
He needs to come home
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@Newtown said:
Benji couldn't coach what he had at his best .
Tigerdave
Well-known member
On the surface, yeah I'd like to see him back, to finish off his career with us. With everything that happened it's soured his legacy here, could that be redeemed somewhat if he came back though? maybe.
I don't think I'd want him playing though, although as Milky and Kul suggested, centre does seem appealing.
I don't think I'd want him playing though, although as Milky and Kul suggested, centre does seem appealing.
foreveratiger
New member
The Days of re-signing players on sentiments should be long gone…..after all it's the reason it got us in a mess in the 1st place.
Rugby League is a Business and that's how we have to operate it .
Benji will always be a Wests Tigers favourite to everyone lets keep it that way.....in the past.
Rugby League is a Business and that's how we have to operate it .
Benji will always be a Wests Tigers favourite to everyone lets keep it that way.....in the past.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
As much as I haven't been able to stomach him the last couple yrs, including when he was here, I'd be lying if this didn't make me feel a little nostalgic. If he could get himself fit, he could be an option I'm the centres.
hammertime
Well-known member
The club does need an image boost right now. Would be a good way to do it, as long as we don't displace anyone that were looking to resign, I.e. Brooks and moses
foreveratiger
New member
What do you guys think he would be worth $200,000 - $300,000 a Season.
It would be like an Anasta signing nothing was achieved by getting him here.
We have allowed Moses and Brooks to learn the hard way in finding there feet in the NRL, let's not even contemplate in changing things around now.
They have learnt the hard way and within 2 years they will be an absolute dynamite of a partnership I reckon.
It would be like an Anasta signing nothing was achieved by getting him here.
We have allowed Moses and Brooks to learn the hard way in finding there feet in the NRL, let's not even contemplate in changing things around now.
They have learnt the hard way and within 2 years they will be an absolute dynamite of a partnership I reckon.
supercoach
Well-known member
The players, the coaches,the board and the punters have to focus on looking forward and stop looking back. Benji will always be remembered as one of the greats at the WestsTigers so just lets leave it at that.
Of course if either Brooks or Moses decided to take up a offer elsewhere things might be different, but that of course would depend who is on the market
Of course if either Brooks or Moses decided to take up a offer elsewhere things might be different, but that of course would depend who is on the market
As SC says - "Look forward, not back".
I don't think he has anything to offer us now - too slow and basically plays off the cuff. You can't teach "off the cuff" plays to anyone else. He has learnt a little more structure in the past year (he has had to, so he could survive). He knows no more about structured play than Brooks or Moses. If one of our young guys left we have Rankin to fill the spot. More than capable,
He is now too slow (especially for centre?).
If you want a good send off, let him do a lap at a home game - you don't have to sign him to do that. Know he WAS good, one of our best but personally I prefer bygones to be bygones.
I don't think he has anything to offer us now - too slow and basically plays off the cuff. You can't teach "off the cuff" plays to anyone else. He has learnt a little more structure in the past year (he has had to, so he could survive). He knows no more about structured play than Brooks or Moses. If one of our young guys left we have Rankin to fill the spot. More than capable,
He is now too slow (especially for centre?).
If you want a good send off, let him do a lap at a home game - you don't have to sign him to do that. Know he WAS good, one of our best but personally I prefer bygones to be bygones.
stevetiger
New member
I think he has been our best player by a fair way and I'd love to see him back. I don't know where you would play him though.
I wonder if he could take on a coaching role.
I wonder if he could take on a coaching role.
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@foreveratiger said:
You need to pull an 0 off before he becomes attractive
N
newtiger
Guest
I though that Marshall's career was finished at the Tigers!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Magpie_Ryan
New member
We arent in a position to make sentimental signings unfortunately,it would be nice to see him finish with wests but we need to prioritise signings.
Love Benji all the same!
Love Benji all the same!
Magpie_Ryan
New member
We arent in a position to make sentimental signings unfortunately,it would be nice to see him finish with wests but we need to prioritise signings.
Love Benji all the same!
Love Benji all the same!
Bringing Pat Richards back didn't really let us down…
Maybe Benji could lead us to a grand final win before he throws in the towel?
Doubt it though, not worth taking a chance with either.
There is no position for him in our team, full strength.
Maybe Benji could lead us to a grand final win before he throws in the towel?
Doubt it though, not worth taking a chance with either.
There is no position for him in our team, full strength.
Harvey
Well-known member
If Moses and Brooks do not re-sign, he might be an option. We let Martin go, and not sure that we have a whole lot coming through that could play 1st grade next year. Much better option than Drinkwater.
