Match Review and Judiciary Thread

[Tucker]

Round 16 results. Another clean sheet for us at the judiciary. Roosters have now overtaken us for the most ill disciplined. Well done to the squad for working on this. No coincidence we have started winning once we got this in check.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

In fact there was a co incidence. Our sin bin illegitimate or not cost us 18 points..

 

[Tucker]

In fact there was a co incidence. Our sin bin illegitimate or not cost us 18 points..

Good reason to be working on our discipline then.
Cant afford to give up that many points

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

We have already. Didnt you just say that 2 posts ago. Total co incidence? Doubt it. How many Canberra players disciplined yesterday? Can you please post stats for that?

 

[Tucker]

Total co incidence? Doubt it.

I said it’s no coincidence.
Once we started working on the backchat and illegal play, we start winning.
For the first 15 weeks we were the worst side discipline wise. 3 clean sheets at the judiciary in a row and viola….we start playing football.

How many Canberra players disciplined yesterday? Can you please post stats for that?

We were penalised more. It’s a work in progress.

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

As Joey pointed out, Pauga got off very lightly with a 4 week suspension. It was reckless and late. He deserved 6 weeks+.

 

[Tucker]

Round 17 results. 2 in the bin, 4 on report, 2 charged and found guilty. Need to do better.

 

[innsaneink]

JWH cops four weeks for playing the game too hard.

Penalty at best sufficient... I hate the way the games going it's insane

On one hand they promote tough hard footy... And then they punish those that play it the way we all want to see it played

 

[Tucker]

View attachment 13540

JWH cops four weeks for playing the game too hard.

Penalty at best sufficient... I hate the way the games going it's insane

On one hand they promote tough hard footy... And then they punish those that play it the way we all want to see it played

Its a bloody disgrace.
He is going to be nice and fresh for the finals though and a tad upset at the game. If the Roosters make the GF he will go beast mode like weve never seen before.

 

[Tucker]

Round 18 resuls at the judiciary. Some teams have copped some suspensions. For us, it was another week where we scored a sin bin, 2 on report and 2 charged. Luckily they only resulted in fines.

 

[Tucker]

Round 19 results at the judiciary. Pretty quiet week with the short round. Only the one suspension which was the BS grade 2 for Kennedy running the ref over.

 

[tiger_one]

 

[Tucker]

Its funny that DCE and Luai escaped charge when they are the two who actually struck each other in the face LOL.
Also, Walsh should have got something for striking.

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

Its funny that DCE and Luai escaped charge when they are the two who actually struck each other in the face LOL.
Also, Walsh should have got something for striking.

And the d head Nanai who escalated everything copped nothing

 

[Tucker]

And the d head Nanai who escalated everything copped nothing

Yeah he is losing 20%. Do they still get $30k/game? Thats a $6k slug.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Dont stress. Not coming out of your pay packet. For Nanai its like $100 for us. He will be okay. They all will. Whilst playing football.

 

[rugbygoated]

Its funny that DCE and Luai escaped charge when they are the two who actually struck each other in the face LOL.
Also, Walsh should have got something for striking.

DCE should have been binned. Nanai should have been suspended. He started the whole thing. It was a one on one fight and he escalated it off the field into the bench which brought guys like Murray and Haumole involved

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

We should just cancel it all. Bin them all. Criminals. All of them.. bringing the game into disrepute

 

[Tucker]

Round 20 results at the judiciary. Pretty full on weekend with 11 charges out of Origin and a few more over the round resulting in 6 sin bins, 17 charges, $32 500.00 in fines and 4 players being suspended for a total of 8 weeks. Aidan Sezer has continued with his ill discipline and is now arguably our worst offender this season.

 

[tiger_one]

Wests Tigers forward Alex Seyfarth has been charged by the NRL Match Review Committee over a tackle on Warriors playmaker Te Maire Martin in Friday night's 28-16 loss.

Seyfarth was charged with Grade 1 Dangerous Contact and faces a fine of $1800 if he pleads guilty or $2500 if she unsuccessfully challenges the charge at the NRL judiciary.