Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?

[Guest]

Discuss.

 

[isaaktigers]

Yeah, never liked him and never thought it was a good player.

No passion.

He should retire and be a drongo

 

[TigerNeddyK]

Discuss.

By far, with daylight second…. He does not even try……

 

[mike]

Discuss.

Maybe not the worse but certainly up there.

 

[Demps]

Top 5 at least.

Talau is useless too.
Should never see grade again.

 

[Guest]

Apparently he gives good service.
Can't tackle. Constantly out of position. Never, I mean never runs the ball.
But he can shovel a pass out, so it's all good.

AND STILL HAS NEVER BEEN DROPPED.

 

[watersider]

Nowhere near the worst but he looks awfully outclassed tonight.

 

[Guest]

First 3 tries were all Mbye.
He actually missed Hynes TWICE when he scored.
Smith's try......leaves a 10 metre gap between him and Luciano on the line.

 

[earl]

First 3 tries were all Mbye.
He actually missed Hynes TWICE when he scored.
Smith's try......leaves a 10 metre gap between him and Luciano on the line.

His one good point has been his defense and this is how he has defended tonight. Value for money he has to be up there. Reynolds, Packer, & Mbye are the winning trifecta.

 

[WT2K]

Probably not the worst but he's definitely in the top 5 or so

 

[Harvey]

In terms of passion and effort, definitely a top 3 player

 

[ElleryHanley]

Mbye actually said two months ago..."sometimes a change is needed to freshen you up".

850 a year and he needs freshening up...

He clocked off months ago.

Some nice ball playing at times, but that is the easy bit. **Absolutely 0% in all the effort areas.**

 

[jadtiger]

First 3 tries were all Mbye.
He actually missed Hynes TWICE when he scored.
Smith's try......leaves a 10 metre gap between him and Luciano on the line.

He and Lucy were diabolical in that first half and not much better in the second.Traffic cops the pair of them,i felt sorry for JTJ and Nofo having to try and cover for them

 

[kratos]

Didn't watch the game properly today but was the the box last week and met him and he said he pulled out cos he was injured and couldn't move properly and didn't want to let the boys down. I wouldn't be surprised if he got rushed in cos walters was that bad last week.

 

[sheer64]

He is our marquee signing with love from IC.

 

[theraptor456]

Between Mbye and Talau you're looking at 2 of our worst players in the last decade

 

[weststigerman]

No. The sad thing is our worst player is actually out with an ACL.

 

[dazza65]

Discuss.

Talau: hold my beer….

 

[Tiger5150]

Not even the worst in this team

 

[bigsiro]

Top 5 at least.

Talau is useless too.
Should never see grade again.

He would never have played this many games at any other club