OFFICIAL Moses Mbye [Discussion]

[twentyforty]

Straight swap for Milf


Im interested in the logic behind this or is it a gee up?


Logic? Here’s some. There’s a theory that if Milf was on a lower contract then he would play like a superstar.

Really ? So it’s a psychological issue with him ? I don’t buy it . I think he saw himself as a 6 , he was a fullback , got fat after his awesome season, stopped working on his craft , and now the rest of the NRL went past him. He’s been playing catch up ever since . Where does he fit in ? Laurie is better, AD is the perfect body shape for a modern day 6 , and Brooks , despite what you think , is better than him. . So what , play him in the Black and white jersey , until we need him ? I can see him wearing a Manly jersey , or staying put at the broncos . Or he will be playing in Huddersfield this time next year .

I just put that up as an example of the crazy logic being pedalled. ? this nonsense that a player will perform better if he’s paid less is reverse Pygmalion, could only happen in an environment void of answers.
I rate Brooks in the top 6 nrl 7s. Show me where I’ve stated differently and then you can start telling me what I think. ?

 

[Snake]

Moses does see what's around the corner ,by round 6 barring injury subs he will be playing out of Lidcombe oval . He needs to get interested parties lined up soon as possible .He is a reliable player Imo nothing special you never notice him on field no stand out, he got lucky and won the lottery and good luck to him . I see him him gone before the end of the season there are some very desperate clubs around at the moment with some very average players in key positions , I would imagine he will accept a big hair cut on money to get a long term deal elsewhere.

 

[rihannafan1]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

Simply seems to me that the club are trying to get value for money. He's not on much and plays in a position of need. He doesn't make us worse.

Brooks will soon be our highest player and won't be on crazy money. Racking up cheapies like Naden are a risk but won't lock up our cap. Sooner or later we'll either be able to spend all that saved money on a star or comfortably upgrade our own talent.

 

[happy_tiger]

Really depends how much of his salary we can right off or someone is prepared to pay

If we are having to write off 500 k ...you'd keep him ...he can fill a lot of gaps in my opinion and does a decent job

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Fill 'my glass' Rothfield

I wish his Pancreas would just fail already.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

Simply seems to me that the club are trying to get value for money. He's not on much and plays in a position of need. He doesn't make us worse.

Brooks will soon be our highest player and won't be on crazy money. Racking up cheapies like Naden are a risk but won't lock up our cap. Sooner or later we'll either be able to spend all that saved money on a star or comfortably upgrade our own talent.

Yes, he would be better value than BJ. He would improve us. I don't like him, I think he's a knucklehead on and off the field but he's young and has time to turn his life around.

 

[gallagher]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

I think he walks into our team. You don't agree?

 

[JC99]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

I think he walks into our team. You don't agree?

Starting winger for sure

 

[gallagher]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

I think he walks into our team. You don't agree?

Starting winger for sure

Or center.

 

[TrueTiger]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

I think he walks into our team. You don't agree?

He probably does Gal,but I think he looks good in a well organised team..he may find it tougher to excel in our team when we are just getting the team to gel and the young ones NRL experience...he appears to be a talent,but what effect would his off field behaviour have on our guys,knowing that he had something to do with drugs...

 

[happy_tiger]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

I think he walks into our team. You don't agree?

He probably does Gal,but I think he looks good in a well organised team..he may find it tougher to excel in our team when we are just getting the team to gel and the young ones NRL experience...he appears to be a talent,but what effect would his off field behaviour have on our guys,knowing that he had something to do with drugs...

We need speed ...not speed

 

[gallagher]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

I think he walks into our team. You don't agree?

He probably does Gal,but I think he looks good in a well organised team..he may find it tougher to excel in our team when we are just getting the team to gel and the young ones NRL experience...he appears to be a talent,but what effect would his off field behaviour have on our guys,knowing that he had something to do with drugs...

I'm just judging his onfield performances. The club would need to assess his lifestyle issues but he would fit in with our indigenous program.

 

[twentyforty]

Can't see Naden getting into the riff side anytime soon. He'd be a good replacement.

Im not sold on Naden, does he make us better or are we being impatient again.

I think he walks into our team. You don't agree?

He probably does Gal,but I think he looks good in a well organised team..he may find it tougher to excel in our team when we are just getting the team to gel and the young ones NRL experience...he appears to be a talent,but what effect would his off field behaviour have on our guys,knowing that he had something to do with drugs...

I'm just judging his onfield performances. The club would need to assess his lifestyle issues but he would fit in with our indigenous program.

I’m not going to pass judgment on a players off field behaviour but..I wonder what happens when you get increased numbers of drug and alcohol dependent members of a group? Do they keep each other honest? Or does it go south? What happens?

 

[TigerSJ]

Moses showing the quality that got him the captains job at the club. He was unable to lead by example on the field and has slowly slid down the rankings to find himself struggling to make the 17 in a team trying hard to lift out of mediocrity. He sees the writing on the wall for him at WTs and as always is handling himself with class and the club with respect. May not have been the best buy as a player but certainly one of our best buys as a role model off the field.

 

[versa]

I’d be looking to swap for DCE

 

[sleeve]

Moses does see what's around the corner ,by round 6 barring injury subs he will be playing out of Lidcombe oval . He needs to get interested parties lined up soon as possible .He is a reliable player Imo nothing special you never notice him on field no stand out, he got lucky and won the lottery and good luck to him . I see him him gone before the end of the season there are some very desperate clubs around at the moment with some very average players in key positions , I would imagine he will accept a big hair cut on money to get a long term deal elsewhere.

I would be surprised if his manager has not been scouting for offers previous to this. He has been on the market for quite a while,and i suspect he knows where he's going.

 

[gallagher]

I’d be looking to swap for DCE

What do you reckon he's worth? Money wise

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]

The Cowboys seem desperate and are interested in luring Mbye immediately. Could Moses move as early as this season?

 

[Tiger_Fanatic3]


 

[Geo]

I’d be looking to swap for DCE

What do you reckon he's worth? Money wise

The team he managers has scored 34 points in 4 games and conceded 156..how much is that worth..?