Elderslie_Tiger
Well-known member
@adelaidetiger said in [Moses Mbye Super Duper Thread](/post/1331692) said:
He must have been at WT'S sometime in his career to let go of all those classy players
OFFICIAL Moses Mbye [Discussion]
- Thread starter foreveratiger
- Start date
He must have been at WT'S sometime in his career to let go of all those classy players
Blake
Well-known member
Mbye's average salary over the time he has been with the Tigers is a lot less than 900k per year, the Bulldogs were paying a a big chuck of his salary for the first 2 years.
The statements that he and the club are making look like they are coordinated. They could be reading from a script designed to give Mbye and the Tigers the best outcome.
The statements that he and the club are making look like they are coordinated. They could be reading from a script designed to give Mbye and the Tigers the best outcome.
Signing with dragons in next few days according to brent read...
Damn, thought we had him.
Damn, thought we had him.
hank37w
Well-known member
@spud_murphy said in [Mbye swap for Josh Mcguire Poll](/post/1330031) said:
Think Mbye may still be useful for us for a bit longer yet and I agree that a swap like that would definitely end up being a case of POOR US.
@wt2k said in [Mbye swap for Josh Mcguire Poll](/post/1332116) said:
Moley reporting a three-way swapsies ..MaGuire to Drags , Clune to Cows and Drinkwater to Knights..
D
Deleted member 3518
Guest
@geo said in [Mbye swap for Josh Mcguire Poll](/post/1332138) said:
Drinkwater ? So the Clifford backflip is real after all ?
@strongee said in [Mbye swap for Josh Mcguire Poll](/post/1332142) said:
oh yeah ..him..
Were building our pack with some gun young players.
Musg
Blore
Stefano
Joffa
Twal
Tuki
A frizell type with more than his final years is what we need to assist captain Tamou
No more packers on big money please.
Musg
Blore
Stefano
Joffa
Twal
Tuki
A frizell type with more than his final years is what we need to assist captain Tamou
No more packers on big money please.
Chipofftheoldblock
Well-known member
McGuire is a grub of the highest order.
We need a decent edge backrower to replace Garner and move Twal back to Prop.
I would of said grab Hess but he is the version of looks like Tarzen but plays like Jane.
McGuire does not fit the recruitment mould for our team.
Happy to grab Mitchell Dunn or Shane Wright in swap but dont think that will happen.
We need a decent edge backrower to replace Garner and move Twal back to Prop.
I would of said grab Hess but he is the version of looks like Tarzen but plays like Jane.
McGuire does not fit the recruitment mould for our team.
Happy to grab Mitchell Dunn or Shane Wright in swap but dont think that will happen.
rihannafan1
Well-known member
@geo said in [Mbye swap for Josh Mcguire Poll](/post/1332138) said:
That would be some incredible cap gymnastics by Newcastle if so. Drinkwater was upgraded at Cows and must be on around 500k + Klemmer + Frizell + Ponga + Fitzgibbon + Barnett + Saifitis. And apparently Clifford is coming, who I don't think they signed for peanuts.
Cairnstigers
New member
A few years ago
But not now
May as well play with 16 men
If he could keep the crap out of his game and just do his job in hitting hard then yes
But he is a grub
But not now
May as well play with 16 men
If he could keep the crap out of his game and just do his job in hitting hard then yes
But he is a grub
Cairnstigers
New member
@snake said in [Mbye swap for Josh Mcguire Poll](/post/1332503) said:
And that is it
Mbye is much better value for our club the that bloke
If we could get $500,000 and McGuire then I would consider
Otherwise NO DEAL
earl
Well-known member
Can I say this is one of the worst Ideas I have ever heard.
leonard day
New member
i agree with earlier replies, if we keep buying players who are over the hill, we will keep going backwards, we keep buying players from other clubs who have had injuries and there best years are behind them, but we will pay them big money and sign them for 4 years and wonder why after a year they are injured all the time or are in 2nd grade, this has been happening for the last 10 years, doesnt anyone in the club understand this, all are they all stupid, i would rather put the money into a good young player and put the effort into him and other young players coming thru, then buying a leilua or a tamou, mcguire is suppose to be a good coach, doesnt he know , and he is supposed to be a defencive coach, we are getting 30 or more points scored against us all the time, im a coach, and what he is coaching them might have worked back in 2014, but it doesnt work today, i could do a better job then he is doing, sorry if i rambled on, but im a passionate supporter
Toowoomba_Tiger
Well-known member
I've been his biggest critic and didn't want him anywhere near 1st grade but I must say he's been playing well for a few weeks now in that bench role.
I'm seriously surprised how he has impacted our play...in a positive way.
Hats off to him and I can't believe I'm saying this but he adds to our team and I don't think anyone else is as versatile.
I'd have no problem if they decided to hold onto him, but that price tag burns for a benchie.
I'm with a few others who would like to see him get a run at 7. He could at least match Brooks irrelevance.
He should have no problem finding another club if we flick him. Just gotta take a pay cut.
Back to the point though. I was wrong, he has something to offer😊
I'm seriously surprised how he has impacted our play...in a positive way.
Hats off to him and I can't believe I'm saying this but he adds to our team and I don't think anyone else is as versatile.
I'd have no problem if they decided to hold onto him, but that price tag burns for a benchie.
I'm with a few others who would like to see him get a run at 7. He could at least match Brooks irrelevance.
He should have no problem finding another club if we flick him. Just gotta take a pay cut.
Back to the point though. I was wrong, he has something to offer😊
avocadoontoast
Well-known member
Mbye is a good player. Not worth what he’s on but we looked a LOT better when he came on. We’re a better team with him in it IMO.
