Saw Lone Survivor last night. I was a tad sceptical about how the adaption of the story would translate from the book to film as it is a very raw bones encounter and out come. The story centres upon the failled Operation Red Wings mission of SEAL team 10 in 2005 in remote Afghanistan and as the title suggests, it does not end well. I read both books a while ago and was very moved by thier content. 19 special operations soldiers lost their lives that day and the story focuses upon what happened to the 4 man reconnasaince operation to locate and extinguish a Taliban warlord named Shah. It is very brutal and honest. The firefights are filmed superbly, there is no crappy shakey cam stuff which ruins most action films and mixed with the amazing cinematography, it is a visceral experience. I have worked in this country and as such felt the experience was captured very well.
There is a tendency in American warfilms for the players to become caricatures soaked in jingoism…i.e. be presented as unstoppable machines who are Ramboesque. This always leaves a bad taste for me as I know this is just not the case. These people are human beings and even though they are highly trained and skillful, they can not repell bullets. If they break bones, they are hurt. They get fatigued. The other thing that usually happens is that the enemy is portrayed as incompetent soldiers. Again this is garbage, especially the Afghans, who are skillful fighters in their own right. I think this film stays away from these stereotypes and presents an honest account of this situation as told by the only eye witness.
I dont recommend this film as a date night movie, it is not a "feel good" saga. It is a heartbreaking story but also one that portrays the comaraderie, courage, skill and spirit, of an elite fighting force all contained within a very intense screenplay. The montage at the end is sure to stir feelings of sadness and loss and may well cause most to tear up...I did.
There is some exaggeration and the film does divert from the books somewhat, however it does not ruin the experience. All in all, this is a very tight, moving and horrific film, that pays homage to some of the worlds best fighting men, the sacrifices that are made and the losses that are suffered in war.
It's a solid 8 and one of the best of the genre.