T
Tiger5150
Guest
@Elderslie_Tiger said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/1236753) said:
You can trawl my posts. No hindsight required. Have never been a fan.
Official - Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread
- Thread starter will1999
- Start date
You can trawl my posts. No hindsight required. Have never been a fan.
@Elderslie_Tiger said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/1236753) said:
Exactly right...he was a Bulldogs icon,played state of origin ..he seemed to be just what we wanted,injuries can be cruel,but why dont we bag and belittle someone who did his best for us the best way he could,but didnt suit some forum members who seem to know better than most of us because of their NRL coaching abilities...
T
Tiger5150
Guest
@TrueTiger said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/1236764) said:
Who bagged or belittled him?
pawsandclaws1
Well-known member
@TrueTiger said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/1236764) said:
TT, you accept a large contract, you expect to come under greater scrutiny especially if you do not deliver.
weststigerman
Well-known member
@Geo said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/770339) said:
Page 1 is where the problem started. @Geo said this, and Ivan missed the sarcasm and followed the advice.
innsaneink
Well-known member
I was right
You was wrong
😜😜😜
You was wrong
😜😜😜
T
tigerbalm
Guest
We should have known this was not going to end well. Only 84 pages for a confirmed signing? and JAC is going hard at 90 on innuendo. The writing was on the wall back on page 10.
@weststigerman said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/1236869) said:
In that case
JAC wants $48.50..sign him up
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@weststigerman said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/1236869) said:
Geo is behind virtually every problem behind this club ...there I said it
tig_prmz
Well-known member
@Tiger5150 said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/1236715) said:
I'm not talking about one person, the general consensus was people supported the signing.
We are blaming Cleary and Pascoe. Cleary's is warranted as he left mid-contract and is a dog, but Pascoe like us had the job of supporting his head coach.
Nothing about being right or wrong, it's a discussion not really an arguement.
Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan
Well-known member
I still cringe at how Josh Reynolds' contract negotiations were handled. Apparently the offer was so out of this world that he didn't even think twice. He put pen to paper faster than Ben Creagh ran from Justin Hodges in origin. That's not how you negotiate a contract. Seriously! Ivan Cleary you ...... (use your imagination as to what this word is).
tig_prmz
Well-known member
@Kazoo-Kid said in [Official \- Josh Reynolds Signs Megathread](/post/1237963) said:
Maybe, but still he would've signed for 750K instead of 800 or 720? It doesn't make that big a difference. At the end of the day, it seemed like a good signing and it may have if he stayed on the park. I am sure Bulldogs are thinking thae same with FOran too.
Strider
Well-known member
Doggies fans were gutted when he left. He was a good player in his element, helped Hodko to Origin. Don't think it was the other way. They helped each other. My mate who was a doggies supporter said Reynolds will get the most of Brooks like he did Hodko. Helps the quiet types. Shame.
